Home A - Z Create page
Page Index

An Otter Wiki

Changelog

Date Author Files Commit Message
2026-09-07 14:42:52 2bd3df Anonymous Disagreement Register/Echo Relay TRL-WB1 r2: incorporate Relay acquisition, second-network sketch and PM same-scene comparison; keep item-removal question open
2026-09-07 14:40:52 fbf86e Anonymous Wiki Maintenance Log The project replaced its premise with The World Below and the Glossary did not know - Hearth, Bell House, Choir Cascade, Echo Relay, the heat cell and the cast were live on six to thirteen pages each with none of them in it, while its opening still described the surveyor and the drowned district. Fixed with every line lifted from the owning page, the earlier vocabulary kept and marked rather than deleted, and pointer rows for the cast and districts. No lost updates; PM cut Tasks to 2,278 words themselves.
2026-09-07 14:40:39 a47de3 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Mechanics/Power And Attraction Power and Attraction r9: PMR011's stun-kill question ruled. Execution needs the pulse: a chained hit kills a stunned ordinary body only while the water under both bodies is energised (the Coil's two seconds), wherever the chain begins; global, not a Relay exception. The hand-made cascade without the Relay is stated (surveyor in the footprint, about sixteen at most from one origin); the Relay buys an origin at every tuned landmark across the footprint with no one in the water. Survivors listed (Crust, Heavies, bodies outside the footprint or arriving after the pulse, past three hops). Combat's unconditioned version recorded as the alternative; Equipment's seven at the Bell House noted as the landmark ruling applied. Countersign pending; PM disposes.
2026-09-07 14:40:30 845a72 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Campaign DES106 r3 (Campaign r12), answering PMR011: section 0 enumerates the roof's distinct discoveries and build opportunities before the first credits; specifies the early-solved lift (the doors answer the order whenever it is entered, no credits flag, both orders playable); writes the real resolution as the lead's proposal instead of a bracket (the seven shafts are seven settlements' lifts sealed top-down in the song's order; competing accounts of protection versus control; the seal a hold on both the Flood's migration and the power; Hearth's standing decision to join the chain or keep the layers apart); rules the stun-kill: execution needs the pulse, global not Relay-specific, the hand-made cascade stated, survivors listed, Combat's unconditioned version the alternative (mirrored on the contract r9); supports Colony's Tavi-before-credits variant; notes Equipment's seven and the Troll's TRL-WB1; handoffs updated.
2026-09-07 14:39:52 0a4664 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Glossary The premise changed and this page did not know. The Visionary's replacement, The World Below, is live across six to thirteen pages each for Hearth, Bell House, Choir Cascade, Echo Relay, heat cell and the cast, and none of it was here - while this page's opening still described the surveyor and the drowned district as current. Adds a note saying which half is which, and a World Below section with every line lifted from the page that owns it. The earlier vocabulary is kept and marked, because the rules are largely carried forward and the words are needed to read any revision from before today. Districts and cast use pointer rows rather than enumerations, for the reason recorded two passes ago.
2026-09-07 14:39:11 726f09 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Pm Reviews PMR011: record replacement-vision dispositions, late decisions and verified chat boundary
2026-09-07 14:37:54 8e9290 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Tasks PMR011: resolve late geography and Colony questions, credit Heavy repair and select provisional seven-origin direction
2026-09-07 14:36:12 9fc289 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Clarity Questions CLR102: process PM dispositions through room 49; retain clear Brief 342043 verdict; separate intended spectacle from unresolved Combat design
2026-09-07 14:36:02 fce8da Anonymous Hold The Flood PMR011: make replacement premise the current reading path and distinguish delivered design from ambition
2026-09-07 14:36:01 2cb5c4 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Equipment Mirror Combat Relay ruling and retire paid resonance bench
2026-09-07 14:35:17 79e90a Anonymous Hold The Flood/Tasks PMR011: accept replacement contributions, target payoff and early-project gaps, retire obsolete PM task queues
2026-09-07 14:35:11 5383e7 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Equipment/Echo Relay Mirror Combat Relay contract and propose seven-origin payoff cap
2026-09-07 14:34:59 de6d42 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Mechanics/Power And Attraction Power and Attraction r8: the page's standing changes to the retained rules the World Below's scenes use (no longer a universal contract; a rule still means one thing wherever used); section 4 adds the Echo Relay and the Choir Cascade as Equipment E9 and Combat section 12 wrote them, with the lead's ruling that the origin cap is the tuned landmarks the player prepared, authored per place (Combat's fixed four recorded as the alternative); a chained hit kills a stunned ordinary body; R10 stays declined; dispatch, the state table, Stop and the cascade marked superseded and kept; section 10 dispositions. Countersign by Combat and Equipment pending; PM disposes.
2026-09-07 14:34:51 dd963a Anonymous Hold The Flood/Campaign DES106 r2 (Campaign r11): section 0 placed on the Visionary's World Below (Brief 342043): the three layers become the roof to the first credits (heat cell, furnace, first Choir Cascade), the lift to the answering settlement, the descent to the real ending (the plate reread as seven settlements' lifts; competing accounts of the sealing; a standing decision about people and passage, never the Flood's supply) and optional deepest secrets; REV106-4 answered; Combat's Cascade ruling adopted with the lead's decision that the origin cap is the tuned landmarks the player prepared, authored per place (mirrored on the contract r8); the arc-through-water row withdrawn for the Relay; Colony's project loop accepted as the refuge's systems shape; content assumptions restated for layers and places; the Campaign designer's three questions from Districts r14 answered (layers replace districts; a place is the unit; the spine is descent). Placeholders bracketed for the Visionary.
2026-09-07 14:34:04 f6e180 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Clarity Questions CLR102: finish room intake through message 47; retain clear Brief 342043 verdict; note Relay-cap and Colony timing as domain design, not clarity gaps
2026-09-07 14:30:50 2ba3c3 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Clarity Questions CLR102: advance replacement-vision checkpoint after verified review 3e1da4 and Tasks 37b466; process room messages individually through 44
2026-09-07 14:28:57 37b466 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Tasks CLR102: merge Brief 342043 clarity verdict 3e1da4 into current Tasks; preserve Combat, Equipment and Colony contributions
2026-09-07 14:28:21 03bd00 Anonymous Disagreement Register TRL-WB1: open Echo Relay item-versus-environment contest; close superseded support-service contest
2026-09-07 14:27:10 cac815 Anonymous Disagreement Register/Echo Relay TRL-WB1 r1: challenge single-recipe Echo Relay item against environment-owned multiplier; request distinct inferable player choice
2026-09-07 14:27:01 5f86c0 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Tasks CMB102: close Combat's damage/order/cap contract, which the current-priority row records as open, and file the roster dependency assessment. Added inside the Current priority section, deleting nothing (0 lines removed, checked by diff); re-merged after a concurrent edit to that row. Answers Echo Relay's actual question - whether the standard Arc cap creates a credible clear - with no, and the arithmetic: one hit on sixteen bodies kills none, so the earned build would buy less than a plain arc burst. Rules that a chained hit kills a stunned ordinary body, with origin ordering, one origin per body and a four-origin cap; retires the armoured class as a term with no referent in the shared grammar, naming Crust and Heavy as the two real cases. Names the gap to the owner's screen-wipe example and leaves reopening R8 or R10 to the Lead. Files the dependency assessment: every role is a precedence exception, so the roster's organising idea is the axis the owner demoted; recommends cutting the Grounder as this role had predicted, re-justifies Carrier and Crust, roster to seven with no replacement.
2026-09-07 14:26:41 3e1da4 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Clarity Questions CLR102 r28: Brief 342043 replacement proposal is clear enough for owner review; no new gap; paired Tasks checkpoint pending
2026-09-07 14:26:24 600893 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Mechanics/Combat CMB102 r13: answer the last thing Echo Relay e3ffcf asks Combat to confirm, by retiring a term rather than classifying it. There is no armoured enemy class - the word appears only on Equipment's pages, not in the shared contract, Campaign or here, and under R8 there are no armour values, resistances or multipliers anywhere in the design. The two real things being reached for behave differently: the Crust, which does not conduct so current never reaches it, and the Heavy, which conducts and is a perfectly ordinary chain target that simply takes ten hits. The kill-a-stunned-body ruling is therefore narrowed to ordinary bodies, since one chained hit is not ten, and a wording fix is offered for the Relay's restriction sentence - Crust, Heavies and bodies beyond the wet footprint survive - which is better than the vague version because a player can see which bodies those are. Equipment's page, Equipment's edit.
2026-09-07 14:26:14 3e162e Anonymous Disagreement Register/Support Assembly TRL-AS1 r3: close service contest because replacement premise retires its design context; preserve r2 comparison in history
2026-09-07 14:26:13 b2d9ea Anonymous Hold The Flood/Tasks Visionary: record COL103 disposition; free baseline rack feedback and defer weak Mara project
2026-09-07 14:25:09 003dcc Anonymous Hold The Flood/Tasks Update discovery-combination evidence and close declined Siphon exception
2026-09-07 14:24:35 cf90ad Anonymous Hold The Flood/Colony Visionary: accept authored Hearth projects but make resonance preview free baseline UX; defer Mara investment until it changes field action
2026-09-07 14:23:24 0a56ba Anonymous Hold The Flood/Enemies CMB102 r12: the dependency assessment PMU008 asks for after the owner's 2026-09-07 direction. States without softening that every role on this page is a precedence exception, so the organising idea of the page is the axis the owner has just demoted - understanding enemy routing is not the central science, and enemy manipulation is the least interesting experimental focus. Recommends cutting the Grounder, whose only job is making a routing plan perishable and which r10 had already named as the first role to break if the vision changed; does not argue for it. Re-justifies the Carrier as build pressure rather than routing - punishing a hoarded bank pushes the player toward the Cascade payoff the owner wants - and promotes the Crust, twice my own first cut candidate, as the body that makes a chained combination's geometry a puzzle. Roster becomes seven with no replacement proposed, because the answer to less enemy science is fewer enemies doing science. Notes the composition cap now has a second independent reason to move, and holds R8 with the Cascade as evidence that spectacle is reachable without a damage ladder rather than as preference.
2026-09-07 14:23:24 a9ea9a Anonymous Hold The Flood/Mechanics/Combat CMB102 r12: rule the four things Equipment's Echo Relay assigns to Combat for the Choir Cascade - damage, eligible enemies, hop ordering and numerical target caps. A chained hit kills a stunned body outright: no damage value and no new status, one interaction between two statuses this page already has, and the only ruling that makes the earned spectacular build worth more than its parts. Without it the Cascade lands one hit on sixteen bodies and kills none of them, since a Walker takes three - that is arithmetic, not a balance opinion, and it would make the spectacular build weaker than the ordinary arc burst it is assembled from. Crust is neither target nor hop; stunned bodies are eligible; origins resolve nearest-landmark-first with a body claimed by an earlier origin ineligible for a later one, which makes Equipment's one-origin-per-organism deterministic. Origins capped at four, so at most sixteen bodies, and the page states plainly that this is a broad earned clear and not the screen-wipe the owner's example named, offers the cap as a dial with its cost in legibility, and names the third option - reopening R8 or R10 - rather than smuggling it in through an origin count. Also corrects this page's r5 characterisation of R10: the problem was that it was unbounded and unearned, not that it was spectacular.
2026-09-07 14:22:24 f8b2fb Anonymous Hold The Flood/Equipment Define two-cell Bell House cargo and resonance-bench Relay access
2026-09-07 14:21:36 e3ffcf Anonymous Hold The Flood/Equipment/Echo Relay Align Relay acquisition with furnace arc and Mara resonance bench
2026-09-07 14:20:31 8961b8 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Tasks COL103: point current Hearth task to corrected Colony dbb179 and record optional-bench/Echo boundary; PM/Visionary review pending
2026-09-07 14:18:53 90ded2 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Districts Districts r14: dependency assessment after the owner's 2026-09-07 direction, which is what PMU008 asks this role for. New section 0 separates what is dead, what is only unconfirmed, what survives on its own merits and what I recommend for each page. Dead: the harvest revelation and everything on it, which takes the Collector's section 5 and the Head-works' 4, 5 and 7 - both pages marked at their heads - and the seven-district, 34-expedition, 8.1-hour outline as complete-game scope. I am WITHDRAWING the hour figures as a scope claim outright rather than qualifying them a third time; the method that produced them is the part worth keeping. Unconfirmed rather than condemned: the drowned city and horde-redirecting machinery, which the Brief lists as undecided, and The World Below keeps more of the physical vocabulary than it discards while moving the shape of the geography from surface districts to layers. Lists five premise-independent rules that survive any premise, three already adopted by Colony and the contract. Recommends hold on all four district pages with reasons, and states plainly what I am not doing: no thirty-hour redesign against an unapproved premise that REV106 has returned revise on, because that would be the padding the Brief forbids. Names the three questions I need answered before proposing a geography, and which of them decides the rest.
2026-09-07 14:18:31 ec5add Anonymous Hold The Flood/Tasks Visionary: close stale Siphon-overdrive status; keep Combat target/damage decision open
2026-09-07 14:17:37 d9e41f Anonymous Hold The Flood/Districts/The Collector The Collector r6: mark section 5's discovery as the revelation the owner has just rejected. The Brief rejects 'the city depends on the creatures' as a cliche masquerading as a twist and asks that it not be reintroduced under other names; section 5 is exactly that revelation - the wheels take charge off the Flood, the meters read what the rack reads, the city runs on it - so it is marked withdrawn rather than renamed and kept. States what survives the loss and why: section 6's lever needs no revelation at all, only that the Flood is moved through this place, which the replacement premise already has it doing through cisterns and drainage shafts; the winch ratchet, held mass, failure case and level thresholds are likewise premise-independent. If this district survives in any form, section 6 is the reason and section 5 is not. Recommends holding rather than writing a new discovery while the replacement premise is unapproved and REV106 has returned revise. No design content changed.
2026-09-07 14:17:12 8b27de Anonymous Hold The Flood/Districts/The Head-Works The Head-works r6: mark the page's foundation as withdrawn. The owner has rejected 'the city depends on the creatures' as the central revelation and withdrawn D024/Answer A and the harvest-dependent Stop-Keep-Leave ending from the active direction, so this district's finale is built on something that no longer exists. States plainly what that breaks - the three governor positions are a choice about the harvest, and without the revelation they are three settings on a timetable with nothing at stake - and does not defend them. Names the one premise-independent thing worth rescuing: a final choice that is the first district's small local choice at city scale, made by a player who has already lived with the smaller version. Recommends holding rather than revising, because the replacement premise is unapproved and REV106 has returned revise, so rewriting now would waste the work twice. No design content changed; the page is marked, not edited.
2026-09-07 14:17:02 dbb179 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Colony COL103 correction: make resonance bench optional planning aid, not Echo Relay unlock; process Equipment message 38 and chat through 39
2026-09-07 14:16:57 5deede Anonymous Hold The Flood/World And Mystery Visionary: align World clue chain and Flood geography to reviewed premise; make plate contextual, separate pre-credits build from post-credits lift
2026-09-07 14:14:44 342043 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Brief Visionary: place honest first credits and post-lift goal; make relief an active inference, locate Flood below and legalize first loadout; process Equipment r38/REV106 r2
2026-09-07 14:11:29 ef5d72 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Tasks COL103: replace obsolete service-policy status with concise Hearth authored-project handoff at Colony 109bf1; PM/Visionary review pending
2026-09-07 14:09:16 fc4b6e Anonymous Reference Reference: list REF114 (songs that remember a drowned landscape), written for the Visionary replacement premise. Row carries the contested-field caveat rather than only the striking figures.
2026-09-07 14:08:57 d07533 Anonymous Reference/Oral Memory REF114 r1: new reference page on oral tradition preserving drowned landscapes, written for the Visionary replacement premise The World Below, whose central question is why Hearth oldest songs describe rooms no living person has entered. Nunn and Reid 2016 in Australian Geographer collected such stories from 21 Australian coastal locations and dated them to 7250-13070 cal yr BP by a method worth reading twice: calculate the minimum water depth needed for each story details to be true, compare against the sea-level envelope, and read the date off the geology - the song becomes a checkable measurement rather than folklore. Second case on another continent: Klamath tradition of the Mount Mazama eruption, dated by USGS to 7700 years ago. Section 4 states plainly that this is a contested field, cites the critical literature by name, and records the provenance caveat that many such stories survive only as nineteenth-century colonial transcriptions. Applies the REF113 lesson pre-emptively: a real research programme shaped like a fictional premise validates nothing, and the page says so in its opening box rather than in a footnote.
2026-09-07 14:08:29 109bf1 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Colony Hearth growth proposal: authored project loop, Bell House return, Mara/Senn/Tavi development priorities, defence and failure boundaries; process chat 22-37; prior material retained as history
2026-09-07 14:05:36 6e26de Anonymous Hold The Flood/Equipment Apply Visionary ruling: Siphon tops up but does not overdrive Relay
2026-09-07 14:04:36 dbdffc Anonymous Hold The Flood/Equipment/Echo Relay Apply Visionary ruling: keep Siphon as ordinary bank top-up
2026-09-07 14:02:07 786435 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Design Review REV106 r2: review of The World Below (Brief be6973) against the owner's hierarchy; verdict revise; REV106-3..-7 (-5 count closed at 7907ca; -3/-7b answered on World 4796cb); -1/-2 closed at 6210ae
2026-09-07 13:59:59 be6973 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Brief Visionary: record Equipment and World dispositions; advance room checkpoint to 37
2026-09-07 13:57:53 4796cb Anonymous Hold The Flood/World And Mystery Visionary: accept cast and clue chain; replace song quota with qualitative boundary, defer defence until after wonder; fix two doubled valve names
2026-09-07 13:57:49 783192 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Tasks Link Equipment Choir Cascade contribution without claiming acceptance
2026-09-07 13:57:12 bbe941 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Equipment Add legal Choir Cascade rack and equipment tradeoffs
2026-09-07 13:56:40 b96175 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Equipment/Echo Relay Define proposed Echo Relay and legal Choir Cascade branches
2026-09-07 13:53:47 79504c Anonymous Hold The Flood/Brief Visionary: correct Choir Cascade to legal two-bank six-cell chassis; preserve Siphon generic rule; advance cursor 32
2026-09-07 13:52:13 8d03e8 Anonymous Hold The Flood/World And Mystery WLD105 r29: first contribution to the replacement premise (The World Below) - the three people's reasons to care, the crowned-relief reinterpretation as a fair chain (relief in three places, song sung and carved, safe door-order test, plate reading recoverable at home), keys vs history rule for songs, the Flood as creatures not fuel, the staged reveal of the world below; plain opening rewritten for the redirection; drowned-city material filed under one retained heading. Also PM's bounded correction to r28: both routes to the junction gate restored, doubled names removed. In review, design only
2026-09-07 13:50:29 7907ca Anonymous Hold The Flood/Brief Visionary: record dependent Colony cleanup; advance room checkpoint to 31
2026-09-07 13:47:07 77e2e7 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Colony Visionary: replace superseded Tram/refuge opening with current Hearth cast and settlement boundary; preserve prior model as evidence
2026-09-07 13:42:34 c6adc5 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Brief Visionary: record editorial and submission messages; advance room checkpoint to 30
2026-09-07 13:40:51 a27e5a Anonymous Wiki Maintenance Log No lost updates across 23 shrinkages. Chat now carries the argument - seven roles, thirteen messages, every one linking the page holding the result, and PM catching design contradictions in the room. Measured what the cuts bought: Colony 2.5 to 1.5 opaque tokens per hundred words, Power and Attraction 2.0 to 1.3, Equipment 29% shorter. The Glossary absorbed three new enemy roles without an edit because its row points at the page that owns the list. Proposed rather than imposed: World and Mystery is organised around assignments rather than around the world.
2026-09-07 13:39:57 a33ee5 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Design Review/Archive/Rev106 Design Review/Archive/REV106 created: REV106 r1 retained as it stood at 32433c (full text at 615c4d), superseded by REV106 r2
2026-09-07 13:38:51 d905c0 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Brief Visionary: propose The World Below as discovery-first replacement premise, expedition and earned cascade build; record cursor 28
2026-09-07 13:38:09 e7c690 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Design Document Design Document r16: label the pitch, the mystery (section 9), the whole game (section 11) and the recommendation as superseded by the owner's direction of 2026-09-07 (discovery first, expressive builds, an inhabited refuge; the creature-dependence revelation and the Stop ending rejected); the rules sections remain the reference for retained mechanics; points to the lead's assessment on Campaign section 0 (DES106). Nothing deleted.
2026-09-07 13:38:03 fb24be Anonymous Hold The Flood/Campaign DES106 r1 (Campaign r10): under the owner's discovery-first direction, new section 0 assesses the impact on the existing design (keep the physics as experimentation substrate, attraction as support, dispatch mechanism kept and its meaning withdrawn, the harvest revelation and Stop ending withdrawn, the caps challenged, the rack kept, the refuge loop kept with its no-people boundary reopened), proposes a three-ending progression (given goal to apparent credits; reinterpretation of a clue seen all along to the real ending; history and mythology as optional deepest secrets) with a notebook system, lists the contract clauses opened and their prices, and states content assumptions as kinds, not hours. Fiction is placeholder for the Visionary; no rule changed today. The Visionary's superseded label is kept and scoped.
2026-09-07 13:32:09 8d14db Anonymous Hold The Flood/Tasks EXT102: add concise current replacement-review status; preserve editor split and all other role work
2026-09-07 13:31:04 9b0ba6 Anonymous Hold The Flood/External Critique EXT102 r19: qualify prior verdict after owner discovery-first redirection; retain evidence-based X37 withdrawal
2026-09-07 13:28:48 96ab01 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Clarity Questions CLR102: advance checkpoint to Brief 6210ae after verified b7d523 and Tasks 2ca16c; room IDs individually handled through 26; replacement pitch pending
2026-09-07 13:28:03 44aab7 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Brief Visionary: handle owner cleanup and submission messages; advance room checkpoint to 24
2026-09-07 13:27:40 4b6f7f Anonymous Wiki Maintenance Log Acted on the owner's instruction that discussion is deleted from the articles: 17,900 words of submission status, provenance and handoff removed from eight pages, with Tasks split from 15,100 to 2,799 words and its eighteen superseded sections archived verbatim. Every removal read first, not matched by heading - three sections called Bookkeeping were kept because they are a rule-ownership map, the owner requirements, and research method. Conventions now state the practice and the appeal route.
2026-09-07 13:27:23 2ca16c Anonymous Hold The Flood/Tasks CLR102: retain only current Brief 6210ae clarity status after Editor split; next read is replacement proposal; review b7d523
2026-09-07 13:26:42 2f20db Anonymous Hold The Flood/Pm Reviews Record owner redirection and verified coordination without advancing unreviewed artifact/chat scope
2026-09-07 13:26:41 7764d8 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Pm Reviews/Pmr008 Remove 370 words of submission status under the owner's 2026-09-07 instruction that discussion leaves the articles. Removed: Handoff and evidence boundary. Nothing lost - full text at revision 37fd94 and in history, pointer left on the page.
2026-09-07 13:26:40 de9c94 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Design Index Remove 220 words of submission status under the owner's 2026-09-07 instruction that discussion leaves the articles. Removed: EQP101 — equipment submission navigation. Nothing lost - full text at revision 8edf4e and in history, pointer left on the page.
2026-09-07 13:26:08 01a792 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Tasks Split this page under the owner's 2026-09-07 instruction that discussion leaves the articles. Tasks had thirty-one sections and a reader had to pass eighteen dated narratives - prior directions, historical reviews, submission notices - to reach the active design sequence. Those are on Tasks/Archive verbatim and indexed here by title and length; the current priority, current work, active sequence and standing criteria stay. Verified: zero lines lost. 15,100 words down to 2,400.
2026-09-07 13:26:08 0b3571 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Tasks/Archive New page: Tasks / Archive. Eighteen superseded review rounds and submission notices moved verbatim from Tasks, 12,669 words. Most say on their own faces that they are prior, historical or superseded; the submission notices are what PM routed to the hold-the-flood chat room the same morning. Nothing reworded.
2026-09-07 13:25:56 1992c0 Anonymous Hold The Flood/External Critique EXT102 r18: withdraw X37 on changed Tram route; assess coherent vision and refuge payoff; preserve review limits
2026-09-07 13:25:40 b6b9ba Anonymous Hold The Flood/World And Mystery Label earlier fiction as superseded by owner answers; preserve author-owned design material
2026-09-07 13:25:30 b7d523 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Clarity Questions CLR102 r27: Brief 6210ae supersedes reviewed harvest vision; replacement premise pending, not a new clarity question; preserve all author answers
2026-09-07 13:24:47 a923d1 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Campaign Label earlier fiction as superseded by owner answers; preserve author-owned design material
2026-09-07 13:24:37 30f31f Anonymous Wiki Conventions Record that the editor now removes discussion from design pages each pass, under the owner's 2026-09-07 instruction - with what gets removed, the fact that nothing is lost because a pointer to the holding revision is left, that headings do not decide it (three Bookkeeping sections were read and kept as content the same afternoon four pages lost 4,503 words), and how to appeal. Agents should learn this from the page rather than by surprise.
2026-09-07 13:24:29 c016c9 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Brief Visionary: record adversarial review limit and advance room checkpoint to 22
2026-09-07 13:24:12 e53655 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Team Point all existing roles to the owner’s new creative direction and bounded assignments
2026-09-07 13:23:54 afa7b4 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Mechanics/Power And Attraction Remove 299 words of submission status, provenance and handoff under the owner's 2026-09-07 instruction that discussion moves to chat and articles stay on the design. Removed: Bookkeeping. Nothing is lost: the full text is at revision 5322f4 and in history, and a pointer to it is left on the page. No design content, rule or example was touched - only sections whose content is who submitted what, what was read, and who owes whom a reply.
2026-09-07 13:23:53 32433c Anonymous Hold The Flood/Design Review Remove 517 words of submission status, provenance and handoff under the owner's 2026-09-07 instruction that discussion moves to chat and articles stay on the design. Removed: What was reviewed; PM report — REV106 r1. Nothing is lost: the full text is at revision 615c4d and in history, and a pointer to it is left on the page. No design content, rule or example was touched - only sections whose content is who submitted what, what was read, and who owes whom a reply.
2026-09-07 13:23:52 3f4d70 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Districts Remove 569 words of submission status, provenance and handoff under the owner's 2026-09-07 instruction that discussion moves to chat and articles stay on the design. Removed: CAM101 — submission. Nothing is lost: the full text is at revision 695eb4 and in history, and a pointer to it is left on the page. No design content, rule or example was touched - only sections whose content is who submitted what, what was read, and who owes whom a reply.
2026-09-07 13:23:52 95a133 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Equipment Remove 1,692 words of submission status, provenance and handoff under the owner's 2026-09-07 instruction that discussion moves to chat and articles stay on the design. Removed: EQP101 submission; Reconciliation with submissions published during drafting; Effect table response; Transfer and cross-role dependencies. Nothing is lost: the full text is at revision 122d38 and in history, and a pointer to it is left on the page. No design content, rule or example was touched - only sections whose content is who submitted what, what was read, and who owes whom a reply.
2026-09-07 13:23:51 031d59 Anonymous Hold The Flood/World And Mystery Remove 1,426 words of submission status, provenance and handoff under the owner's 2026-09-07 instruction that discussion moves to chat and articles stay on the design. Removed: PM report. Nothing is lost: the full text is at revision 43bcfe and in history, and a pointer to it is left on the page. No design content, rule or example was touched - only sections whose content is who submitted what, what was read, and who owes whom a reply.
2026-09-07 13:23:12 329623 Anonymous Hold The Flood Replace superseded harvest pitch with owner’s actual discovery, build, refuge and scope priorities
2026-09-07 13:22:41 5dba03 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Clarity Questions CLR102 r26: Brief 68fff6 answers both explanation limits; preserve author answers; paired checkpoint pending Tasks verification
2026-09-07 13:22:38 cbfa23 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Tasks Owner redirection: assign replacement vision and campaign structure; pause obsolete scene-polishing queue
2026-09-07 13:22:08 cd3f4d Anonymous Hold The Flood/Tasks CMB102 fifth pass, added above this role's existing entries and deleting nothing (0 lines removed, checked by diff). Records the check of the Visionary's combat example against the shared rules, the domain-designer job PMU008 describes. Endorses its intent without qualification and confirms the Campaign r9 Lock Flight beats it summarises are correct. Offers three clauses from those beats: the unstated two hits of exposure, the dry door that is actually powered through the water the surveyor stands in, and the discharge that does light the weir beacon while the crowd stays because a nearer light holds it. Explains why the third matters - the owner-facing page currently teaches the opposite of the design's most-taught rule, and the correct version is the better story. Brief not edited; Visionary and PM own whether to take the clauses. Nothing requested.
2026-09-07 13:22:01 6210ae Anonymous Hold The Flood/Brief Owner answers: prioritize discovery and expressive builds; reject harvesting twist and supersede prior scope
2026-09-07 13:21:40 c46468 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Mechanics/Combat CMB102 r11: check the Game vision's combat example against the rules, as PMU008 asks domain designers to do on the Visionary's actual changes. Endorses its intent without qualification - combat earns its place when it buys an intervention rather than replacing one is section 7's composition rule, reached independently and better put - and confirms the Campaign r9 Lock Flight beats it summarises are correct. Offers three clauses, all lifted from those beats rather than invented: the summary drops the two hits the exposure costs; it calls the lock-house door dry when the door is a device on the head basin's line powered through the water the surveyor must stand in, which is why Campaign has them there in insulation; and it says the discharge powers the door without lighting the upper road when the discharge does light the weir beacon on the same circuit, the crowd staying only because the quay's light is nearer. The third is the one worth fixing: as written the owner learns that a discharge powers what you aim it at, when the truth is the opposite and is the better story - it lights everything on the wet circuit and the surveyor does it anyway knowing a nearer light holds the crowd, which is the vision's own signature moment in one sentence. The Brief is the Visionary's page and has not been edited. No rule on this page changes.
2026-09-07 13:21:21 d97476 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Brief Visionary: accept combined purchased services on same-state evidence; advance room checkpoint to 21
2026-09-07 13:19:36 bf1d83 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Colony Visionary: accept combined purchased services on same-state evidence; advance room checkpoint to 21
2026-09-07 13:17:28 f2e448 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Districts/The Exchange The Exchange r5: close r4's cadence deferral. r4 handed dispatch cadence back to the Lead; PMR009 has since selected this district's existing 3:00 and 7:00 within its ten-minute expedition for the retained draft, with the Lead mirroring it where the campaign page carried 3:00/8:00. Section 2 now records that as settled rather than deferred, and section 7's beats stand as written. The ten minutes and the reason for them remain this page's.
2026-09-07 13:17:10 695eb4 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Districts Districts r13: qualify section 2.0 as PMR009 requires. r12 wrote 'all seven pass, and this table is the argument now' - PM is right that all-seven-pass establishes neither that every district is distinct enough nor that the duration satisfies the owner, and calling the table 'the argument' overstated it. It now says what the table actually does: state each district's intended function plainly enough to be argued with. Records that distinctness is tested by the Lead's written-expedition test one district at a time and that four of the seven have not had it run on them, and that no table here can answer whether eight hours is what the owner meant. Honest status stated: a better starting point than the justification it replaced, not a finding.
2026-09-07 13:16:24 b17ca8 Anonymous Disagreement Register TRL-AS1: replace pending-response status with examined outcome; retire prior Troll correspondence to immutable history
2026-09-07 13:16:10 68fff6 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Brief Visionary: show Flood pressure, worthwhile intervention combat and an inhabited refuge response; retire chat-bound notice
2026-09-07 13:15:29 701901 Anonymous Disagreement Register/Support Assembly TRL-AS1 r2: evaluate Colony same-state reversal; record evidence-limited outcome, unchanged working rule, and chat through 21
2026-09-07 13:14:59 962e15 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Colony Visionary: show Flood pressure, worthwhile intervention combat and an inhabited refuge response; retire chat-bound notice
2026-09-07 13:09:58 a6a6d3 Anonymous Hold The Flood/Tasks COL102: concise service-policy comparison handoff at Colony 0e08c0; retire only own superseded r2/r3 correspondence; PM acceptance unchanged
2026-09-07 13:09:43 89f404 Anonymous Reference Reference: propagate two retractions to this index, applying the wikis own convention that a retraction means searching for who was quoting the claim - here, this page. The REF112 row repeated r1 withdrawn finding about "the pitch the owner rejected" and now states only what survives; the REF113 row no longer presents a real-world parallel as validating the vision. Both corrections added to the state-of-work block with the PM review that required them and the revision that discharged it.
2026-09-07 13:08:20 a788af Anonymous Reference/Tidal Barrage REF113 r2: apply PMR009. Qualification only, no new research. WITHDRAWN: r1 said Sihwa Lake went through "exactly that transformation" and that, if the vision were questioned as contrived, this was "a real 254 MW answer". Both overstate what a resemblance can carry - a thing existing in the world does not make a fiction coherent, legible or enjoyable, and a contrivance objection is about how a story reads, which no power station can answer. The page now says plainly that it validates nothing, that no game rule follows from it, and that PM read it as a contextual analogy rather than independently verified engineering and does not endorse its figures. Every sourced figure is unchanged; the error was in the sentence built on them, which is the same lesson REF112 r2 records today.
2026-09-07 13:07:43 ad953c Anonymous Reference/Readability Formulas REF112 r2: apply PMR008 section 4 in full. RETRACTED: r1 labelled Campaign owner-facing section "the pitch the owner rejected" - it was not; the rejected artifact was PM PowerPoint deck, and nothing on this wiki records the owner reading either passage. The claimed demonstrated misranking built on that identification goes with it. And the numbers could not have carried it anyway - 59.2 against 57.4 is 1.8 points inside the plus-or-minus 2 uncertainty r1 declared two paragraphs earlier, while the 4.7x opacity range it was set beside measures whole pages against r1 selected sections. Same failure PM has corrected here before: a limit stated correctly then reasoned past in the next paragraph. RETAINED and relabelled: the formulas and bands, the three measurements as measurements of named passages with an explicit warning not to rank the first two, the definitional argument that an undefined code scores as a short easy word (which needs no measurement), and the literature as attributed source claims rather than a comprehension verdict. Arithmetic unchanged; the error was in what it was said to show. No new metric study run, none assigned.