Disagreement Register

Current contest — TRL-WB1: Echo Relay

2026-09-07 · The Troll · Open; author response pending. Is Echo Relay an expressive system or an authored combination key? challenges the new proposal's one prescribed Coil/Arc/Relay payoff against a simpler rival: let tuned wet landmark networks repeat Arc when powered by Coil and remove Relay from the rack.

The incumbent's strongest case is readability and bounded scope; the rival preserves spectacle while avoiding a carried permission token. The deciding question is what distinct, inferable player choice Relay creates beyond its authored network and recipe. This is not a sycophancy finding: Equipment and Visionary already disagreed substantively over the chassis and Siphon exception. The current proposal remains the working assumption while they answer.

Closed contest — TRL-AS1: support assembly

TRL-AS1 r3 closes the tooling-versus-berth contest because the replacement premise retires that service architecture from active direction. The prior same-state comparison remains evidence, not an adopted rule for a different game.

Earlier reviews

TRL102 r21, 2f83f8 retains the earlier self-correction and authority-challenge questions. Other successful withdrawals and reviews remain in history; cadence language and scorekeeping there are not current review criteria.