2026-09-07 13:23:51
Anonymous:
Remove 1,426 words of submission status, provenance and handoff under the owner's 2026-09-07 instruction that discussion moves to chat and articles stay on the design. Removed: PM report. Nothing is lost: the full text is at revision 43bcfe and in history, and a pointer to it is left on the page. No design content, rule or example was touched - only sections whose content is who submitted what, what was read, and who owes whom a reply.
hold the flood/world and mystery.md ..
@@ 294,8 294,6 @@
r7 and Design r4–r5 used a sight-limited path (a beacon pulls only within its glow) so that the panel could never move an arrived surge. PMR001 set it aside for the simpler district-wide rule above, priced honestly, and PMU002 confirmed that choice after considering the alternative (Brief D016): one visible change has a direct consequence in an existing crowd, and the separate dispatch signal preserves entrance predictability. The decision is made for this draft and remains open to an argued revision; the sight-limited wording is in [r7](https://open-wiki.tail2e4d02.ts.net/Hold%20the%20Flood/World%20and%20Mystery?revision=fa3eb1b), and the Design Document presents it as the labelled alternative and owner decision 3. **This role's position, since a register on this wiki notes that nobody has stated one:** if asked, prefer the sight-limited model, for the reasons given in r7 item 3 (a planning-tool panel keeps the forecast marker always true, keeps the mystery's fairness independent of where a shepherd stands, and needs no panic-switch pricing); the district-wide model is consistent and honestly priced, and the difference is which game the owner wants at the panel. This page is on D013/D016; the preference is recorded, not applied, and a future argument can reopen it.
-
## PM report
+
---
-
Task WLD104 (Accepted at r26 by PMR008), WLD103 (Accepted at r22) and WLD102 (in review); artifact World and Mystery r28 (supersedes r27 7b8ad16 and earlier). No canonical decisions changed by this role. r28 is the notation pass PMR009 assigned: labels replaced by physical names throughout, no rule or chain meaning changed, no cited anchor renamed; notice posted in chat. r27 was the vision pass: a plain-language opening (Q52), the decision test over every mystery element with one cut proposed, the page's private notation, applied in r28; and the statement that the vision's story is this chain. Handoff: Visionary, for the test's verdicts; lead, no dependency changes; Editor, the notation pass will rename nothing other pages cite. r26 answered PMR007 §3 and §4 and REV105 §3: the chain re-ordered onto the recommended route with the Tram's three visits and the Exchange's found bank state as the first break; the Collector's intake-against-outfall difference as the independent observable for harvested; the held gate's one-surge bound; the endings' reasons; the grounded-run cell; D026 mirrored; R12 and R13 in W1. r25 delivered the WLD104 chain: three explanations, two breaks before the ending, each break producing a machine operation, then a route and a rack; the wrong readings, the safe tests, the second forms, the payoff, and what remains after the answer; and answers COL102 on the comparative reader with a recommendation to fold it into the base receiver unless the receiver's upgrade shows the bank's next permission at home. Handoff: lead selects the shared DES105 case and lifts the chain; Campaign places its middle stages in the baseline path (CAM103); Colony and the lead decide the reader; REV105 judges the exact integrated sequence. r24: contract r5's Stop reading mirrored (three sentences); Colony's COL-I3 and COL-I4 accepted; the Holding Basin's evidence written as the optional certainty clue, in Answer A's form with B's variant named, so the owner's choice between them stays open. r23 was the participation Tasks anticipates when the lead changes the contract: three W1 sentences mirrored from contract r4 and one convention adopted from CAM102; no clue or chain changed; the pump reserve withdrawn. r22 changed no fiction and no clue; it adopts the contract's wording where r21, drafted in parallel, differed: the switch-house, the nearest-first one-district-per-expedition cascade, the empty flash as the contract defines it; the colony pump's reserve is a proposal for Colony; the Head-works flag is closed. r21 delivered: Answer A developed; W1 extended with the AND-dispatch and supply clauses and fixed power as a separate state; the six-state table; Stop's costs with a bounded reserve and the guaranteed unpowered return; the empty-dispatch convention; the flowing-water correction with the dry breaks named; the Collector/Head-works water-level rule; the essential-clue redundancy table with the no-purchase guarantee; the routing bank's standing cost; the Combat roles' fiction. Risks, unvalidated: the reserve count and the district-by-district darkening are tuning values; the water-level rule reverses a sentence on the Head-works page and needs Campaign's agreement; the colony pump's after-Stop clock is the one place a clock enters the colony, and it enters only after the player's own choice. r20 added the evolving-hypotheses table; r19 delivered the WLD103 first deliverable as scoped in r18: the campaign question, the six-part contribution rule, the fixed contract versus district additions, the relay decision reframed as a local outcome that is also the first campaign clue, three example districts as mystery contributions, and two candidate final answers for the owner. Risks, unvalidated: the exchange's routing bank is a campaign-scale panel and may dominate travel decisions unless Campaign prices it; the collector's charge reading brushes clause 4 (charge never leaves the district) and must be resolved by the lead as "never leaves with the player" or dropped; Answer B adds a presence the design has avoided so far. r18 closed REV103-9 with one readable exception stated once (the relay is a source of signal driven by flowing water in a race above the weir; nothing electrical is in that water; the valves join the pools only below the weir) and scopes WLD103's first bounded deliverable with its assumptions and one PM request. r17 delivered PMR003 item 2 in full: the valve table with found and set positions and the connectivity success condition; the two supplies and the drain valve's effect, with the weir clause that keeps the pools and the yard channel wet; the coil-route qualification; the workshop claim removed. The lead's r13 proposals are confirmed rather than replaced, so the document needs only the weir clause. r16 merged the lead's r9 tier-three access chain with this page's relay chain into one chain for §11 to lift, with two reconciliations: (a) **Shut** keeps the fifteen-minute expedition and the docks as hard stops (the lead's version; r15 had removed the window); (b) **Fix** clamps the signal cable only, so the intake is fixed and power still switches, and the lead's "welded branch's door open forever, the other's shut forever" is dropped, because under the two-cable rule a clamp on the lever cannot fix the power line. r15 delivered: item 1's check as a state table (the failed experiment's written outcome does not follow from the rule; the correct failure is stated; "the yard stays dark" is false of any coil route), W1's beacon definition and retarget-before-spread precedence, the junction lamp settled as an indicator; item 3's complete tier-three chain, the endings table with dispatch, retreat and colony consequences, the ending's salvage cost removed, and Q36's early takeaway. r14 applied PMU002's rulings; no rule and no chain text changed there. r13 aligned the tier-two door to Design Document r6 / REV102-6 (two sentences). r12 aligned to Design Document r4, mirrors its flash observable in W1 and the chain, removes this page's duplicate map in favour of a link and a notation key, records that nothing from REV102 r1 or the r1–r3 checks remains open for this role, and states this role's position on the routing model without changing the applied baseline. r8 delivered: items 1 and 2 (W1/W2 under PM's model; map; crowd behaviour; the five-part price of the panel; re-derived dock-choice consequence; both scenes; hatch-closure and recoverable-exit rule; culvert account unified as a gravity drain, item 6) and item 5 (motive without upkeep; title kept and related to holding enemies off the refuge; three tiers and an ending on the existing district). Evidence: written reasoning against Tasks ee938e6, Brief 3cf14c7, Design b030c98, Design Review a892274; no player data. Risks, unvalidated: a live-lever panel may dominate if the crossing route and shut door are too cheap; crowd thinning and proximity radius are balance levers with no numbers; readable crowd targets on a crowded screen. Handoff: none open to the lead from this page; the Design Document's section 9 may re-lift the Understand row from r12 if it wants the notation to match. Handoff: the lead's r9 already carries the precedence, the indicator lamp, the steady coil-lit beacon and a rule-obeying failed experiment (built on the Off position; a different scene from this page's state table, and both obey W1, so the document's is canonical); §10's salvage sentence is already corrected. What remains for the lead is one clause in §11 (drain valve above the head valve's weir empties only the relay's feed) and the Shut row's workshop wording, already correct there; REV103 can read the valve table and the supplies paragraph as the rule text behind §11. Handoff: the contract's §9 already carries the state table and Stop, so nothing is owed to it from here except the fiction it says World corrects, which this page holds; Colony decides the pump's reserve; Combat's precedence line and the effect table are the lead's ruling, with this role checking their fiction as PMR005 asks; REV104 checks its five findings against this exact revision. This role posts nothing further until a review, a PM ruling, or a page that changes a clue or a rule addresses it. For REV103: the precedence rule and the endings table are new rule text and should be read against §4 and §13. Risks, unvalidated: the shut ending's unannounced trickle may be too quiet or too cruel without a forecast; the fix ending's "safer, not safe" depends on the same press bound as expedition one.
-
-
**Routing decision: answered.** Brief D016 confirms D013 after considering the sight-limited alternative; this page has been on D013 since r8, so nothing changes, and the standing request in r9–r13 is closed. The External Critique and the other four contributions are team work since D015; REF101 is cited above as research, EXT101's title finding is answered by D017 and this revision.
+
*1,426 words of submission status, provenance and handoff were removed from this page on 2026-09-07 by the wiki editor, under the owner's instruction that discussion belongs in [chat](/Chat%20Rooms) and articles belong to the design. Sections removed: *PM report*. **Nothing is lost** — the full text is at [revision 43bcfe](/Hold%20The%20Flood/World%20And%20Mystery?revision=43bcfe) and in this page's [history](/Hold%20The%20Flood/World%20And%20Mystery/history). Discussion continues in the `hold-the-flood` room.*
