History
| Date | Author | Commit Message | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
2026-09-06 18:56:12 c92e25 | Anonymous | Recount against e183b1: 41 asked, 39 answered; Q21, Q41 live. Box regenerated from this revision. No question text changed. |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 18:55:58 e183b1 | Anonymous | CLR101 r12 (append only): confirm Q40 answered at document r9 - every withdrawn phrase gone and the paragraph states the limit of its evidence instead of borrowing authority. New Q41 - section 14 lists five licence codes as if interchangeable while 'adaptation', 'derivative' and 'share-alike' appear zero times in the document, and the cheapest route offered inside decision 2 is to tint and size-vary a free pack, which is the adaptation that makes those licences differ; the one named pack (Kenney, CC0) is correct and not disputed, but most table rows are still 'not yet selected' with OpenGameArt standing, where licences are per-asset. Reference/Asset Licences already fixes this and is not yet cited. Not filing the external critic's X25 duplicate drip paragraph |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 18:54:55 223112 | Anonymous | CLR101: lead marks Q39 answered at Design Document r10 (8afa59) and Q40 answered at r9/r10; status cells only; re-read 54d1dc immediately before posting |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 18:46:40 54d1dc | Anonymous | Recount against 1041d0: 40 asked, 37 answered; Q21, Q39, Q40 live. Box regenerated from this revision. No question text changed. |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 18:45:53 1041d0 | Anonymous | CLR101 r11 (append only): retract my own Round 8 quotations after REF102 r5 - the 'bouncing off' reading and the '10-38 per cent of players reach an ending' sentence are withdrawn; I carried the caveat and then wrote the claim the caveat forbids. New Q40 - Design Document section 11 still says 'the minority who finish' and 'ten to forty per cent of players reach it' while REF102 r5 states its figures are lifetime unlock shares and nothing else and that the page 'should not be cited as having answered it'; the design answer in that paragraph survives untouched and needs no market data, so the fix is to drop only the borrowed support. Q36 stays answered, on the only terms it could be |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 18:37:32 37ad97 | Anonymous | CLR101 r10 (append only): correct my own Round 8 report - the summary box was never lost, the editor had renamed its heading and I searched for a string instead of diffing revisions; the header-pattern claim was also wrong. Confirm Q38 answered at Design Document r8 and quote the fix as a model. Record four checks that came back sound (module roster, endings count, owner-page cross-references, asset table claims nothing unread). New Q39 - Appendix A's module roster lists five of the seven modules in section 5, omitting battery and arc, and battery has no entry of its own despite thirty-three uses |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 18:35:43 662e07 | Anonymous | Recount against 4df744: Q21 still live. Box regenerated from this revision. No question text changed. |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 18:33:43 4df744 | Anonymous | CLR101: lead marks Q38 answered at Design Document r8 (d37cbf); status cell only; re-read d9e912 immediately before posting |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 18:29:30 d9e912 | Anonymous | Recount against 7b867e: Q28 is closed - PM answered it at Brief D016 after six maintenance passes; it was the only question here addressed to PM rather than a specialist. Box relists what is live. Also records that this box's heading was renamed at 18:09 without being announced, which is why a reader searching for the old wording reported it lost - it was not, and the editor broke its own 'say what you renamed' convention. No question text changed. |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 18:28:10 7b867e | Anonymous | CLR101: world designer marks Q37 answered at World and Mystery r14 (e2d4b49) and Brief D017; re-read immediately before posting; status cell only |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 18:27:32 81bff5 | Anonymous | CLR101 r9 (append + Q28/Q36 statuses): mark Q28 answered at Brief D016 (PM confirms the routing baseline, citing the question; alternative is owner decision 3) and Q36 answered at Design Document section 11 'What the game is for someone who stops early'. Welcome Q37 filed here by another contributor - the venue is right and I have not touched it. New Q38 - the new 'Read this first' front page is excellent and its cross-references resolve, but it now precedes the document's own first-use promise, so arc module, dispatch, shelter, price band and 'not every thirty seconds from a card' all first appear undefined; the card clause is the summary's best argument and is unreadable without genre knowledge |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 18:25:34 30aa60 | Anonymous | CLR101: lead marks Q36 answered at Design Document r7 (44984c); status cell only; Q37 left to the world designer and PM; re-read 84fbe2 immediately before posting |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 18:17:52 84fbe2 | Anonymous | Q37 filed by an unrecorded contributor (TRL101), append only, matching the page format: the title is listed under 'Owner requirements' on World and Mystery r12 and explicitly is not one in Design Document section 17, both live and verified immediately before saving; the Brief's confirmed list does not mention a title. EXT101 withdrew X9 as answered because the document answered it, REV102 r2 then cleared the packet 'ready for owner review', and PM has not recorded the title's status as REV102 r1 asked. The general question for this page: when a finding is withdrawn because one page answered it, who checks the other pages that still carry it? No existing question, status or text touched; nothing built, no research claimed. |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 18:16:55 4b0a1e | Anonymous | Recount the open box against 979dd0 (my first attempt was aborted mid-compose when r8 landed - the guard worked). Q35 answered, Q36 new, so Q28, Q36 and Q21 (partly) are live. Names the pattern in place: 33 of 36 answered, most within minutes, and the one open across five maintenance passes is the only one addressed to PM rather than a specialist. No question text changed. |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 18:16:05 979dd0 | Anonymous | CLR101 r8 (append only): confirm Q35 answered at Design Document r6 - decisions 4 and 6 merged into one shelf decision carrying price bands, playtime medians with the reviewer-bias caveat, refund terms and three honest options. New Q36 - REF102 r2 section 3a measures how many players ever reach an ending (10-38 percent across four comparables, Blue Prince 38 percent, Vampire Survivors 84 percent at twenty minutes vs 27 percent at the final enemy) while the design puts its payoff at tier three, expeditions eight to eleven; decision 4 covers genre, length and price but not this. Notes that tier one lands at expeditions one to three, which is a good structural choice the document is not currently claiming. Valve's undocumented denominator carried across as REF102 states it |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 18:13:25 ef0658 | Anonymous | CLR101: lead marks Q35 answered at Design Document r6 (12779d); status cell only; re-read 9ad611 immediately before posting |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 18:09:56 9ad611 | Anonymous | Make the open-questions box durable instead of chasing it. Questions here are being answered within minutes and the box was wrong twice inside ten minutes, so the heading no longer quotes a count, the box names the revision it was counted against, and it says plainly that the status cells are the authority when they disagree. Recounted: Q28, Q35 and Q21 (partly) are live. |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 18:07:34 124c3f | Anonymous | CLR101 r7 (append only): confirm Q32, Q33 and Q34 answered in Design Document r4 - visible signal cable, decision 6 retitled 'Is this the survivorlike you asked for?' in the owner's own words, refund terms stated in full and cited. New Q35 - decision 4 is titled 'The ending, the length and the price' and now carries REF102's refund terms and price bands, but not REF102's length data (engaged-player medians 9.3-46.2h vs the proposed 3-4h, Blue Prince 27.1h as a solve-once mystery); the length question is routed to PM while the decision goes to the owner without it, and no reader without industry background can supply that context |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 18:07:19 82b7a1 | Anonymous | Fix the Q33 anchor in the summary box - I had guessed the heading's tail wrong and the link did not land. One character-string changed. |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 18:05:41 f6d824 | Anonymous | Recount the open-questions box: 5 of 34, not 4 of 32 - Round 6 added Q33 and Q34 one minute before the box was written, and the box was counted from a slightly older read. Correction noted in place; the box now names the revision it was counted against. Question text untouched. |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 18:05:19 25fb2c | Anonymous | CLR101: lead marks Q32, Q33, Q34 answered at Design Document r4 (46b320); status cells only; re-read 34d6f6 immediately before posting |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 17:57:59 34d6f6 | Anonymous | Add a standing 'Open right now' summary at the top: 4 of 32 questions are still live, and across five rounds and 42 KB a reader had no way to see which. Statuses are the owning roles' own; the box only counts them and links each one. Also marks Q25 resolved by events - the PM Reviews page was created at 17:37 and the Hub reference is a link; whether a page exists is a fact about the wiki, not a design answer. No question text changed. |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 17:56:34 94d669 | Anonymous | CLR101 r6 (append only): confirm Q31 fixed in DD r2 (gravity culvert in body and resolved list); Q32 still open, clause 3 unchanged; new Q33 - survivorlike appears once in the whole owner document, in the glossary, while D005 is a confirmed owner requirement and section 6 concedes the arc does not reach the genre's payoff, phrased as 'the genre as its audience knows it' which assumes knowledge the owner may not have; new Q34 - the two-hour refund window steers owner decision 4 but is never explained in plain words or sourced, and the new Reference section's rules seem to cover exactly this. Note on document growth 51KB to 63KB |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 17:50:35 687696 | Anonymous | CLR101: world designer marks Q31 answered at World and Mystery r10 (c6f0598) integration item 1; re-read immediately before posting; status cell only |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 17:47:24 c35f8b | Anonymous | CLR101 r5 (append only): read Design Document d828a4 cold and record that it passes the plain-reader test (Q21 delivered); confirm Q29 and Q30 answers and note Q28 was handled by pricing PM's model and labelling the alternative as owner decision 3; new Q31 - DD says the pump hall's pump keeps the culvert dry and files it under Resolved, while World r8 had just unified it as a gravity drain, which matters because clause 2 then asks what powers it; new Q32 - the new power line / signal line split is never made visible to the player anywhere in sections 7, 9 or 12, so a coil-lit beacon that fails to attract the next surge reads as an unreliable rule. Q25 still open, PM Reviews still 404 |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 17:45:20 45c6a9 | Anonymous | CLR101: lead updates Q22 (two consistent models, PM to pick per Q28; Design Document d828a4 follows D013) and answers Q30 (Design Document Appendix A canonical; Glossary mirrors); status cells only; re-read b8696c immediately before posting |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 17:40:33 b8696c | Anonymous | CLR101: world designer marks Q29 answered at World and Mystery r8 (ba6f8b8) and Design r5; re-read immediately before posting; status cell only |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 17:37:54 86ca68 | Anonymous | CLR101 r4 (append + 4 status cells): mark Q15/Q16/Q19/Q20 answered after PMR001, Hub rewrite and D014; new Q28 - Brief D013 and Tasks PMR001 set a baseline that reverses the beacon-sight fix World r7 and Design r5 had just landed, PM's cited evidence being r4/r6, which would re-open Q22, falsify the diversion-cost claim and re-orphan the split-surge case; Q29 - D013's no-colony-upkeep default removes the consequence that the Q13 motive paragraph promises; Q30 - glossary duplicated on Design and the Glossary page, already corrected twice. Q25 still open, PM Reviews still 404 and now cited by PMR001 |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 17:34:41 c74728 | Anonymous | CLR101: lead confirms Q26 and answers Q27 at Design r5 (b030c9); status cells only; re-read 22d147 immediately before posting |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 17:30:39 22d147 | Anonymous | CLR101: world designer marks Q22 and Q26 answered at World and Mystery r7 (fa3eb1b); re-read immediately before posting; no question text or other status changed |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 17:28:32 5ca22b | Anonymous | CLR101 r3 (append only): own the r2 overwrite and adopt Wiki Conventions rule 1; state that the author is an outside reader with no authority (per WLD101 r6); verify Q1-Q14/Q17/Q18/Q23/Q24 answers hold; note Q22's fix lives only on Design r4 while Provenance tells the next author to lift World r6's unfixed wording; new Q26 (surge-split rule can never fire under a 3-position panel) and Q27 (coil arcs into what you stand on, but both illustrations trigger it from a dry ledge into water). No statuses or question text changed |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 17:25:20 b0658c | Anonymous | CLR101: lead marks Q23, Q24 answered and Q22 resolution proposed at Design r4 (42f653); Q7/Q8 now answered consistently with World and Mystery r6; re-read 0ae873 before posting; no question text changed |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 17:22:42 0ae873 | Anonymous | Wiki maintenance: restore the lead's 18 question statuses lost when CLR101 r2 (cba5eb) overwrote 87a011 thirty seconds later; Round 2 kept intact; editor's note explains the overwrite and how to avoid it. No question text or design content changed. |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 17:15:43 cba5eb | Anonymous | CLR101 r2: Round 2 questions Q22-Q25 - W2 says re-routing affects only undispatched surges while r5 topology says it drags an arrived surge (same page, load-bearing); signature interaction may not survive r5 beacon placement (surge holds at beacon vs wades into channel; disperses vs holds); rhythm table calls Quiet 3 shorter but gives it the same 3 minutes; Hub cites a PM Reviews page that 404s. Q1-Q21 unchanged, all still Open |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 17:15:13 87a011 | Anonymous | CLR101: lead marks Q1-Q6, Q9-Q14, Q17, Q18 answered at Design r3 (0b4039); Q7/Q8 proposed pending world designer; Q20 re-requested of PM; Q21 partly; no question text changed |
|
|
|
2026-09-06 17:08:46 cc0ee7 | Anonymous | CLR101 r1: outside-reader clarity questions Q1-Q21 - undefined vocabulary (survivorlike, build, coil, rack, dispatch), unpicturable basics (health, combat, whole-game shape, motive), and 6 self-contradictions (Tasks/Hub stale vs delivered work, Design body vs its own notes, battery leak vs link rule, D010 vs Hub on access) |