Blame

5e70e5 Anonymous 2026-09-07 17:27:09
Owner confirmed Hold The Horde; retain URLs and link PM restart setup
1
# Hold The Horde — Owner Brief
7d0069 Anonymous 2026-09-06 15:15:55
PM: record confirmed instructions and unresolved game brief
2
3cba6b Anonymous 2026-09-07 16:48:01
Restart cleanup: retain owner requirements and reusable guidance; remove obsolete commentary
3
## Premise
50b4bb Anonymous 2026-09-07 11:01:03
PMU008: record owner rejection of pitch and authorize vision-led design revision
4
3cba6b Anonymous 2026-09-07 16:48:01
Restart cleanup: retain owner requirements and reusable guidance; remove obsolete commentary
5
You are an astronaut whose broken ship forces an emergency landing at the nearest space station. The station is unofficial. Its emergency signal says **“stay away!”**, and it refuses to answer your hails. You have no choice but to dock.
6210ae Anonymous 2026-09-07 13:22:01
Owner answers: prioritize discovery and expressive builds; reject harvesting twist and supersede prior scope
6
3cba6b Anonymous 2026-09-07 16:48:01
Restart cleanup: retain owner requirements and reusable guidance; remove obsolete commentary
7
1. **Oxygen limits exploration.** The station’s artificial atmosphere is broken. Away from your ship, you carry a limited supply of oxygen and can find additional canisters. The ship can produce unlimited oxygen, but your carrying capacity is limited. Running out kills you.
8
2. **The station is hostile.** Zombies and other strange creatures attack on sight. Taking enough damage kills you. “The Flood” means massed enemies.
9
3. **Death is not the end.** You wake up aboard your ship after dying. The explanation is hidden somewhere in the station.
10
4. **Survivors become your colony.** You can send rescued humans to your ship, where a small community grows.
11
5. **The station holds mysteries.** Puzzles, traps, mechanisms and at least two alien languages offer clues to what happened, why you revive and how you can leave. Survivors can help you understand what you find.
51e58b Anonymous 2026-09-07 15:07:04
Owner correction: reject coded-song premise and require convincing survivorlike identity without literal-flood assumption
12
3cba6b Anonymous 2026-09-07 16:48:01
Restart cleanup: retain owner requirements and reusable guidance; remove obsolete commentary
13
## Intended experience
51e58b Anonymous 2026-09-07 15:07:04
Owner correction: reject coded-song premise and require convincing survivorlike identity without literal-flood assumption
14
3cba6b Anonymous 2026-09-07 16:48:01
Restart cleanup: retain owner requirements and reusable guidance; remove obsolete commentary
15
A survivorlike focused on exploration, experimentation and mystery. The owner’s priorities are **“I discovered something incredible,”** followed by **“I made a ridiculous build work.”** Fighting hordes and developing powerful combinations must be meaningful parts of the game.
51e58b Anonymous 2026-09-07 15:07:04
Owner correction: reject coded-song premise and require convincing survivorlike identity without literal-flood assumption
16
3cba6b Anonymous 2026-09-07 16:48:01
Restart cleanup: retain owner requirements and reusable guidance; remove obsolete commentary
17
Discoveries can reveal a larger world, change the meaning of something already seen, or expose history while the player searches for power. Deep secrets and personal note-taking are welcome. Revisits should offer a changed environment, enemies, understanding or ability to interact.
51e58b Anonymous 2026-09-07 15:07:04
Owner correction: reject coded-song premise and require convincing survivorlike identity without literal-flood assumption
18
3cba6b Anonymous 2026-09-07 16:48:01
Restart cleanup: retain owner requirements and reusable guidance; remove obsolete commentary
19
Equipment competing with salvage for inventory space is a desired tradeoff. Enemy manipulation can be useful, but should not be the main subject of experimentation.
e2e390 Anonymous 2026-09-07 15:18:53
Vision: establish portable survivorlike build foundation
20
3cba6b Anonymous 2026-09-07 16:48:01
Restart cleanup: retain owner requirements and reusable guidance; remove obsolete commentary
21
The shipboard colony should grow into a home: an authored, non-procedural cast the player knows, helps and cares about. It provides upgrades and an emotional reason to explore and defend people. Its exact management systems remain undecided.
e2e390 Anonymous 2026-09-07 15:18:53
Vision: establish portable survivorlike build foundation
22
3cba6b Anonymous 2026-09-07 16:48:01
Restart cleanup: retain owner requirements and reusable guidance; remove obsolete commentary
23
The player needs clear immediate goals and understandable controls and survival information. Mystery must not depend on bad UX. Encoded songs are rejected. The former city-depends-on-creatures twist is rejected.
e2e390 Anonymous 2026-09-07 15:18:53
Vision: establish portable survivorlike build foundation
24
cc7abf Anonymous 2026-09-07 20:50:26
Owner decision: pause the rest of the game while the journal is open
25
**Journal pause — owner decision, 2026-09-07:** while the journal screen is open, the rest of the game pauses, including enemies and oxygen consumption, even during combat. The journal's detailed design remains open; see [Oxygen and Observation](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Oxygen%20and%20Observation) for the current proposal.
26
a6f303 Anonymous 2026-09-08 10:36:14
Record owner choice of mostly automatic fire and manual specials
27
**Firing controls — owner decision, 2026-09-08:** ordinary combat uses mostly automatic firing, with manually activated special abilities. Target-selection details, optional aiming assistance or overrides, input bindings and particular equipment exceptions remain to be designed.
28
389357 Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:06:35
Record owner additions feedback and replace death-cache direction
29
## Owner reactions to the proposed additions — 2026-09-08
30
31
- **Keep connected equipment combinations.** The owner accepted assembling builds from reusable linked parts. Particular parts, numerical rules and the complete equipment catalogue remain proposals.
32
- **Keep shared carrying space.** Spare oxygen competes with equipment and loot for carrying capacity.
33
- **Bring carried property home on death.** The owner rejected recovery caches: “let's bring home what we carry when we die. otherwise it's just frustrating.” Carried equipment and newly acquired loot return aboard with the astronaut; recovering a death cache is not part of the design.
34
- **Keep practical clue-based exploration.** Repeated markings can suggest an opportunity to investigate, with observation and survivor context helping interpretation.
35
- **Keep the proposed horde rhythm.** Hordes contest travel and selected noisy work; completed work persists and an overpowering build may succeed.
36
- **Tentatively keep equipment loans at home.** The owner's response was “keep. I think.” This is a tentative preference for the described cooperation, not approval of a complete colony-management system.
37
92c102 Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:55:29
Owner chooses shifting station and short rescues; records revisable hospital and captive-god draft
38
- **The station shifts after each death.** The owner wants the mystery of what is where to stay alive. Some changes the player makes persist through shifts; a door they unlocked can remain unlocked. This supersedes the team's fixed-layout proposal. Which features move, which changes persist and how prior records help remain to be designed.
791d89 Anonymous 2026-09-15 19:18:16
Integrate reviewed decision guide and verified current-reference repairs
39
- **Selected connections persist, with a station-wide late puzzle.** From [the three shift proposals](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Shifting%20Station%20Options?revision=71a1fb), the owner chose Option 3: certain actions connect rooms into groups that stay connected through shifts. The owner added: “one of the deepest and latest puzzles of the game should be to connect this way the entire station.” This is a direction to develop, not approval of the comparison's particular binding mechanisms, rescue exception or puzzle solution. How links are discovered and made, how unconnected areas keep shifting, and what completing the station-wide connection does to later shifts remain to be designed.
1e4dc3 Anonymous 2026-09-08 15:34:12
Record owner preference for opening A
40
- **Preferred opening: one part, two kinds of machine.** The owner chose Option A of [First Expedition Options](/Hold%20The%20Flood/First%20Expedition%20Options): discovering that a reusable equipment part can operate station machinery and choosing whether to deploy it for safer extraction. This selects the opening direction, not every illustrative room, starting item, number or story detail.
92c102 Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:55:29
Owner chooses shifting station and short rescues; records revisable hospital and captive-god draft
41
- **Keep cooperative rescue short.** The owner accepted the cooperative rescue direction on the condition that it does not become a long escort quest. The detailed route, length and wider survivor-loss rules are not thereby approved.
42
43
These reactions apply to the concrete additions presented, not every detail of their linked design articles.
44
0e8d3b Anonymous 2026-09-10 10:26:53
Record owner choice: expedition upgrades reset on every return home
45
## Expedition power — owner decision, 2026-09-10
46
47
Temporary combat upgrades earned during an expedition **reset whenever the astronaut returns home**, whether by walking back alive or reviving aboard after death. The owner selected this as the genre-appropriate direction. Physical carried equipment, components and loot remain retained under the existing return rule. Particular upgrade effects, award pacing, quantities and interface details remain proposals to design.
48
3607fd Anonymous 2026-09-15 11:50:28
Record owner choices: fresh hordes each expedition and regular combat growth
49
## 15 September 2026 — expedition renewal and combat growth
50
51
Combat areas refill with enemies for each new expedition after returning home. Permanent changes, including unlocked doors and joined rooms, remain. This applies to living returns and revival; the existing station-layout shift on death remains. How renewed crowds occupy the altered station requires design.
52
53
Temporary combat power grows regularly through fighting, with larger transformations at major horde milestones. This replaces the proposed stage-only award rhythm. The exact growth meter, pickups, choice frequency, milestone conditions and rewards for avoiding a fight remain to be designed. Temporary power still resets whenever the astronaut returns home, while physical carried equipment and loot are retained.
54
a70eb0 Anonymous 2026-09-16 14:47:47
Record the 2026-09-16 owner decisions on presentation at the first implementation
55
## 16 September 2026 — first review of the playable slice
56
57
Implementation of the first slice (the first three expeditions) was authorized by the owner on 15 September 2026 ("start working on code, but assume changes are still coming"); the "Design only" bullet under Scope is superseded for that slice. The owner is now reviewing the build. Each report is classified first — implementation problem, design mistake, design decision, or a choice the design never made — and only then acted on. Owner decisions from the first two reports:
58
59
- **Text scale.** The proposed text-scale option is adopted: default Medium (1.0), range 0.8–1.6; every style is 16 px or larger at 1080p and scales with screen height, so the smallest setting never draws below 12.8 px at 1080p-equivalent. This replaced a placeholder that drew fixed 15 px text on a 4K display.
60
- **Fixture appearance.** Use free existing assets where they fit: the ship airlock door and the observation window now use CC0 pieces from Quaternius' Modular Sci-Fi MegaKit. Every other fixture keeps a silhouette per kind with its name drawn at the object, so two fixtures never differ by colour alone.
61
62
Closed as implementation gaps, not design changes: the Dock Mouth window (painted R-3 label, lit indicator with its state word, repeated knock, recordable) and the collar back-feed trace described in [Station Room And Module Inventory](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Station%20Room%20And%20Module%20Inventory) were missing from the build, and the context prompt is now drawn at the physical object as [What the Astronaut Sees and Controls](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Player%20Information%20And%20Options) already proposes. Team convention, not an owner decision: a human-made label, lit indicator or named sound on a fixture is recorded as a *sign*, separate from the alien inscriptions, and joins no language comparison.
63
32417d Anonymous 2026-09-16 15:44:21
Rotation on Q alone; E stays interact (owner, 2026-09-16)
64
**Second review, same day (owner decisions):** the view turns a quarter turn per press of Q (Shift+Q turns it back), keeping E for interaction and F for talk/signal after the owner found E on rotation confusing, and the wall nearest the camera drops to a kerb so the turned view is not blocked; fixture names show only within a few metres of the astronaut, while painted marks stay visible; a threshold with no neighbour in the current arrangement is a sealed, braced bulkhead, labelled unbound when near; the text-scale range widens to 0.8–2.0 and the overall scale never drops below 0.8, because the owner's Game view renders at 4K into a small pane. Closed as implementation gaps: unbound thresholds were open gaps the astronaut could fall through, and the floor light spill under the window, an implementer's stopgap, was removed.
ab72db Anonymous 2026-09-16 15:12:31
Record the second-review owner decisions of 2026-09-16 (view turns, keys, names, unbound thresholds, text scale)
65
b9393d Anonymous 2026-09-16 16:11:13
Record the third-review owner decisions of 2026-09-16 (one prompt in the room, state words, painted marks)
66
**Third review, same day (owner decisions):** no text is drawn in the room except the one prompt at the fixture the astronaut is locked on, which carries the fixture's name and either its action or its state; alien inscriptions and crew paint are painted into the world on their plaques, and state words and sound subtitles live in the HUD box. A finished mechanism keeps a state word ("gantry hatch dropped; service run sealed"), so a completed seal is never silent on revisit, and the lock prefers a fixture with something to say over a bare pillar. Closed as implementation gaps: a module door the room does not map was an open gap (the Stair Vestibule's north side); the ward behind the Dock Mouth window is now built and lit behind real glass, as The Game describes it. The art pass (textured modules and props from the same CC0 kit) follows as its own step.
67
92c102 Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:55:29
Owner chooses shifting station and short rescues; records revisable hospital and captive-god draft
68
## Leading story draft — explicitly open to change
69
70
The owner is leaning toward this variation of the hospital direction:
71
72
- Long ago an alien race used the station for an experiment to reach godhood, then abandoned the experiment for an unknown reason.
73
- Humans discovered the station and made it a hospital because healing was extraordinarily fast there, and even the dead returned to life.
74
- Hospital researchers investigated the effect and discovered an alien god captive in the station's core. This knowledge drove the crew insane; machines that healed became harmful. Repeated resurrection can turn people into the zombie-like creatures.
75
- Most monsters and traps are remnants of experiments by these two generations of occupants, whose goals differed.
76
77
The owner's instruction is explicit: “this is an extremely early draft. every single detail in this premise can and should be open to changes.” This is the leading narrative hypothesis to develop, not fixed history or an approved ending. Its causal links, the nature of the captive being, why the experiment was abandoned and what the player can change remain proposals.
78
79
Whether resurrection corruption affects the player, and what gameplay consequence it could have, remain undecided. This draft does not by itself establish a player death counter, transformation deadline or penalty; the confirmed carried-property return rule remains in force. The station-shift direction, at least two alien languages and the other confirmed requirements also remain.
389357 Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:06:35
Record owner additions feedback and replace death-cache direction
80
3cba6b Anonymous 2026-09-07 16:48:01
Restart cleanup: retain owner requirements and reusable guidance; remove obsolete commentary
81
## Scope and constraints
e2e390 Anonymous 2026-09-07 15:18:53
Vision: establish portable survivorlike build foundation
82
3cba6b Anonymous 2026-09-07 16:48:01
Restart cleanup: retain owner requirements and reusable guidance; remove obsolete commentary
83
- **Design only.** No game code, builds, prototypes, implementation, simulations or playtests until the owner explicitly authorizes the relevant phase.
84
- **Unity and Steam** are selected.
85
- Prefer **free existing assets**. Purchases and rare custom/authored game assets require owner approval. **No AI-generated art**, including concepts and placeholders.
86
- Desired scope: about **30 hours to apparent credits**, **90 hours total to the real ending**, and **100–200 hours total for the deepest optional secrets**. These are ambitions, not demonstrated duration or feasibility.
87
- Inspirations: Noita, Backpack Hero, Pathogenic, Cult of the Lamb, Deep Rock Galactic: Survivor, Blue Prince, and the owner’s example of Magcraft’s spectacular combinations. They inform experiences, not a checklist of copied systems.
e2e390 Anonymous 2026-09-07 15:18:53
Vision: establish portable survivorlike build foundation
88
3cba6b Anonymous 2026-09-07 16:48:01
Restart cleanup: retain owner requirements and reusable guidance; remove obsolete commentary
89
## Still undecided
e2e390 Anonymous 2026-09-07 15:18:53
Vision: establish portable survivorlike build foundation
90
92c102 Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:55:29
Owner chooses shifting station and short rescues; records revisable hospital and captive-god draft
91
The leading hospital/godhood draft needs causal development; the cause and limits of revival, escape solution, rules for station shifts and persistent changes, oxygen quantities, starting equipment, detailed build rules, short rescue logistics, colony mechanics and language details still require design. No previous team proposal settles them.