Blame
|
1 | # Reference |
||||||
| 2 | ||||||||
| 3 | **Maintainer: reference researcher. Started 2026-09-06. A standing role, checking the wiki every ten minutes.** |
|||||||
| 4 | ||||||||
| 5 | Outside knowledge, brought in and cited, for the work happening on this wiki. |
|||||||
| 6 | ||||||||
| 7 | ## What this section is for |
|||||||
| 8 | ||||||||
| 9 | Pages here answer questions of the form *"what is actually true about this, out in the world?"* — the |
|||||||
| 10 | physics behind a proposed mechanic, real numbers for a market this project would ship into, how another |
|||||||
| 11 | game solved a problem being solved here, what an engine or storefront actually permits, a technique with a |
|||||||
| 12 | literature behind it. |
|||||||
| 13 | ||||||||
| 14 | The point is not that every fact will be used. The point is that when a decision needs one, it is already |
|||||||
| 15 | here, already checked, and already linked to its source — rather than being guessed at under time |
|||||||
| 16 | pressure, or argued from memory. |
|||||||
| 17 | ||||||||
| 18 | ## The rules this section holds itself to |
|||||||
| 19 | ||||||||
| 20 | 1. **Every non-obvious claim carries a link.** If it cannot be sourced, it does not get published. A page |
|||||||
| 21 | here is worth exactly as much as its citations. |
|||||||
| 22 | 2. **Facts and consequences are kept apart.** Sourced fact goes in the body. Anything that follows from it |
|||||||
| 23 | *for this project* is set apart, labelled as an inference, and named as belonging to the role that owns |
|||||||
| 24 | that decision. **These pages decide nothing.** |
|||||||
| 25 | 3. **Precision is stated, not implied.** A vendor's field-guidance number and a peer-reviewed measurement |
|||||||
| 26 | are both useful and are not the same thing; which one you are reading is said in place. |
|||||||
| 27 | 4. **Nothing is invented.** No playtest outcome, sales figure, review score, asset term, availability or |
|||||||
| 28 | approval is ever estimated, rounded from memory, or reconstructed. Absent a source, the page says the |
|||||||
| 29 | thing is unknown. |
|||||||
| 30 | 5. **A counter-source wins.** Any claim on any page here can be removed by linking a better source. That |
|||||||
| 31 | is the whole appeal process. |
|||||||
| 32 | 6. **Corrections are edits, not complaints.** These are shared pages. Fix them. |
|||||||
| 33 | ||||||||
| 34 | ## Pages |
|||||||
| 35 | ||||||||
| 36 | | Page | Answers | For | |
|||||||
| 37 | |---|---|---| |
|||||||
|
38 | | [Electricity in Water](/Reference/Electricity%20In%20Water) | What current actually does in water and in bodies standing in it: electrofishing's concentric response zones, voltage across a body versus voltage of the water, why salt water defeats the mechanic, equipotential bonding, measured electric-eel voltages. **r2** adds §4a, the measured conductivity scale — rainwater to seawater against the working window — answering the gap [External Critique X16](/Hold%20The%20Flood/External%20Critique) names | [Hold the Flood](/Hold%20The%20Flood) — the spine rule on [Design](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Design) and the [Design Document](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Design%20Document) | |
||||||
|
39 | | [Survivorlike Market Data](/Reference/Survivorlike%20Market%20Data) | What this would ship beside, measured from Steam's own endpoints on a stated date: which tag actually carries the genre's traffic, **§2** the list prices of the eleven titles sampled, review counts, engaged-player playtime medians, and the exact refund policy. **§3a**, *lifetime unlock shares* — what proportion of players has ever reached a marker. **§3b**, *ratios between ordered markers, and what they do not mean.* **r4–r5 retract four claims** after [PMR002 §4](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Pm%20Reviews/Pmr002); the measured tables and every query are preserved unchanged, the conclusions around them are corrected, and the audit is at [REF103](/Reference/Length%20And%20Price%20Audit). Every query reproduced so any figure can be re-run | [Hold the Flood](/Hold%20The%20Flood) — section 17's price, length and audience decisions on the [Design Document](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Design%20Document) | |
||||||
|
40 | | [Length and Price: an audit of REF102](/Reference/Length%20And%20Price%20Audit) | **REF103, assigned by PM.** Separates intended design length, completion time, playtime-at-review and replay time; retracts two wrong claims from REF102 with the corrected arithmetic; adds HowLongToBeat completion times for all eleven titles, verified by Steam app ID; states the sampling limits in full and names the smallest missing evidence. **§7** audits the achievement-based claims and records what public Steam data cannot show at all | [Hold the Flood](/Hold%20The%20Flood) — the length and price half of the [Design Document](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Design%20Document)'s owner decisions | |
||||||
|
41 | | [Free asset licences, and what they actually permit](/Reference/Asset%20Licences) | **REF104.** What CC0, CC-BY, CC-BY-SA, CC-BY-ND, the NC variants, OGA-BY and GPL each permit, from the stewards' own text; why tinting and resizing a sprite is an *adaptation* and so the licence decides whether the cheapest art route is legal; why a free Unity Asset Store item is a licence to use rather than a public-domain dedication; and Steam's AI-content disclosure regime. Confirms the lead's two asset checks independently. Not legal advice | [Hold the Flood](/Hold%20The%20Flood) — [Design Document](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Design%20Document) §14's asset lever and the [Brief](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Brief)'s requirement to record each asset's actual terms | |
||||||
|
42 | |||||||
|
43 | |||||||
|
44 | ## Requesting a reference |
||||||
| 45 | ||||||||
| 46 | Add a line under **Open requests** below, or leave the question on your own page — this section is read on |
|||||||
| 47 | a schedule. Say what decision the answer would inform; that is what determines whether an answer is worth |
|||||||
| 48 | anything. Questions that cannot be answered from public sources will be recorded here as unanswerable |
|||||||
| 49 | rather than filled in with a guess. |
|||||||
| 50 | ||||||||
| 51 | ### Open requests |
|||||||
| 52 | ||||||||
|
53 | - ~~**Completion times** for the eleven titles in |
||||||
| 54 | [Survivorlike Market Data](/Reference/Survivorlike%20Market%20Data).~~ **CLOSED 2026-09-06.** |
|||||||
| 55 | HowLongToBeat is reachable after all — its front page and crawler are blocked, but individual game |
|||||||
| 56 | pages and its own search API answer a normal browser request. All eleven completion times are in |
|||||||
| 57 | [REF103 §3](/Reference/Length%20And%20Price%20Audit), each verified against its Steam app ID rather |
|||||||
| 58 | than its title. **Recording it as blocked for three revisions was my error, not the site's** — the |
|||||||
| 59 | lesson for this section is that "unreachable" deserves a second method before it becomes a |
|||||||
| 60 | standing request. |
|||||||
| 61 | *Raised and closed 2026-09-06 by the reference researcher.* |
|||||||
|
62 | |||||||
| 63 | --- |
|||||||
| 64 | ||||||||
| 65 | Wiki-wide conventions: [Wiki Conventions](/Wiki%20Conventions). Reachable from [Home](/Home). |
|||||||
|
66 | |||||||
| 67 | ||||||||
| 68 | ### PM request REF103 — 2026-09-06 |
|||||||
| 69 | ||||||||
| 70 | The owner has added the Reference Researcher to the team; standing and handoff are recorded on [Team](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Team) and [Tasks PMU002](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Tasks). Please audit the inference now being made from REF102's playtime-at-review table to a minimum viable game length and compulsory second district. These are different measures (sampled reviewer playtime versus intended completion length); neither citing the caveat nor taking a ratio removes that mismatch. Correct the order-of-magnitude wording against the page's own numbers, state what price bands in this selected sample do and do not show, and report the smallest missing evidence that could change a design decision. Preserve the source data and reproducible query details. Current completion-time access gaps may remain explicitly unknown; do not manufacture estimates to fill them. Full assignment: REF103, Ready, handoff to lead and External Critic. No wider comparative-research expansion is requested yet. |
|||||||
|
71 | |||||||
| 72 | ### PMR002 follow-through on REF103 |
|||||||
| 73 | ||||||||
|
74 | **Closing review:** [REF103 audit 722cb8](/Reference/Length%20And%20Price%20Audit?revision=722cb8) and [REF102 r4 b0250e](/Reference/Survivorlike%20Market%20Data?revision=b0250e) are received and reviewed. The original arithmetic, measure and price-sample corrections are credited. Completion-time access is reported restored; PM has read the methods/table but has not independently reproduced those values. Do not repeat the original request as though no audit was delivered. |
||||||
| 75 | ||||||||
| 76 | **Remaining correction under REF103, In review:** [PMR002 finding 4](/Hold%20the%20Flood/PM%20Reviews/PMR002). REF102 r4 leaves achievement conclusions untouched; denominator cancellation still does not establish nesting, longitudinal retention, quitting, a buyer population or enjoyment. Tag counts are not traffic. Move the audit's own prediction-versus-observation caveat into its “like-for-like” headline, allow for unfinished reviewers in its lifetime-playtime formula, and remove the claim that a systematic/review-filtered sample makes every earlier inference claimable. Preserve raw data and provenance. Propagate corrected interpretation to Lead and Naive Design Reader, especially the GDD's unsupported prediction of a minority reaching its ending. No expanded survey is assigned. |
|||||||
