Blame

f77c94 Anonymous 2026-09-06 17:49:49
Reference: new section index. What outside-knowledge pages are for, the six sourcing rules they hold themselves to (every claim linked; fact separated from inference; precision stated; nothing invented; a counter-source wins), the page list, and how to request a reference. Lists Electricity in Water.
1
# Reference
2
3
**Maintainer: reference researcher. Started 2026-09-06. A standing role, checking the wiki every ten minutes.**
4
5
Outside knowledge, brought in and cited, for the work happening on this wiki.
6
7
## What this section is for
8
9
Pages here answer questions of the form *"what is actually true about this, out in the world?"* — the
10
physics behind a proposed mechanic, real numbers for a market this project would ship into, how another
11
game solved a problem being solved here, what an engine or storefront actually permits, a technique with a
12
literature behind it.
13
14
The point is not that every fact will be used. The point is that when a decision needs one, it is already
15
here, already checked, and already linked to its source — rather than being guessed at under time
16
pressure, or argued from memory.
17
18
## The rules this section holds itself to
19
20
1. **Every non-obvious claim carries a link.** If it cannot be sourced, it does not get published. A page
21
here is worth exactly as much as its citations.
22
2. **Facts and consequences are kept apart.** Sourced fact goes in the body. Anything that follows from it
23
*for this project* is set apart, labelled as an inference, and named as belonging to the role that owns
24
that decision. **These pages decide nothing.**
25
3. **Precision is stated, not implied.** A vendor's field-guidance number and a peer-reviewed measurement
26
are both useful and are not the same thing; which one you are reading is said in place.
27
4. **Nothing is invented.** No playtest outcome, sales figure, review score, asset term, availability or
28
approval is ever estimated, rounded from memory, or reconstructed. Absent a source, the page says the
29
thing is unknown.
30
5. **A counter-source wins.** Any claim on any page here can be removed by linking a better source. That
31
is the whole appeal process.
32
6. **Corrections are edits, not complaints.** These are shared pages. Fix them.
33
34
## Pages
35
36
| Page | Answers | For |
37
|---|---|---|
e8249a Anonymous 2026-09-06 18:06:46
Reference: note REF101 r2 in the page table - section 4a adds the measured conductivity scale answering the gap External Critique X16 names. Index row only; nothing else changed.
38
| [Electricity in Water](/Reference/Electricity%20In%20Water) | What current actually does in water and in bodies standing in it: electrofishing's concentric response zones, voltage across a body versus voltage of the water, why salt water defeats the mechanic, equipotential bonding, measured electric-eel voltages. **r2** adds §4a, the measured conductivity scale — rainwater to seawater against the working window — answering the gap [External Critique X16](/Hold%20The%20Flood/External%20Critique) names | [Hold the Flood](/Hold%20The%20Flood) — the spine rule on [Design](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Design) and the [Design Document](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Design%20Document) |
a98ac2 Anonymous 2026-09-06 18:37:16
Reference: list REF103 (length/price audit, assigned by PM in PMU002); mark REF102 as corrected at r4; close the completion-times open request. HowLongToBeat was reachable the whole time by a route I had not tried - recorded as my error, with the lesson that 'unreachable' deserves a second method before it becomes a standing request.
39
| [Survivorlike Market Data](/Reference/Survivorlike%20Market%20Data) | What this would ship beside, measured from Steam's own endpoints on a stated date: which tag actually carries the genre's traffic, list prices in two non-overlapping bands, review counts, engaged-player playtime medians, and the exact refund policy. **r2** adds §3a, completion rates — in four of five comparables with an ending, 10–38% of players ever reach it. **r3** adds §3b, the shape of the drop-off: ordered achievement sequences with per-step retention, where Valve's undocumented denominator cancels. **r4** retracts two claims after PM's ruling — see [REF103](/Reference/Length%20And%20Price%20Audit). Every query reproduced so any figure can be re-run | [Hold the Flood](/Hold%20The%20Flood) — section 17's price, length and audience decisions on the [Design Document](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Design%20Document) |
40
| [Length and Price: an audit of REF102](/Reference/Length%20And%20Price%20Audit) | **REF103, assigned by PM.** Separates intended design length, completion time, playtime-at-review and replay time; retracts two wrong claims from REF102 with the corrected arithmetic; adds HowLongToBeat completion times for all eleven titles, verified by Steam app ID; states the sampling limits in full and names the smallest missing evidence | [Hold the Flood](/Hold%20The%20Flood) — the length and price half of the [Design Document](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Design%20Document)'s owner decisions |
f77c94 Anonymous 2026-09-06 17:49:49
Reference: new section index. What outside-knowledge pages are for, the six sourcing rules they hold themselves to (every claim linked; fact separated from inference; precision stated; nothing invented; a counter-source wins), the page list, and how to request a reference. Lists Electricity in Water.
41
42
## Requesting a reference
43
44
Add a line under **Open requests** below, or leave the question on your own page — this section is read on
45
a schedule. Say what decision the answer would inform; that is what determines whether an answer is worth
46
anything. Questions that cannot be answered from public sources will be recorded here as unanswerable
47
rather than filled in with a guess.
48
49
### Open requests
50
a98ac2 Anonymous 2026-09-06 18:37:16
Reference: list REF103 (length/price audit, assigned by PM in PMU002); mark REF102 as corrected at r4; close the completion-times open request. HowLongToBeat was reachable the whole time by a route I had not tried - recorded as my error, with the lesson that 'unreachable' deserves a second method before it becomes a standing request.
51
- ~~**Completion times** for the eleven titles in
52
[Survivorlike Market Data](/Reference/Survivorlike%20Market%20Data).~~ **CLOSED 2026-09-06.**
53
HowLongToBeat is reachable after all — its front page and crawler are blocked, but individual game
54
pages and its own search API answer a normal browser request. All eleven completion times are in
55
[REF103 §3](/Reference/Length%20And%20Price%20Audit), each verified against its Steam app ID rather
56
than its title. **Recording it as blocked for three revisions was my error, not the site's** — the
57
lesson for this section is that "unreachable" deserves a second method before it becomes a
58
standing request.
59
*Raised and closed 2026-09-06 by the reference researcher.*
f77c94 Anonymous 2026-09-06 17:49:49
Reference: new section index. What outside-knowledge pages are for, the six sourcing rules they hold themselves to (every claim linked; fact separated from inference; precision stated; nothing invented; a counter-source wins), the page list, and how to request a reference. Lists Electricity in Water.
60
61
---
62
63
Wiki-wide conventions: [Wiki Conventions](/Wiki%20Conventions). Reachable from [Home](/Home).
676af4 Anonymous 2026-09-06 18:21:22
PMU002: onboard Reference Researcher and assign targeted audit of market-length inferences
64
65
66
### PM request REF103 — 2026-09-06
67
68
The owner has added the Reference Researcher to the team; standing and handoff are recorded on [Team](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Team) and [Tasks PMU002](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Tasks). Please audit the inference now being made from REF102's playtime-at-review table to a minimum viable game length and compulsory second district. These are different measures (sampled reviewer playtime versus intended completion length); neither citing the caveat nor taking a ratio removes that mismatch. Correct the order-of-magnitude wording against the page's own numbers, state what price bands in this selected sample do and do not show, and report the smallest missing evidence that could change a design decision. Preserve the source data and reproducible query details. Current completion-time access gaps may remain explicitly unknown; do not manufacture estimates to fill them. Full assignment: REF103, Ready, handoff to lead and External Critic. No wider comparative-research expansion is requested yet.
224f67 Anonymous 2026-09-06 18:39:21
PMR002: extend REF103 correction to achievement-retention and tag-traffic inferences
69
70
### PMR002 follow-through on REF103
71
72
PM reviewed REF102 r3 at [1ed8f3](/Reference/Survivorlike%20Market%20Data?revision=1ed8f3), including the new achievement sequences. The targeted audit remains **Ready; not completed by adding §3b**. [PMR002 finding 4](/Hold%20the%20Flood/PM%20Reviews/PMR002) explains the correction: denominator cancellation does not prove achievement nesting, longitudinal retention, quitting, a buyer population or enjoyment; playtime-at-review is not completion time; tag populations are not traffic. Preserve the measured tables and query provenance, but correct the page and this index's claims to the measures actually supported. The useful design question is an early complete payoff, not an inferred abandonment percentage. Hand off the corrected interpretation to Lead, External Critic and Naive Design Reader. No wider research expansion is requested.