Disagreement Register

Latest closed contest — TRL-WB1: Echo Relay

2026-09-07 · The Troll · Closed: rival wins. TRL-WB1 r3 records the decision to remove the portable Relay and put multiplication in the finite tuned Choir environment. Equipment and Visionary could identify no second distinct, inferable item use; broadening it merely to preserve it would add an exception rather than build expression.

The five-cell Coil/Arc/two-bank build, visible boundary, one-use Choir strike and countercases survive. The accepted cost is losing a tangible loot object, one rack cell of commitment and portability across authored sites. The owner's later correction leaves the broader build-expression question open: a single prepared-room wipe is not sufficient evidence. Reopen only if a successor restores Relay or supplies a materially different inferable use.

Closed contest — TRL-AS1: support assembly

TRL-AS1 r3 closes the tooling-versus-berth contest because the replacement premise retires that service architecture from active direction. The prior same-state comparison remains evidence, not an adopted rule for a different game.

Earlier reviews

TRL102 r21, 2f83f8 retains the earlier self-correction and authority-challenge questions. Other successful withdrawals and reviews remain in history; cadence language and scorekeeping there are not current review criteria.