Blame

0da3e5 Anonymous 2026-09-07 21:07:10
Death and Persistence: recoverable cache with retained records, compared against expedition rollback; state table, dependencies and reopening conditions
1
# Hold The Horde — Death and Persistence
2
11380d Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:08:58
Owner decision 2026-09-08: carried equipment and loot return with the astronaut on death; cache and rollback withdrawn, spent and installed boundaries stated as non-penalties
3
**Status.** The core rule here is an owner decision, recorded on 2026-09-08: everything the astronaut is carrying when they die comes home with them. The [Owner Brief](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Brief) requires that death returns the astronaut to the ship for a reason hidden in the station; that cause is not addressed here. Damage and oxygen depletion both kill. Oxygen quantities, map structure, rescue logistics and colony systems remain undecided, and the proposals marked below are proposals.
0da3e5 Anonymous 2026-09-07 21:07:10
Death and Persistence: recoverable cache with retained records, compared against expedition rollback; state table, dependencies and reopening conditions
4
11380d Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:08:58
Owner decision 2026-09-08: carried equipment and loot return with the astronaut on death; cache and rollback withdrawn, spent and installed boundaries stated as non-penalties
5
## The rule
0da3e5 Anonymous 2026-09-07 21:07:10
Death and Persistence: recoverable cache with retained records, compared against expedition rollback; state table, dependencies and reopening conditions
6
11380d Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:08:58
Owner decision 2026-09-08: carried equipment and loot return with the astronaut on death; cache and rollback withdrawn, spent and installed boundaries stated as non-penalties
7
**Death returns the astronaut to the ship with everything they were carrying.** Equipment brought from home, salvage found that trip, records, a part still in the rig — all of it arrives aboard. There is no cache, no recovery trip, and nothing is confiscated or taxed to compensate.
0da3e5 Anonymous 2026-09-07 21:07:10
Death and Persistence: recoverable cache with retained records, compared against expedition rollback; state table, dependencies and reopening conditions
8
11380d Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:08:58
Owner decision 2026-09-08: carried equipment and loot return with the astronaut on death; cache and rollback withdrawn, spent and installed boundaries stated as non-penalties
9
Two boundaries keep this from duplicating anything, and neither is a penalty:
bb2c95 Anonymous 2026-09-07 21:44:08
Author response to review 117: cache lifecycle and stake stated plainly; loadout-protection rationale replaces cheap-exit; four recovery states; depletion reach corrected; journal ranking removed; delivery conditioned on sending
10
11380d Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:08:58
Owner decision 2026-09-08: carried equipment and loot return with the astronaut on death; cache and rollback withdrawn, spent and installed boundaries stated as non-penalties
11
- **Resources already spent stay spent.** Oxygen breathed, salvage consumed by a rig, a canister emptied — these were gone before death and do not come back. Death returns what is *carried*, not what was used.
12
- **Equipment deliberately left elsewhere stays there.** A relay seated in a station fixture, a part installed in a project aboard, a canister handed to someone — these were not in the pack. They are where the player put them, which is what they chose.
0da3e5 Anonymous 2026-09-07 21:07:10
Death and Persistence: recoverable cache with retained records, compared against expedition rollback; state table, dependencies and reopening conditions
13
11380d Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:08:58
Owner decision 2026-09-08: carried equipment and loot return with the astronaut on death; cache and rollback withdrawn, spent and installed boundaries stated as non-penalties
14
**Discoveries are unaffected.** Journal records and discovered-location references persist through death, as they do through any return.
0da3e5 Anonymous 2026-09-07 21:07:10
Death and Persistence: recoverable cache with retained records, compared against expedition rollback; state table, dependencies and reopening conditions
15
11380d Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:08:58
Owner decision 2026-09-08: carried equipment and loot return with the astronaut on death; cache and rollback withdrawn, spent and installed boundaries stated as non-penalties
16
**People are not cargo.** A rescued person is a route-and-transfer outcome, not something that comes home in the pack. Someone already sent to the ship stays aboard. Someone rescued but not yet sent is not retroactively delivered by the astronaut's death, and remains where the rescue rules leave them. Whether a survivor can be permanently lost is undecided and is not settled here.
0da3e5 Anonymous 2026-09-07 21:07:10
Death and Persistence: recoverable cache with retained records, compared against expedition rollback; state table, dependencies and reopening conditions
17
11380d Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:08:58
Owner decision 2026-09-08: carried equipment and loot return with the astronaut on death; cache and rollback withdrawn, spent and installed boundaries stated as non-penalties
18
**World state.** Discovered locations persist. Enemies, traps and mechanisms may reset on their own terms, and deliberate infrastructure changes the player made persist as those rules describe.
0da3e5 Anonymous 2026-09-07 21:07:10
Death and Persistence: recoverable cache with retained records, compared against expedition rollback; state table, dependencies and reopening conditions
19
11380d Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:08:58
Owner decision 2026-09-08: carried equipment and loot return with the astronaut on death; cache and rollback withdrawn, spent and installed boundaries stated as non-penalties
20
## What returning alive and dying each give
bb2c95 Anonymous 2026-09-07 21:44:08
Author response to review 117: cache lifecycle and stake stated plainly; loadout-protection rationale replaces cheap-exit; four recovery states; depletion reach corrected; journal ranking removed; delivery conditioned on sending
21
11380d Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:08:58
Owner decision 2026-09-08: carried equipment and loot return with the astronaut on death; cache and rollback withdrawn, spent and installed boundaries stated as non-penalties
22
| | Returning alive | Dying |
23
|---|---|---|
24
| Equipment brought from the ship | Comes home | Comes home |
25
| Salvage and equipment found that trip | Comes home | Comes home |
26
| Consumed oxygen, spent materials | Already spent | Already spent |
27
| Parts left installed in the station or aboard | Where they were left | Where they were left |
28
| Records and discovered locations | Retained | Retained |
29
| A person rescued that trip | Joins the colony if actually sent | Stays aboard if already sent; otherwise still in the station |
0da3e5 Anonymous 2026-09-07 21:07:10
Death and Persistence: recoverable cache with retained records, compared against expedition rollback; state table, dependencies and reopening conditions
30
11380d Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:08:58
Owner decision 2026-09-08: carried equipment and loot return with the astronaut on death; cache and rollback withdrawn, spent and installed boundaries stated as non-penalties
31
## What death actually costs
0da3e5 Anonymous 2026-09-07 21:07:10
Death and Persistence: recoverable cache with retained records, compared against expedition rollback; state table, dependencies and reopening conditions
32
11380d Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:08:58
Owner decision 2026-09-08: carried equipment and loot return with the astronaut on death; cache and rollback withdrawn, spent and installed boundaries stated as non-penalties
33
Not property. The costs are real but they are all time and position:
0da3e5 Anonymous 2026-09-07 21:07:10
Death and Persistence: recoverable cache with retained records, compared against expedition rollback; state table, dependencies and reopening conditions
34
11380d Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:08:58
Owner decision 2026-09-08: carried equipment and loot return with the astronaut on death; cache and rollback withdrawn, spent and installed boundaries stated as non-penalties
35
- The expedition ends *there*. Whatever the player was partway through — a route, a staged action, a rescue in progress — stops, and the next trip starts from the ship rather than from where they were.
36
- Progress inside a staged piece of work follows the ordinary rules: completed checkpoints persist, an unfinished stage is lost.
37
- Anything the player was going to do next, they now do on another trip.
bb2c95 Anonymous 2026-09-07 21:44:08
Author response to review 117: cache lifecycle and stake stated plainly; loadout-protection rationale replaces cheap-exit; four recovery states; depletion reach corrected; journal ranking removed; delivery conditioned on sending
38
11380d Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:08:58
Owner decision 2026-09-08: carried equipment and loot return with the astronaut on death; cache and rollback withdrawn, spent and installed boundaries stated as non-penalties
39
That is a modest cost, and stating it plainly is better than implying a larger one. This rule makes death an interruption rather than a loss.
bb2c95 Anonymous 2026-09-07 21:44:08
Author response to review 117: cache lifecycle and stake stated plainly; loadout-protection rationale replaces cheap-exit; four recovery states; depletion reach corrected; journal ranking removed; delivery conditioned on sending
40
11380d Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:08:58
Owner decision 2026-09-08: carried equipment and loot return with the astronaut on death; cache and rollback withdrawn, spent and installed boundaries stated as non-penalties
41
## Designing around it
bb2c95 Anonymous 2026-09-07 21:44:08
Author response to review 117: cache lifecycle and stake stated plainly; loadout-protection rationale replaces cheap-exit; four recovery states; depletion reach corrected; journal ranking removed; delivery conditioned on sending
42
11380d Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:08:58
Owner decision 2026-09-08: carried equipment and loot return with the astronaut on death; cache and rollback withdrawn, spent and installed boundaries stated as non-penalties
43
Returning by death can be useful — a player far out, low on oxygen, with a full pack, can die and arrive home with everything. That is a consequence of the rule, not a loophole to be closed, and the design should treat it as a legitimate way to end a trip.
0da3e5 Anonymous 2026-09-07 21:07:10
Death and Persistence: recoverable cache with retained records, compared against expedition rollback; state table, dependencies and reopening conditions
44
11380d Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:08:58
Owner decision 2026-09-08: carried equipment and loot return with the astronaut on death; cache and rollback withdrawn, spent and installed boundaries stated as non-penalties
45
What that asks of the rest of the design is that **going out be worth doing for reasons other than avoiding loss**. A trip is worth taking because of where it lets the player get to, what they can reach with the supply they carry, and what they want to be doing. Those hold regardless of how the trip ends. Nothing here should be balanced by inventing a penalty on the other side.
0da3e5 Anonymous 2026-09-07 21:07:10
Death and Persistence: recoverable cache with retained records, compared against expedition rollback; state table, dependencies and reopening conditions
46
11380d Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:08:58
Owner decision 2026-09-08: carried equipment and loot return with the astronaut on death; cache and rollback withdrawn, spent and installed boundaries stated as non-penalties
47
It also means the interesting pressure sits earlier: what to carry, how far to push, whether to spend a part on something in the station, and whether to commit to a rescue. Those choices all still bite, because capacity is still limited and what is spent or installed is still gone.
0da3e5 Anonymous 2026-09-07 21:07:10
Death and Persistence: recoverable cache with retained records, compared against expedition rollback; state table, dependencies and reopening conditions
48
fa518f Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:10:42
Keep superseded comparison in revision history; state only the live consequence that no stranding dependency remains
49
## A dependency that no longer exists
0da3e5 Anonymous 2026-09-07 21:07:10
Death and Persistence: recoverable cache with retained records, compared against expedition rollback; state table, dependencies and reopening conditions
50
fa518f Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:10:42
Keep superseded comparison in revision history; state only the live consequence that no stranding dependency remains
51
Because nothing is left behind, the player cannot be stranded by a death. There is no need for a rule guaranteeing a minimum useful expedition after a loss, and other articles should not carry one on this account.
0da3e5 Anonymous 2026-09-07 21:07:10
Death and Persistence: recoverable cache with retained records, compared against expedition rollback; state table, dependencies and reopening conditions
52
53
## Unresolved
54
11380d Anonymous 2026-09-08 13:08:58
Owner decision 2026-09-08: carried equipment and loot return with the astronaut on death; cache and rollback withdrawn, spent and installed boundaries stated as non-penalties
55
Oxygen quantities; map generation and respawn rules; the full rescue and colony systems; whether an authored survivor can ever be permanently lost; and the cause of revival, which is untouched here and remains open across every candidate story.