2026-09-09 12:16:18
Anonymous:
Record readiness submissions555/557 and verified ONE critique558
hold the flood/progress.md ..
@@ 1,12 1,14 @@
# Hold The Horde — Progress
-
**Updated 2026-09-09 12:09 Jerusalem (UTC+3); current status through553.** The owner resumed all project work and original Claude roles in490. All work remains **design only**.
+
**Updated 2026-09-09 12:16 Jerusalem (UTC+3); current status through558.** The owner resumed all project work and original Claude roles in490. All work remains **design only**.
**38 tracked design packages:37 preparation-closed,1 open (38).** Scope and development handoff refresh37 ([Production Scope](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Production%20Scope); [Development And Validation Handoff](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Development%20And%20Validation%20Handoff)) closed550 at12:05:47. [V1 Readiness38](/Hold%20The%20Flood/V1%20Readiness), assigned551–553, gives a stable ID to the already-planned final coherence/readiness work; it adds no game scope. All15 domains have usable first-pass contracts/0 partial; M2/M3 are not yet declared complete and this is not a game-completion percentage. Existing24 modules/40 rooms,12 equipment definitions,10 encounters INCLUDING2 setpieces and13 major mechanisms remain proposed content;13 is not every interactive object. Intake407 and administration add no further packages.
“Closed” means the bounded written design/review outcome is complete. It does not mean a feature is implemented, every detail approved or fun validated. This board covers the current design batch; it is not a complete campaign or production backlog, and the closed/total ratio is not an overall game-completion percentage. Stable IDs stay fixed; added/reopened work must be recorded explicitly.
-
**Actual availability and handoffs:** original identities/models/efforts remain unchanged. Lead551 and Systems552 are WORKING on38; Reviewer553 is WORKING on independent criteria. Receiving/full contracts were verified at12:06:22/27 for Lead,12:06:18/22 for Systems and12:07:16/21 for Reviewer. Lead owns only the new administrative V1 Readiness article; Systems supplies a local factual audit for the same38 outcome; Reviewer prepares independent criteria before ONE critique of the actual stopped submission. All existing game articles and prior parent ownership are STOPPED; no37 follow-up is authorized. PM owns36/Home/Information STOPPED. No additional permanent agent or owner forwarding is needed.
+
**Readiness inputs delivered:** Lead557 at12:12:42 and Systems555 at12:12:20; both STOPPED. Reviewer554 criteria are complete, and its ONE critique558 is now WORKING. Critique target13:15 (12:45–14:00); reviewed38 remains16:00 (14:30–18:00), Jerusalem today. The four-defect Lead claim and13-record audit require reconciliation; neither closes M2/M3.
+
+
**Actual availability and handoffs:** original identities/models/efforts remain unchanged. Lead557 and Systems555 are STOPPED after their38 submissions; Reviewer558 is WORKING on the ONE combined critique after criteria554. Receiving558 and the full contract were verified at12:14:39/44. Receiving/full contracts were verified at12:06:22/27 for Lead,12:06:18/22 for Systems and12:07:16/21 for Reviewer. Lead owns only the new administrative V1 Readiness article; Systems supplies a local factual audit for the same38 outcome; Reviewer saved independent criteria554 and is conducting ONE critique of the stopped submission and audit. All existing game articles and prior parent ownership are STOPPED; no37 follow-up is authorized. PM owns36/Home/Information STOPPED. No additional permanent agent or owner forwarding is needed.
## Forward forecast — baseline F1
@@ 41,7 43,7 @@
The remaining critical sequence is38 readiness assessment + supporting factual audit → ONE critique and at most ONE consolidated response → bounded repairs and separate PM M2/M3 disposition.35,36 and37 are preparation-closed inputs. The14–26 role-hour allowance at response549 included37 response/disposition4–8 plus coherence10–18. With37 closed, only **10–18 role-hours for coherence/repair disposition** remains forward work. M4 **350–590 role-hours** and the future packet **289–490 role-hours /5–8 working weeks** are low-confidence conditional estimating proposals, not logged labor or development authority. No additional agent or development phase is assumed.
-
**Next delivery, Jerusalem:** [V1 Readiness38](/Hold%20The%20Flood/V1%20Readiness) numbers the previously planned whole-v1 coherence work. Draft target **13:30 (12:45–14:30)** and reviewed disposition **16:00 (14:30–18:00)** today9 September, low confidence; earlier completion can support an earlier M2/M3 delivery decision. Systems552 factual support targets **13:00 (12:30–14:00)**; Reviewer553 criteria **12:45 (12:30–13:15)**, then ONE critique roughly30–60 minutes after the stopped full submission. Lead551 and Systems552 are WORKING on38; Reviewer553 is WORKING on independent criteria. Receiving/full contracts were verified at12:06:22/27 for Lead,12:06:18/22 for Systems and12:07:16/21 for Reviewer. Lead owns only the new administrative V1 Readiness article; Systems supplies a local factual audit for the same38 outcome; Reviewer prepares independent criteria before ONE critique of the actual stopped submission. Scope and development handoff refresh37 ([Production Scope](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Production%20Scope); [Development And Validation Handoff](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Development%20And%20Validation%20Handoff)) closed550 at **12:05:47**, after response549 at11:58:19 and one critique/response: Production68db46ea (21,243 bytes), Handoff59945901 (27,529 bytes), before its15:00 reviewed target. Both parents are Systems STOPPED.35 closed11:35:17 and36 closed11:49:32. The14–26 role-hour allowance at response549 included37 response/disposition4–8 plus coherence10–18. With37 closed, only **10–18 role-hours for coherence/repair disposition** remains forward work. M4 **350–590 role-hours** and the future packet **289–490 role-hours /5–8 working weeks** are low-confidence conditional estimating proposals, not logged labor or development authority. F1.14 milestone dates remain unchanged pending38; five owner choices remain unanswered. The overnight owner pause was authorized downtime;144–247 remains dated8September planning history.
+
**Next delivery, Jerusalem:** [V1 Readiness38](/Hold%20The%20Flood/V1%20Readiness) numbers the previously planned whole-v1 coherence work. Draft target **13:30 (12:45–14:30)** and reviewed disposition **16:00 (14:30–18:00)** today9 September, low confidence; earlier completion can support an earlier M2/M3 delivery decision. Systems552 factual support targets **13:00 (12:30–14:00)**; Reviewer553 criteria **12:45 (12:30–13:15)**, then ONE critique roughly30–60 minutes after the stopped full submission. Lead557 and Systems555 are STOPPED after their38 submissions; Reviewer558 is WORKING on the ONE combined critique after criteria554. Receiving558 and the full contract were verified at12:14:39/44. Receiving/full contracts were verified at12:06:22/27 for Lead,12:06:18/22 for Systems and12:07:16/21 for Reviewer. Lead owns only the new administrative V1 Readiness article; Systems supplies a local factual audit for the same38 outcome; Reviewer saved independent criteria554 and is conducting ONE critique of the stopped submission and audit. Scope and development handoff refresh37 ([Production Scope](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Production%20Scope); [Development And Validation Handoff](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Development%20And%20Validation%20Handoff)) closed550 at **12:05:47**, after response549 at11:58:19 and one critique/response: Production68db46ea (21,243 bytes), Handoff59945901 (27,529 bytes), before its15:00 reviewed target. Both parents are Systems STOPPED.35 closed11:35:17 and36 closed11:49:32. The14–26 role-hour allowance at response549 included37 response/disposition4–8 plus coherence10–18. With37 closed, only **10–18 role-hours for coherence/repair disposition** remains forward work. M4 **350–590 role-hours** and the future packet **289–490 role-hours /5–8 working weeks** are low-confidence conditional estimating proposals, not logged labor or development authority. F1.14 milestone dates remain unchanged pending38; five owner choices remain unanswered. The overnight owner pause was authorized downtime;144–247 remains dated8September planning history.
**Adopted F1.14 forecast — 9 September:** M3 first-pass wiki now targets **14 September (11–18 September), low confidence**. M2 coherent core remains11 September (10–14); M4 detailed campaign remains10 November (20 October–1 December). The revision follows the remaining-deliverables audit and preparation closeouts25–33, including the actual24-module/40-room and ten-encounter/thirteen-mechanism first passes. It uses current PM, Systems and restored original Lead/Reviewer capacity; additional agents are not prerequisites. It is a scope-based calendar judgment, not a conversion of word counts or elapsed chat minutes into role-hours. A changed joining architecture, expanded first-pass scope, unresolved integration or unavailable capacity can move the estimate. Next scheduled re-estimate:9 September18:00 Jerusalem, or sooner after consequential acceptance, scope or capacity changes. The earlier absent-two-specialists→25Sep scenario is historical and no longer the current schedule. The earlier14Sep conditional calculation in yesterday’s unpublished draft is now explicitly adopted by PM.
@@ 104,7 106,7 @@
- [Mechanical Interfaces And Opening Quantities35](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Mechanical%20Interfaces%20And%20Opening%20Quantities) preparation closed533 at11:35:17, final2e604fc2 (44,079 bytes), after one critique/response, twelve independently verified parent revisions and two narrow PM532 collar fixes. Home is now08f8dde6 and Information9ca194c2; the other ten retain530 revisions. Counts/owner branches are unchanged.
- [Campaign Evidence And State Crosswalk36](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Campaign%20Evidence%20And%20State%20Crosswalk) closed545 at11:49:32, final70e004e9 (28,144 bytes), after one critique/response and PM integration. It maps 8 existing chains,15 scenes and26 evidence INDEX entries—not26 new objects or single captures—with7 host variants,5 personal variants and2 Regional25 orders. Optional parent tags were declined; no handoff remains. Lead stopped36 at closeout; PM36 remains STOPPED. Lead’s current38 administrative assignment is separate.
- Scope and development handoff refresh37 ([Production Scope](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Production%20Scope); [Development And Validation Handoff](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Development%20And%20Validation%20Handoff)) closed550 at12:05:47 after response549 at11:58:19, ONE critique547 and independent factual verification. Final Production68db46ea/Handoff59945901,21,243/27,529 bytes; both Systems STOPPED. The14–26 role-hour allowance at response549 included37 response/disposition4–8 plus coherence10–18. With37 closed, only **10–18 role-hours for coherence/repair disposition** remains forward work. M4 **350–590 role-hours** and the future packet **289–490 role-hours /5–8 working weeks** are low-confidence conditional estimating proposals, not logged labor or development authority.
-
- [V1 Readiness38](/Hold%20The%20Flood/V1%20Readiness) assigned551–553 for the existing final coherence/readiness obligation. Lead551 and Systems552 are WORKING on38; Reviewer553 is WORKING on independent criteria. Receiving/full contracts were verified at12:06:22/27 for Lead,12:06:18/22 for Systems and12:07:16/21 for Reviewer. Lead owns only the new administrative V1 Readiness article; Systems supplies a local factual audit for the same38 outcome; Reviewer prepares independent criteria before ONE critique of the actual stopped submission. Draft13:30 (12:45–14:30), reviewed16:00 (14:30–18:00); no new game content or scope.
+
- [V1 Readiness38](/Hold%20The%20Flood/V1%20Readiness) assigned551–553 for the existing final coherence/readiness obligation. Lead557 and Systems555 are STOPPED after their38 submissions; Reviewer558 is WORKING on the ONE combined critique after criteria554. Receiving558 and the full contract were verified at12:14:39/44. Receiving/full contracts were verified at12:06:22/27 for Lead,12:06:18/22 for Systems and12:07:16/21 for Reviewer. Lead owns only the new administrative V1 Readiness article; Systems supplies a local factual audit for the same38 outcome; Reviewer saved independent criteria554 and is conducting ONE critique of the stopped submission and audit. Draft13:30 (12:45–14:30), reviewed16:00 (14:30–18:00); no new game content or scope.
- Five unanswered owner questions and unadopted intake407 remain. All original roles resumed490. M3 now targets14 September (11–18), low confidence; M2/M4 remain unchanged. The144–247 allowance remains dated. Yesterday’s F1.14 drafts were not published.
## Open and closed outcomes
@@ 150,7 152,7 @@
|35|[Mechanical Interfaces And Opening Quantities35](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Mechanical%20Interfaces%20And%20Opening%20Quantities)|Closed|Reviewed conditional interfaces/quantities; no gameplay validation|9Sep11:35:17 closeout533, final2e604fc2|One critique/response, twelve-parent alignment and two532 fixes verified. Mechanical35/ten parents Systems STOPPED; Home/Information PM STOPPED. Owner choices and M4 variants remain|
|36|[Campaign Evidence And State Crosswalk36](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Campaign%20Evidence%20And%20State%20Crosswalk)|Closed|Finite8-chain/15-scene crosswalk;26 evidence INDEX entries, not26 new objects|9Sep11:49:32 closeout545, final70e004e9 (28,144 bytes)|One critique/response and PM integration verified;7 host variants/5 personal variants/2 Regional25 orders. PM owns36 STOPPED; Lead STOPPED. Optional parent tags declined; no transfer needed. Prior reviewed14:00 target achieved|
|37|Scope and development handoff refresh37 ([Production Scope](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Production%20Scope); [Development And Validation Handoff](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Development%20And%20Validation%20Handoff))|Closed|Reviewed scope/packet planning proposal; no development authority|9Sep12:05:47 closeout550; response54911:58:19; final68db46ea/59945901|ONE critique/response and exact factual verification.21,243/27,529 bytes; both Systems STOPPED. Prior15:00 reviewed target achieved; only10–18 coherence role-hours remains forward|
-
|38|[V1 Readiness38](/Hold%20The%20Flood/V1%20Readiness)|Open — assignments551–553 sent|Previously planned final coherence/readiness assessment and supporting audit; no new game scope|Lead/Systems WORKING38; Reviewer criteria WORKING; all receiving/full contracts verified|Lead administrative draft13:30 (12:45–14:30); Systems support13:00 (12:30–14); Reviewer criteria12:45; ONE critique, at most ONE response, reviewed16:00 (14:30–18). PM decides M2/M3|
+
|38|[V1 Readiness38](/Hold%20The%20Flood/V1%20Readiness)|Open — ONE critique558 underway|Previously planned final coherence/readiness assessment and supporting audit; no new game scope|Lead557/Systems555 STOPPED after submissions; Reviewer558 WORKING, receiving/full contract verified|Lead administrative draft13:30 (12:45–14:30); Systems support13:00 (12:30–14); Reviewer criteria12:45; ONE critique, at most ONE response, reviewed16:00 (14:30–18). PM decides M2/M3|
## Recent delivery timeline
@@ 188,13 190,13 @@
|[Mechanical Interfaces And Opening Quantities35](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Mechanical%20Interfaces%20And%20Opening%20Quantities)|Preparation closed533 at11:35:17; final2e604fc2; prior13:00 target achieved|Use reviewed interfaces/quantities and exact aligned parents; no second review or phase authorization|
|[Campaign Evidence And State Crosswalk36](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Campaign%20Evidence%20And%20State%20Crosswalk)|Preparation closed545 at11:49:32, final70e004e9; prior14:00 target achieved|Use accepted8-chain/15-scene/26-index crosswalk in whole-v1 coherence. PM owns36 STOPPED; no parent transfer needed|
|Scope and development handoff refresh37 ([Production Scope](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Production%20Scope); [Development And Validation Handoff](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Development%20And%20Validation%20Handoff))|Closed550 at12:05:47, final68db46ea/59945901; Systems STOPPED|Use accepted scope/packet in38; no second37 review|
-
|[V1 Readiness38](/Hold%20The%20Flood/V1%20Readiness)|Lead/Systems WORKING38; Reviewer criteria WORKING; all receiving/full contracts verified. One administrative result with local factual support|Draft13:30 (12:45–14:30), support13:00 (12:30–14), criteria12:45, reviewed16:00 (14:30–18)|
+
|[V1 Readiness38](/Hold%20The%20Flood/V1%20Readiness)|Lead557/Systems555 STOPPED after submissions; Reviewer558 WORKING, receiving/full contract verified. One administrative result with local factual support|Draft13:30 (12:45–14:30), support13:00 (12:30–14), criteria12:45, reviewed16:00 (14:30–18)|
|Additional proposal intake|Both full pages read; explicitly unadopted|Track authorship and assess protected retreat/next-shift meeting before integrating|
|Shared integration04|Preparation closed518 at11:07:24 after accepted [Death Shift And Rescue Continuity](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Death%20Shift%20And%20Rescue%20Continuity) candidate577236e7 and eleven verified parent alignments|All affected parents and Continuity STOPPED under current533 ownership. No further04 review; owner-dependent branches and remaining whole-v1 interfaces stay explicit|
-
|Original Claude Lead/Reviewer|Original roles resumed490; identities unchanged|Lead551 readiness and Reviewer553 independent criteria WORKING after verified receiving/full contracts. Existing Systems552 supports the same38 outcome; earlier35/36/37 reviews complete|
+
|Original Claude Lead/Reviewer|Original roles resumed490; identities unchanged|Lead557 and Systems555 submitted/STOPPED. Reviewer558 WORKING after verified receiving/full contract; criteria554 complete; earlier35/36/37 reviews complete|
|Additional specialist setup|No extra agent required today; no new sessions created|Technical/production candidate10Sep only for concrete independent handoff scope; optional campaign integration only for an actual gap|
-
Current ownership through553: Lead owns only the new administrative V1 Readiness article for38. Systems552 has local factual-support work and no new article ownership. Reviewer553 prepares independent criteria then ONE critique; Lead551 and Systems552 are WORKING on38; Reviewer553 is WORKING on independent criteria. All existing game articles retain their STOPPED owners, including Systems’ two37 parents, Mechanical35 and ten mechanical parents; PM36/Home/Information remain STOPPED. Any actual parent repair requires a later explicit transfer; none is assumed here.
+
Current ownership through558: Lead owns only the new administrative V1 Readiness article for38. Systems552 has local factual-support work and no new article ownership. Reviewer553 criteria554 are complete; ONE critique558 is underway; Lead557 and Systems555 are STOPPED after their38 submissions; Reviewer558 is WORKING on the ONE combined critique after criteria554. Receiving558 and the full contract were verified at12:14:39/44. All existing game articles retain their STOPPED owners, including Systems’ two37 parents, Mechanical35 and ten mechanical parents; PM36/Home/Information remain STOPPED. Any actual parent repair requires a later explicit transfer; none is assumed here.
