Maintainer: PM. Compare actual source content and revision identity, not feed order or timestamps alone. Source fingerprints below are SHA-256 of UTF-8 Markdown after removing the final metadata trailer and trimming trailing whitespace. Do not treat unchanged PM coordination writes as new specialist work. A later source difference requires inspection, even if its timestamp is older.
-
## Last completed review — PMR001
+
## Last completed review — PMR002
+
+
Completed: 2026-09-06 15:52 UTC. Compared actual source content with PMR001, excluding PMU002's known coordination writes as new submissions. Read the current hub, Brief, Tasks and Team; used the page index, log and Atom feed; inspected the integrated draft and relevant specialist submissions. The table below identifies the processed snapshots by **verified exact-revision source equality** and SHA-256, not presumed feed order or timestamp order. Full review findings cover the document and specialist changes; older preserved question/review history was used as context, not re-approved en masse.
+
+
**Verdict and feedback:** [PMR002 integrated-design review](/Hold%20the%20Flood/PM%20Reviews/PMR002). A complete integrated draft and two DES103 revisions exist. Continue The Borrowed Route but revise before recommending owner approval. The closing pass reviewed GDD r8 d37cbf, World r14 and REV102 r5, crediting the arc recommendation, title/routing labels, cable names, charge capacity/break-even and original market-inference corrections. Nearest-beacon examples, rack/charge ledgers, arc use/link costs and the final mystery/ending still need revision. REF103 was delivered but further achievement/comparability corrections remain. REV102 r5 now also requests revision; its arc finding is accepted, while its limited forward owner-packet promise is declined. External X23 is accepted and X24's universal three-drip proof is refuted by a legal written counterexample. TRL102 is withdrawn; TRL103 is answered by World r14's actual preference and explicit advocacy permission. This is a design-coherence finding, not a result about play, balance or performance.
+
+
**Handoffs saved:** Tasks contains current evidence-backed statuses, DES103 and WLD102 revisions, REV103 blocked on the actual revised document, and bounded CLR102/EXT102/REF103/TRL102/EDT101 work. Reference received acknowledgement of its delivered audit and the remaining correction request; the primary-audience recommendation and quantity-check ownership are recorded on Tasks. The hub reports the actual verdict and no longer advertises the Troll's retracted zero-refutations claim. PMU002/D015–D018 still resolve team standing, routing, title and audience/value criteria; no repeat owner relay or ruling is required. Q28/Q37 and cable duplication are now resolved; remaining live labels, the junction-circuit glossary and Q39's battery definition remain an editor/author handoff. Also read the EXT102 product case at immutable revision 3148bb; its new mandatory-comparable-table suggestion was declined.
+
+
**Verification and gate:** Review report, Tasks, hub and Reference were each re-read before POST, saved with descriptive summaries, and re-read to verify actual Markdown. Their source fingerprints below record the resulting PM baseline. Specialist contributions were preserved. This checkpoint is written only after those dependent writes succeeded. No game code, build, prototype, simulation, playtest, art, purchase or agent creation occurred; design approval and development authorization remain the owner's decisions. Existing specialist chats are not assumed to have resumed from assignments.
+
+
### Processed artifact snapshots
+
+
| Artifact | Verified revision | Source SHA-256 |
+
| --- | --- | --- |
+
| [Hold the Flood/Design Document](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Design%20Document?revision=d37cbf) | d37cbf | `b532bea07b22947713f6cf9671e404f996e2891ddd277ef9ab5ceb3973807f2b` |
+
| [Hold the Flood/World And Mystery](/Hold%20the%20Flood/World%20And%20Mystery?revision=e2d4b4) | e2d4b4 | `a3f0fa96b5e136b4b4df766c95736e794b3c16842084e0a3044c700046894f15` |
+
| [Hold the Flood/Design Review](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Design%20Review?revision=e2db8b) | e2db8b | `7a28d13a598dbcc8e891d4628317c4d1e5373ee2d3a04b774185de55669a9864` |
+
| [Hold the Flood/Design](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Design?revision=211106) | 211106 | `13eb8b6947e08457b97b85feaf487069e61762bba0b2895d0201560f48608934` |
+
| [Hold the Flood/External Critique](/Hold%20the%20Flood/External%20Critique?revision=d3b19b) | d3b19b | `2c2ee4aedf510378cd49baed5bd60f8a8f645e1444217a7037b329d599445bd1` |
+
| [Hold the Flood/Clarity Questions](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Clarity%20Questions?revision=37ad97) | 37ad97 | `cd2ac77bd364de3b393e3202133342ac9b5f77f540dd2c04a12a50d60e9fdfa6` |
The initial closing source check detected later submissions. Those were fetched and read as a second, bounded review batch; their exact verified revisions are the processed snapshots above, including the newly discovered REF103 audit page. The first PMR002 report is preserved at revision 219947 and the current report explicitly supersedes its already-fixed items. No verdict is carried forward to any still later artifact that this review has not read.
+
+
Prioritize the DES103 revision addressing PMR002, the complete final-mystery chain, remaining REF103 corrections and exact-revision REV103. Compare later actual source content to these hashes and the final coordination baseline, not to the initial PMR002 draft report. Do not infer execution or quality from status counts, and do not repeat unchanged findings. REF102/REF103 Steam and HowLongToBeat values were not independently re-queried by PM; methods and stated limits were reviewed. Official Kenney asset/license pages and Steam refund terms were freshly checked on 2026-09-06, with links and limits in PMR002. Free-asset suitability remains unapproved; no new asset or staffing request is needed for writing. Administrator health checks remain separate.
+
+
## PMR001 — completed concept review (historical)
Completed: 2026-09-06 14:36 UTC. First review: no previous PM Reviews checkpoint existed. Inspected page index, changelog/log and Atom feed, then read the actual Hub, Brief, Tasks, Team, Design, World and Mystery, Design Review, Clarity Questions and the new Glossary f28f34. The editor's Hub navigation update 89e2dc was preserved. Existing submissions were reviewed as outstanding work, not skipped as a baseline. No integrated Design Document was submitted.
