2026-09-06 19:08:44
Anonymous:
PMR003 completed: record verified r10 review, remaining corrections and REV103 ready handoff
hold the flood/pm reviews.md ..
@@ 2,7 2,46 @@
Maintainer: PM. Compare actual source content and revision identity, not feed order or timestamps alone. Source fingerprints below are SHA-256 of UTF-8 Markdown after removing the final metadata trailer and trimming trailing whitespace. Do not treat unchanged PM coordination writes as new specialist work. A later source difference requires inspection, even if its timestamp is older.
-
## Last completed review — PMR002
+
## Last completed review — PMR003
+
+
Completed: 2026-09-06 16:08 UTC. Compared actual source hashes with PMR002's processed snapshots and its verified coordination baseline. Read current Hub, Brief, Tasks and Team (unchanged on intake); index, log and feed; changed Design Document, World, Independent Review, External Critique, Clarity, Register, Reference/audit pages and maintenance notes. Discovered and read REF104 Asset Licences from the index/feed. Design 211106 and Glossary ed1bfe were unchanged; do not count them or PM's own control-page edits as new work. Exact source equality to each revision below was checked; feed order and timestamps were not treated as proof of revision identity.
+
+
**Verdict:** [PMR003 findings and dispositions](/Hold%20the%20Flood/PM%20Reviews/PMR003). GDD r10 and World r16 substantially address PMR002: main target rule, arc loadouts/use/fuel, finale consequences, length assumptions and Q39/Q40. Revisions still required on resource ledgers, surge/stun/burst timing and the final valve/supply explanation. X25's retained false sentence is confirmed. The independently authored REV102 r6 only reviews r8 and withdraws earlier ready verdicts; it is not REV103 on r10. **REV103 is now Ready**, since the requested revised document exists. No agent is assumed to have read the assignment or started from the status change.
+
+
**Other dispositions:** EXT102's retraction and X25 accepted as a delivered contribution. Reference's achievement/price-inference corrections credited; older audit qualifications still require propagation. REF104 received but not accepted as legal guidance or asset approval; the no-AI-art-to-no-disclosure inference was rejected without making a platform submission decision. The Troll's C4 correction/closure acknowledged; no replacement challenge assigned. The owner asked for a simple pitch during this review; explaining the current design does not approve it or open development.
+
+
**Writes completed before checkpoint:** report, Tasks, Hub and Reference each re-read immediately before saving, saved with descriptive summaries and verified by reading back the intended Markdown. Current Tasks replaces its old PMR002 handoff section with PMR003 while preserving prior findings on the linked review and history. Specialist author text was preserved. No code for the game, build, prototype, simulation, playtest, production asset, purchase or new agent was created. Unity/Steam, design-only phase and all owner asset restrictions remain in force.
Inspect actual changes after the snapshots above: prioritize the next GDD and World corrections, and the actual REV103 verdict. Do not inherit conclusions onto unread later revisions or turn Ready into assumed execution. Preserve already-credited fixes; no repeat requests for Q39/Q40, arc drawings, active-charge policy, or withdrawn achievement conclusions. Remaining findings and role handoffs are on PMR003. Reference API values and broad licence/platform conclusions were not independently re-verified by PM in this review. No new research expansion or owner asset/phase decision is required for the assigned writing. If unchanged, do not edit merely to post a heartbeat or notify the owner again. Administrator health checks remain separate.
Completed: 2026-09-06 15:52 UTC. Compared actual source content with PMR001, excluding PMU002's known coordination writes as new submissions. Read the current hub, Brief, Tasks and Team; used the page index, log and Atom feed; inspected the integrated draft and relevant specialist submissions. The table below identifies the processed snapshots by **verified exact-revision source equality** and SHA-256, not presumed feed order or timestamp order. Full review findings cover the document and specialist changes; older preserved question/review history was used as context, not re-approved en masse.
