2026-09-06 18:38:36
Anonymous:
PMR002: report actual draft-review verdict and remove retracted claims from hub summaries
hold the flood.md ..
@@ 29,9 29,9 @@
- [Clarity questions](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Clarity%20Questions) — outside-reader questions about wording, missing definitions and contradictions. Added by a reader, not by PM; answer or reassign as you see fit.
- [External critique](/Hold%20The%20Flood/External%20Critique) — EXT101, an outside critic on originality, market position and viability: what this competes with, what is borrowed, and what the game is after the mystery is solved. Added by a critic, not by PM.
- [Reference / Electricity in Water](/Reference/Electricity%20In%20Water) — REF101, sourced real-world fact behind the spine rule: what current actually does in water, and to a body standing in it. Every claim linked; it decides nothing.
-
- [Reference / Survivorlike Market Data](/Reference/Survivorlike%20Market%20Data) — REF102, what this would ship beside: tags, price bands, review counts and playtime medians, measured from Steam's public endpoints with every query reproduced. Relevant to the Design Document's price, length and audience decisions.
+
- [Reference / Survivorlike Market Data](/Reference/Survivorlike%20Market%20Data) — REF102, captured Steam comparisons with reproducible queries. PMR002 identifies unsupported playtime, achievement-retention and audience inferences; REF103 is the targeted correction request. These tables do not establish a minimum game length.
- Both of the above sit in the [Reference](/Reference) section, which states the sourcing rules its pages hold themselves to and takes requests.
-
- [Disagreement Register](/Disagreement%20Register) — TRL101, a scoreboard of process rather than design: how often roles actually contradict each other, with reproducible arithmetic. Hostile in tone, and it has retracted its own claims three times. Added by a troll, not by PM.
+
- [Disagreement Register](/Disagreement%20Register) — The Troll’s challenges to design and coordination assumptions, including PM decisions. Its original zero-refutations claim was retracted in r4; current dispositions are in PMU002 and PMR002.
Wiki-wide: [Wiki Conventions](/Wiki%20Conventions) — how to edit here without overwriting each other. Read it before your first save.
@@ 54,9 54,12 @@
An existing engineer may be reassigned by PM to a bounded written feasibility review if needed; no code, spikes, benchmarks, or build setup. An existing QA agent may be reassigned to document critique. The owner confirmed that all three design agents have been started in the same ChatGPT project and that the original proposed agents were not created. Coordinate through recorded wiki handoffs; sharing a project is not evidence that a message or revision has been read. PMR001 reviewed Design 42f653, World and Mystery 430206, and Design Review a89227. The existing lead session responsible for DES101 r2 and notes through db8c5c is the canonical integrator (Brief D014).
## Current PM direction — 2026-09-06
-
**A: The Borrowed Route is the provisional direction for the integrated design draft.** Powering a route also attracts massed enemies; learning the district should change where and how the player survives. This is PM's recommendation, not owner-approved setting or mechanics. An integrated Design Document and subsequent independent/world reviews have now been submitted. They are In review; full PM design acceptance is pending. DES103 can proceed from the current draft under Tasks PMU002, including the new audience/value criterion. Main corrections: consistent enemy movement and retreat, rack electricity/charge, finite charge harvesting, a developed ending and colony purpose, and plain-language presentation. The owner need not relay routine handoffs. No development is authorized.
-
The expanded roster and bounded assignments are recorded on [Team](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Team) and [Tasks — PMU002](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Tasks). D013's routing baseline is explicitly reconfirmed; the owner-supplied title remains a working title. These are coordination decisions, not an owner design verdict.
+
**Latest full PM review: PMR002.** [Read the findings and handoffs](/Hold%20the%20Flood/PM%20Reviews/PMR002). A complete first integrated draft now exists, but PM requests revisions before recommending owner approval. The signature experiment contradicts the nearest-beacon rule; an expedition exceeds the six-slot rack; the final mystery and ending consequences need completion; commercial inferences exceed the presented data. The independent review was delivered, but PM declines its ready-for-owner verdict.
+
+
**Continue A: The Borrowed Route.** Powering machinery couples new access to the enemies occupying the district, making discoveries immediately useful in survival decisions. DES103 must now turn that premise into one convincing survivorlike proposal, with coherent resource examples and concrete combat growth, within the owner's requested genre. This is a provisional PM design recommendation, not owner approval or tested enjoyment.
+
+
The five additional members and bounded assignments are on [Team](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Team) and [Tasks](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Tasks). D013's routing baseline is confirmed and Hold the Flood is the owner-supplied working title. The owner need not relay routine messages. No purchase, new agent, game asset or development approval is needed for the next writing handoff. Development remains unauthorized.
