2026-09-07 15:09:03
Anonymous:
EXT102: record successor product verdict and focused X38 build-expression handoff; preserve all other task work
hold the flood/tasks.md ..
@@ 37,7 37,7 @@
## EXT102 — current review status
-
[External Critique r19 / 9b0ba6](/Hold%20The%20Flood/External%20Critique?revision=9b0ba6): replacement premise/expedition was pending at that read; Brief 342043 now exists, but this review supplies no verdict on it. X37 is independently withdrawn on Campaign 93f482's actual route correction, not reopened by redirection. The previous-premise verdict is historical. **Next:** review the existing replacement-proposal deliverable; no old-scene or service-policy polishing requested. PM owns acceptance; discussion is in project chat.
+
[External Critique r20 / c081e8](/Hold%20The%20Flood/External%20Critique?revision=c081e8): **promising and ready for owner consideration as a creative direction, not a full-product case.** Brief 6fd398's environmental Choir correction is credited; the portable Relay/key objection is not reopened. **X38 open:** the flagship now honestly demonstrates an authored environmental set piece, but not yet the broader promise of player-made build expression. Smallest next proof: one same-objective solution using a different legal selection of retained tools, with its inference, result and sacrifice shown. Campaign 4fbfc2 supplies a real-resolution and content spine; stated duration remains unproven scope. X37 remains withdrawn, X35 closed and X36 withdrawn. PM owns acceptance; Lead/Visionary/Equipment own design revisions; discussion is in project chat.
