2026-09-07 11:20:12
Anonymous:
PMR008: advance scoped checkpoint after verified review, task and Hub saves
hold the flood/pm reviews.md ..
@@ 1,5 1,21 @@
# Hold the Flood — PM Reviews
+
## PMR008 — latest completed scoped design review
+
+
**Completed 2026-09-07.** [Findings, dispositions, exact revisions and source hashes](/Hold%20the%20Flood/PM%20Reviews/PMR008). Compared actual current intake with PMR007; PMU008's unchanged staffing/coordination was not counted as specialist progress. Read Hub, Brief, Tasks, Team, index, log and feed. Matched the report's immutable source revisions to the captured intake by exact Markdown equality. This supersedes the unpublished PMR008 drafts, not the Visionary-first priority.
+
+
**Disposition:** DES105 r2 and REV105 r2 delivered, with creative closure withheld on the long wait/Siphon value and a new expiry-versus-extraction accounting correction. World/Colony targeted changes, Combat countersign/copy repairs, Build Paths shelter reconciliation, Collector notches, Enemies accounting removal and Districts revisit audit accepted within report scope. Exchange retains four cells plus cadence/terminal integration. Equipment's mistaken reorder was reversed; Q52 remains open. X35, Q53 and REF112's wrong rejected-artifact comparison have bounded owners. Q54 Hub guidance corrected in the verified save. Initial Visionary synthesis received, concrete expedition/change assessment still awaited.
+
+
**Processed baseline:** use PMR008's snapshot table for only the explicitly read/disposed sections; inherited scopes retain prior review limits. Later successors are not silently processed. Reference formulas/engineering/market/licence claims were not externally reverified; REF112 was reviewed for its local provenance and comparison error. Index and maintenance discovery alone do not establish design progress. Do not repeat unchanged findings as new work.
+
+
**Write verification:** fresh target reads preceded saves; report, Tasks and Hub were fetched afterward and matched intended Markdown exactly before this checkpoint. Specialist contributions and the Visionary's Brief/Hub text were preserved. Targeted Hub navigation/status edits retain their earlier text in revision history. These hashes identify PM outputs, not new specialist work:
+
+
- [Hold the Flood/PM Reviews/PMR008](/Hold%20the%20Flood/PM%20Reviews/PMR008): `d05b5df1654549c734c8bcd704ff5c21736dd52094a97a64a4c40dee6564aa06`
+
- [Hold the Flood/Tasks](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Tasks): `b3434efafcb581a27c6bb85745ee5c0c746f79fb90916aad13c3598298051189`
+
- [Hold the Flood](/Hold%20the%20Flood): `261bbdda700f0735b61dda2c916928706768d9029ba45507789a3a55cc35b049`
+
+
No new agent, game code, build, prototype, implementation, simulation, playtest, game-asset creation or purchase occurred. No new owner decision is required for the current correction/vision pass; development remains unauthorized.
+
## PMU008 — Visionary staffing and priority change
**2026-09-07 · Coordination update, not an artifact-review checkpoint.** The owner reported creating The Visionary and supplied its mandate to establish a clear identity, challenge any agent and change/remove incompatible mechanics. PM read current Team, Brief, Tasks, Hub and PM Reviews plus index/log and recorded the role and first milestone on existing coordination pages. During the handoff the Visionary published its Game vision section on Brief; the Brief readback mismatch was inspected, its contribution preserved, and the handoff revised to acknowledge receipt and request the next concrete example rather than duplicate its first synthesis. The owner’s criticism of the pitch and PM’s responsibility are explicitly recorded.
