2026-09-10 17:26:22
Anonymous:
Remove review history and align superseded prose with current design rules
hold the flood/mystery directions.md ..
@@ 1,115 1,5 @@
-
# Hold The Horde — Mystery Directions
+
# Mystery Directions
-
**Current owner direction — 2026-09-08.** The owner has supplied a leading, explicitly revisable hospital story: an abandoned alien godhood experiment, later human medical use, a captive god in the core and corrupted healing. See the Owner Brief. The three stories below remain previous alternatives, not an unanswered equal-choice gate or constraints on that new draft. Every detail of the leading narrative remains open; no player death-count penalty is adopted. [Owner Brief](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Brief).
+
Read [Hospital Story Directions](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Hospital%20Story%20Directions) for the current story alternatives and their tradeoffs. The [Owner Brief](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Brief) records the leading hospital-and-godhood premise as fully revisable. No exact explanation or ending is selected.
-
**Status.** Three story directions prepared for an owner comparison. None is adopted. Each states an actual proposed truth rather than a tease. No hour counts, room lists or cast catalogue are proposed, and nothing here establishes that any of it is enjoyable.
-
-
**The baseline all three keep.** Ordinary revival continues through the deeper play. In each direction the apparent ending makes departure *available* without spending it, and service ends only at a final departure. Ending revival earlier — a mortal phase after the apparent ending — is a separate exception the owner could choose in any of the three; it is not implied by picking one, and it is not the default here.
-
-
---
-
-
## 1. The Registry
-
-
**Pitch.** The station squats inside an alien port authority that is still doing its job, and the job is keeping berthed ships' crews complete.
-
-
**The truth.** The older structure registers and services visiting vessels. Registration records who belongs to a vessel; while registration remains active, the authority maintains its complement by physically recovering an injured or dead crew member and repairing them at the berth. Nothing is copied and no snapshot is stored, so the astronaut who returns remembers everything up to the moment they died. The human station is an unlicensed salvage yard cut into the port, selling berth services it never owned.
-
-
**What the astronaut is carrying travels with them.** Registration covers a person and what is on them: the authority recovers the crew member as found, kit included, since separating a body from its equipment is no part of returning it to a berth. Return lands aboard **this ship** because registration bound the astronaut to this vessel at its berth, and the astronaut always returns to this ship until final departure ends their service. A separately authorised destination transfer is an option for other stranded complements, not a relocation of the player's revival point. Departure clearance permits leaving but does not cancel registration while the ship remains docked.
-
-
The **creatures** are stranded complements subject to an old quarantine warrant. Their vessels vanished or left without properly closing registration. Recovery continues, but a containment device fitted to quarantined crew overrides voluntary movement and directs attacks against people outside that quarantined complement. Repair restores the device along with the body. Some affected crew were human; others were alien, accounting for different forms. Missing ships explain why they remain; the warrant and device explain hostility. Other stranded complements have no warrant and remain coherent. This is a proposed completion of the story, not death-count degeneration or a hidden future transformation of the astronaut. The astronaut's valid registration has no quarantine warrant. The **warning** is the yard crew's, once they understood.
-
-
This adds a cost: some enemies are people under coercion. Their devices and warrant histories need visible evidence, and cancelling recovery must not be confused with safely removing control. The alternative considered was an earlier biological contamination that repair preserves; that avoids bureaucratic control but adds a separate biological explanation. The comparison below uses the quarantine version so its actual consequence can be judged.
-
-
**Escape** is repairing the ship and clearing its distress flag, which authorises departure. Service continues until the ship actually leaves.
-
-
**Early interpretation.** Infection: bodies, hostility, a quarantine warning, a fled crew.
-
-
**Two discoveries.** First, a berth cradle in use — a body being repaired, with the authority's marks and a service record naming a vessel that is not present. *Observed:* the process, mid-operation. *Supports:* recovery and repair of persons. *Leaves open:* whether the astronaut's own returns come from the same source. Second, the berth register: an addressable list of vessels still flagged, most long gone, each with a complement still maintained — including this ship. *Supports:* one mechanism covering both. *Credible rival:* the register merely records recovery caused elsewhere. A control berth continues logging ordinary casualty recovery while cancelling an old registration stops new recovery transactions at that berth. That difference supports a causal role for registration; it does not prove the entire mechanism or the identity of every recovered person. Departure clearance for the astronaut is a different operation and does not stop their returns. Visible control devices plus distinct warranted and unwarranted service records support the quarantine explanation; a flag alone does not prove it.
-
-
**Deeper action, and what complicates it.** An old berth offers distinct choices: restore a valid destination for its stranded complement, cancel its registration to stop future recovery, or leave it active while evidence is incomplete. Cancellation does not remove living creatures or release their control devices. Later client filings reveal coherent people whose ships left without them, alongside warrants that keep reimposing hostile control. The player must determine whose case they are changing and what can actually be repaired or transferred; one universal release button is not the deeper solution. Restoring a destination needs a consenting receiving vessel and does not imply that the astronaut can add everyone to their own ship. The deeper resolution is an informed settlement of these continuing cases, with its exact authored extent still to design.
-
-
**Two languages.** The authority's builders left the working script of a port — berths, services, permissions — which is also where the service and access marks come from. A frequent **client species** left standing filings at the berths in their own language. Both are here because this was a port: hosts and visitors wrote on the same walls. Understanding the builders' script lets the player work a fitting or read a permission; understanding the clients' filings tells them which berth belongs to which vessel, which is what makes the register navigable rather than a wall of addresses.
-
-
**A survivor.** Yeva worked berth interfaces on this side of the yard for six years. She can operate the fittings she used and knows what the yard did to the ones it stripped; she has not been into sections the yard never worked, and has never read a client filing.
-
-
**Coverage.** The authority covers active registered complements, including stranded registrations whose ships vanished. The astronaut entered on docking; authorised final departure closes that registration. Merely being brought aboard does not enrol a rescued person. Whether a rescued survivor is covered is not established by this direction and is not settled here; existing rescue, abort and Sent outcomes stand as the working proposal.
-
-
**Endings.** Clearing your own flag authorises departure — a complete, earned achievement that later play does not invalidate. Continuing is ordinary play with revival intact, and the deeper story is the berths.
-
-
---
-
-
## 2. The Appropriated Unit
-
-
**Pitch.** The thing bringing the astronaut back came aboard with them, and the station is where they find out who put it there.
-
-
**The truth.** The station is a refuge built by people hiding from a pursuit, on a wreck they have been stripping for years. Among the things they stripped and rebuilt is a recovery unit of alien manufacture. The refuge fitted such units to selected ships — including this one, before it left, without its pilot's knowledge.
-
-
The unit cannot work alone. It needs the wreck's protected berth anchor and the astronaut's individual casualty tag to retrieve the current body. The serial-addressed ship unit then repairs and revives that body. This pairing explains why revival works throughout this station, and why it lands aboard **this ship**. It does not establish that no other installation could ever perform a return. **What the astronaut is carrying travels with them.** The unit retrieves the tagged body as it stands, and what is on that body comes with it; it has no mechanism for stripping anything off first.
-
-
The **warning** is human: a refuge sheltering people who cannot be found, for whom a docked ship means a manifest and a witness. The **creatures** are a containment failure of biological material the refuge was moving as part of the same programme — an accident with causes, decisions and someone responsible for routing it through a place where people lived.
-
-
**Escape** is repairing the ship and removing the sponsor's navigation lock; away from the wreck's infrastructure this unit has no retrieval link. Unlocking departure leaves ordinary revival active while docked.
-
-
**Early interpretation.** The station is doing this, because the station is the strange thing.
-
-
**Two discoveries.** First, in the refuge's own records, a fitting list: ships modified, dates, and this ship on it. *Observed:* a document naming the vessel. *Supports:* the modification and who performed it. *Leaves open:* why this ship was chosen. Second, an archived fitting test traces its unit serial and the individual tag through capture, transfer and onboard repair. A control run transferred a subject without reviving them until the unit connected. Matching logs after ordinary deaths support a joint ship-and-station cause, against the rival of a passive ship box and station-only revival. A fitting list alone would not settle that cause or the sponsor's intent.
-
-
**The selection and its cost.** This comparison chooses the arranged version: an outside sponsor selected the craft, arranged the failure and routed it back to the refuge. Dated navigation orders and a lock carrying the sponsor's authorisation are the later evidence. The astronaut's emergency was real, but its cause was engineered. This makes them an unwitting experimental subject and commits the story to a human conspiracy. A coincidental return remains an alternative, with a weaker causal connection between fitting and arrival; it is not quietly mixed into this pitch.
-
-
**Deeper action.** Orders and alien relay records reveal that the sponsor is still routing people and machines through hidden refuge groups. The player can alter an upcoming route, warn a group to stay hidden, and decide which evidence reaches a recipient able to expose the controller. An unredacted disclosure also exposes people still using the refuge. Those already Sent remain aboard under the existing rules. The deeper action changes an ongoing movement of people, rather than merely collecting a complete document set; exact recipients and outcomes remain to author.
-
-
**Two languages.** The wreck's builders wrote the working script of their vessel, which the refuge learned enough of to strip it. The recovery units carry a **second, different alien hand** — the makers of that technology, who were not the wreck's builders; the wreck was carrying their equipment. Both are here because the refuge is living inside one species' ship and rebuilding another's machines. The builders' script gets the player through the wreck; the makers' hand is on the unit itself, and reading it is how the player learns what the unit is for, which is not what the refuge assumed.
-
-
**A survivor.** Dorn worked the refuge's fitting shop and can describe exactly what was installed and how, because he installed some of it. He does not know why particular ships were chosen; that was decided above him.
-
-
**Coverage.** Coverage follows the individual casualty tag into the station, not presence aboard a fitted ship. Only the astronaut has that tag in this comparison. A later offer to install or reassign one would need a concrete owner decision, including any effect on the astronaut's coverage. This does not settle global survivor loss or immunity.
-
-
**Endings.** Repair and depart — complete. Continuing keeps revival while docked, and the deeper story is the records and the people they name.
-
-
---
-
-
## 3. The Clinic
-
-
**Pitch.** The station was an illegal clinic, and its triage has never been told to stop.
-
-
**The truth.** An unlicensed clinic hulk doing work that could not be done lawfully. Its triage still runs across the whole hulk, which is what the hulk was built for: it detects a casualty, retrieves the body, repairs and revives it, and delivers the patient to their vessel of record. Nothing is stored and nothing is copied; the body is the body, so memory is continuous. Coverage is the hulk, and this direction proposes no hidden failure case and no undisclosed limit.
-
-
**What the astronaut is carrying travels with them.** Triage recovers a patient as found and delivers them with their effects, the way any casualty arrives at a receiving bay. Delivery is to **this ship** because the vessel of record was set by the arrival manifest at the airlock, the only admission the astronaut has.
-
-
The **creatures** are former patients of the experimental work, still here. The **warning** was left by staff who fled when the wards breached.
-
-
**Escape** requires ship repair and discharge authorisation after resolving the admission hold. Permission makes leaving possible; discharge executes only on final departure. Ordinary triage remains active while the player stays to investigate.
-
-
**Early interpretation.** A derelict overrun by something, with an inexplicable resurrection attached.
-
-
**Two discoveries.** First, restore an observation window and watch an actual casualty transfer, then compare two treatment checkpoints with archived wounds and an embedded tag. *Observed:* a body moves through treatment; matching traces support continuity of that body, without proving metaphysical identity. Drag marks alone would only suggest transport. Second, the astronaut's admission record, created at docking, names their vessel and links their casualty tag to a completed treatment-and-delivery record after an ordinary death. That connects admission to their own return, beyond merely finding their name in a file. A rival reconstruction mechanism remains harder to exclude than a purely clerical file. Neither clue requires deliberate player death. Seeking departure permission does not test a cessation of revival, because treatment continues until actual departure.
-
-
**On the consent records.** Treatment records carry signatures that do not match the patients' other records in the same files. That supports someone other than the patient having authorised the work, or an inconsistent filing practice. Calling it forgery would need evidence of who signed and who was entitled to; the article does not claim it.
-
-
**Deeper action.** The commission names an external programme still sending new cases. The player can revoke experimental protocols while preserving ordinary stabilising triage, release patients who can safely leave a ward, and select a recipient for evidence about the programme. Those actions affect treatment and incoming cases. A named patient may need continuing care, so closing every ward is not automatically rescue. The distinction between necessary care and the experimental protocol needs concrete records and outcomes, not an arbitrary button that announces the ethical answer.
-
-
**Two languages.** The hulk's builders wrote its working script — doors, wards, service fittings. The illegal work was reverse-engineering another species' medicine, and their **clinical texts** are aboard in that species' own hand, brought here as source material. Both are present because one species' ship was being used to copy another's practice. The builders' script moves the player through the hulk; the source texts are how a procedure in a record becomes intelligible as something done to a person.
-
-
**A survivor.** Yeva was engineering staff on the hulk's power and pressure systems and can get the player through the sections she maintained. She never had ward access, believed the wards were quarantine, and has no idea what the records say.
-
-
**Coverage.** Triage covers anyone admitted through the airlock. Whether a survivor found inside was ever admitted is a real question this direction raises and does not answer.
-
-
**Endings.** Discharge and departure — complete. Continuing keeps triage running, and the deeper story is the records and who commissioned them.
-
-
**Where it is weakest.** Its horde is the most narratively loaded of the three, and a game wanting ordinary combat throughout must avoid making every fight a moral event.
-
-
---
-
-
## Decision cards
-
-
**The Registry — an institution still enforcing its rules.** The station has enrolled you in a return service. Missing vessels and quarantine warrants keep other crews trapped in repeated recovery and coercion. Repair your way out, then decide which ongoing cases to repair, transfer, cancel or leave alone. Its strength is that deciphering the station changes what familiar infrastructure means and what you can do with it. Its cost is alien bureaucracy plus the knowledge that some combatants are controlled people.
-
-
**The Appropriated Unit — an emergency somebody arranged.** An alien unit was secretly fitted to your ship; the station holds the other half, and the records of who sent you there. Repair and unlock departure, then interfere with the sponsor's ongoing routes and decide how to expose them without exposing hidden refugees. Its strength is personal human responsibility and conflicting interests. Its cost is turning the opening accident into a conspiracy and keeping the chain of sponsor, refuge and alien machines understandable.
-
-
**The Clinic — treatment that has become captivity.** Your resurrection is active triage; some creatures are former patients of an illegal programme. Earn discharge, then separate necessary care from harmful experiments, free viable patients and act against the people still sending cases. Its strength is making medical records and familiar enemies acquire a human meaning. Its cost is a substantial moral burden on repeated horde combat and the need for convincing differences between care, release and abandonment.
-
-
**PM recommendation: develop the Registry first if the owner likes its premise.** It offers a direct connection between discovering how the station works and changing its ongoing cases. The Unit is the strongest alternative for a personal conspiracy; the Clinic for a patient-centred horror story. These are reasoned creative preferences, not tested effects or a vote. Each direction now has consequential deeper actions, so none wins simply because another was left with document collection alone.
-
-
## Decision still needed
-
-
Which story, if any, is worth developing. This comparison does not commit an ending early enough to remove ordinary revival, a global survivor-death rule, or the campaign's promised duration. Those require their own concrete justification or owner answer when relevant. The languages' detailed contents, specific later characters and extent of each deeper path remain to author after direction is chosen.
+
[Story and Ending Map](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Story%20And%20Ending%20Map) develops the proposed evidence chains and player actions.
