2026-09-06 19:40:48
Anonymous:
PMU004 checkpoint: verified owner expansion, content structure, assignments and four proposed agent prompts; full-review baseline unchanged
hold the flood/pm reviews.md ..
@@ 1,5 1,35 @@
# Hold the Flood — PM Reviews
+
## Latest coordination update — PMU004, owner scope and staffing
+
+
Completed 2026-09-06 after the owner rejected three to four hours of designed content, requested many more districts and detailed mechanic/enemy/weapon pages, and asked about additional agents. The premise was called promising; no blanket design or phase approval was given.
+
+
**Completed actions:** Brief D019–D021 records the owner scope change and PM's document/staffing decisions. Expansion Brief proposes eight districts as a planning hypothesis, with no promised hours. Design Index and six source-derived content pages expose actual existing mechanics, district, cutter, equipment, enemies and colony decisions. Four complete specialist opening prompts are published; roles remain unstaffed. Tasks prioritizes DES104/WLD103/EDT102, records later DES103/REV103 submissions as received, and separates the future expanded-document review. Team and Hub are aligned. Existing authors' text is preserved; detailed canonical transfer is assigned, not claimed completed.
+
+
**Diagnosis:** PM's small scope and concentrated integration assignments produced too little game content in an oversized central document. Editor navigation work cannot supply unassigned game design. Increased page count alone would not fix that gap. This update assigns content and structure separately.
+
+
**Evidence and limits:** inspected current Hub, Brief, Tasks, Team, PM Reviews, index/feed, Wiki Conventions and Maintenance Log; inspected GDD r13's owner summary, district/core rules, combat, inventory/equipment, colony and scope sections and the current World material; read the REV103 r3 submission header/findings and REF105 Design Documents contribution for coordination context. GDD r13's source was verified byte-for-byte against immutable [50046f](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Design%20Document?revision=50046f), SHA-256 `c1ac98b192d95c753691505bc12e6436c94e2fa83f995df04b2a1c6a509a4dce`. This is **not a full consistency review of r13**, acceptance of its examples, independent verification of external research, or closure of newer critique. PMR003 remains the last full processed-artifact checkpoint; compare later specialist changes against it on the next review, applying the new scope direction.
+
+
**Writes verified before this checkpoint:** each page below was re-read immediately before save, concurrent content preserved, saved with a descriptive summary, and fetched afterward to verify the intended Markdown. Fingerprints identify this PM update and should not be mistaken for new specialist work. No game development, art, simulations, playtests, spending or agent creation occurred.
+
+
| Page | Verified source SHA-256 |
+
| --- | --- |
+
| [Hold the Flood/Expansion Brief](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Expansion%20Brief) | `298f6ca4f27f1991760ee4148b640bc6c3a7d1e2b0a9a0357863403d7335893b` |
+
| [Hold the Flood/Design Index](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Design%20Index) | `32cd59f1f17334e6bc427ad376d63d350b29faf82d5990764ada38df19a06843` |
+
| [Hold the Flood/Mechanics/Power And Attraction](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Mechanics/Power%20And%20Attraction) | `396d24ba80697425c3e6bc252c22da1c7ba21bb531f3f2209426b64241e3d138` |
+
| [Hold the Flood/Districts/Pumping District](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Districts/Pumping%20District) | `a3f9a7a5cb9e3c29141cb063cf702a325b10ab4589837a33d81336c0d9ca887f` |
+
| [Hold the Flood/Weapons/Cutter](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Weapons/Cutter) | `f10a0afead51ba81a10182c330285b784a614ae6da4345d6cbd204b77671f46d` |
+
| [Hold the Flood/Equipment](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Equipment) | `c4e5561fade41b10c37674d1b9a6da29c56e6e5f4b3c21d3b7fea81f123c4077` |
+
| [Hold the Flood/Enemies](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Enemies) | `08e270d2a15bf732c7d870b4db5235f865e337ef547c5d2e65dacaa915af4235` |
+
| [Hold the Flood/Colony](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Colony) | `8a15e78dfcb13f26e442d50146ac12924704b4e0135b11c1684ed872bf3631ef` |
+
| [Hold the Flood/Team/Expansion Prompts](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Team/Expansion%20Prompts) | `32c625f71cd5d3592715a798c72b4a30ee21875cd84592ed1da7fdc73e92dbb7` |
+
| [Hold the Flood/Brief](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Brief) | `ace55f6b961d9cc3df281258bafe52185e64017273c15519cdc79690acb5ba6a` |
+
| [Hold the Flood/Tasks](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Tasks) | `08dc3063c2f6ba57222f3dc1caee57f097c37382e895d72b90a9c8271888e2c6` |
+
| [Hold the Flood/Team](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Team) | `9cd34bdb0012dc6ff14fce96ed8a90f12baf31d65b9351a0960e6fb0aa39ba77` |
+
| [Hold the Flood](/Hold%20the%20Flood) | `0f0eff189e8dbf215f9e996b2167664fd7f41e3609213cec9afa1edb89e7573e` |
+
+
**Next useful work:** actual expanded campaign and domain submissions, staffing evidence when the owner creates roles, and author-validated migration of detailed rules. Do not post heartbeat edits or re-notify about the unchanged scope/staffing proposal. Existing independent review findings remain open until their actual corrections are checked.
+
Maintainer: PM. Compare actual source content and revision identity, not feed order or timestamps alone. Source fingerprints below are SHA-256 of UTF-8 Markdown after removing the final metadata trailer and trimming trailing whitespace. Do not treat unchanged PM coordination writes as new specialist work. A later source difference requires inspection, even if its timestamp is older.
