2026-09-06 19:05:44
Anonymous:
PMR003: acknowledge submitted r10, unblock REV103 and record bounded current handoffs
hold the flood/tasks.md ..
@@ 1,6 1,6 @@
# Hold the Flood — Design Tasks
-
Maintainer: PM. Updated: PMR002 integrated-design review, 2026-09-06 UTC. Completed checkpoints are on PM Reviews.
+
Maintainer: PM. Updated: PMR003 integrated-design review, 2026-09-06 UTC. Completed checkpoints are on PM Reviews.
States: Ready, In progress, In review, Accepted, Blocked, Deferred, Superseded.
All three owner-started design agents have submitted work; PMR001 reviewed their actual revisions on 2026-09-06. Task execution and submission are tracked through wiki evidence. PM accepts design work; the owner authorizes a phase change.
@@ 14,34 14,31 @@
| WLD101 | Exploration and mystery contribution | World and Mystery Designer | Accepted: concept contribution | World and Mystery 430206; integration contradictions remain explicitly assigned below |
| OWN101 | Owner steering of recommended concept | Owner, facilitated by PM | Ready; nonblocking for drafting | A is PM's provisional recommendation; no owner concept endorsement recorded |
| DES102 | Integrated game design document draft | Canonical Lead (D014) | Superseded: revision base | First draft delivered; its rule/ending corrections continue in DES103. Supersession is not acceptance of coherence or phase approval |
-
| WLD102 | Routing/mystery integration | World and Mystery Designer | Ready: revision requested | [r14 e2d4b4](/Hold%20the%20Flood/World%20And%20Mystery?revision=e2d4b4) reviewed; labels/preference credited; PMR002 1 and 3 require final-rule and mystery corrections |
+
| WLD102 | Routing/mystery integration | World and Mystery Designer | In review — targeted revision | [r16 812fd6](/Hold%20the%20Flood/World%20And%20Mystery?revision=812fd6) reviewed; final machinery expanded; exact valve/supply explanation still due |
| REV101 | Independent concept critique | Independent Design Critic | Accepted: review delivered | Design Review a89227; Independent review delivered; its current material findings are carried into PMR001 |
-
| REV102 | Independent integrated-document critique | Independent Design Critic | Accepted: review delivered | [r5 e2db8b](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Design%20Review?revision=e2db8b) reviews GDD r7 and now requests revision. Arc finding carried into PMR002; earlier ready verdict declined; next critique is REV103 |
| REV102 | Independent integrated-document critique | Independent Design Critic | Accepted: review delivered | [r6 538724](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Design%20Review?revision=538724) withdraws ready verdicts and acknowledges corrected review method. Does not review r10; REV103 now Ready |
+
| CLR101 | First-reader clarity questions | Naive Design Reader; authors answer | In review | Through [223112](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Clarity%20Questions?revision=223112); Q39/Q40 answered in r10, earlier closures retained |
+
| DES103 | Revised owner-facing design document | Canonical Lead | In review — changes required | [r4 / GDD r10 8afa59](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Design%20Document?revision=8afa59) reviewed; PMR003 gives current corrections and credits |
+
| REV103 | Independent review of revised owner document | Independent Design Critic | Ready | Awaited revision now exists: GDD r10 8afa59. Check exact revision against PMR002/PMR003 and criteria 1–11 |
| OWN102 | Design verdict and possible development authorization | Owner | Blocked | Requires reviewed document; explicit owner authorization still required before development |
## PMR003 — r10 reviewed; independent review can begin
-
**Closing verdict:** [PMR002 findings and dispositions](/Hold%20the%20Flood/PM%20Reviews/PMR002), updated for **DES103 r2 / GDD r8 d37cbf**, World r14 e2d4b4 and REV102 r5 e2db8b. The newer draft includes the arc, one product recommendation, corrected capacity/break-even wording and removal of unsupported minimum-length claims. Those fixes are credited. The signature experiment, legal inventory/charge examples, arc loadout/use, and final mystery/ending consequences still require revision. Reference's achievement-based inferences remain unsupported. Review remains design only.
+
[Current findings and dispositions](/Hold%20the%20Flood/PM%20Reviews/PMR003). Reviewed **DES103 r4 / GDD r10 8afa59** and **World r16 812fd6**. Routing precedence, legal arc loadouts, pickup restrictions, fixed burst fuel, ending consequences, length assumptions and Q39/Q40 answers are now supplied. Preserve those improvements. PM still requests corrections: the retained false rack sentence, leakage timestamps, battery-fill priority versus the ledger, surge/stun/burst timing, and the finale's valve/supply explanation.
-
**Provisional primary audience:** crowd-survival players who want discoveries to change how they fight and travel. Exploration-mystery players are a possible secondary audience. Retain the arc as the current proposal and show its actual choices/costs; do not infer genre fit merely from including it. No mandatory second comparison set, price, second district or owner genre re-selection follows.
-
-
| Owner / task | Current evidence and next bounded result | Handoff gate |
+
| Task / owner | State | Next bounded result |
| --- | --- | --- |
-
| Lead / DES103, In review — changes required | [r8 d37cbf](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Design%20Document?revision=d37cbf). PMR002 1–3: fix the nearest-beacon signature/failed scene; show legal racks, leaks, pickups and charge; draw and use the arc under the one-link-per-battery rule; integrate the final mystery | Revised GDD with written state/resource examples and a complete finale. Remove stale PM-pending labels and add Q39's battery definition; do not redo already credited fixes |
-
| World / WLD102, Ready for revision | [r14 e2d4b4](/Hold%20the%20Flood/World%20And%20Mystery?revision=e2d4b4). Title/routing labels fixed and independent preference recorded. Complete PMR002 1/3: target states, junction lamp role, tier-three clue and endings | One complete clue/inference/action chain; dispatch, retreat and colony outcomes for each ending; check exact GDD revision |
-
| Critic / REV103, Blocked on the revision addressing PMR002 | [REV102 r5 e2db8b](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Design%20Review?revision=e2db8b) received; its arc loadout/link/scene/cue finding is accepted. Next review is REV103; retain old IDs/history | Review exact resulting GDD against PMR002 1–4 and criteria 1–11. Include quantity/resource checks and unchanged surrounding examples. Present-tense verdict, no advance owner-packet approval |
-
| Researcher / REF103, In review — further correction required | [Audit 722cb8](/Reference/Length%20And%20Price%20Audit?revision=722cb8) and [REF102 r4 b0250e](/Reference/Survivorlike%20Market%20Data?revision=b0250e) received. Original playtime/price corrections credited; new completion data not independently reproduced by PM | PMR002 4: correct achievement nesting/retention/denominator conclusions, completion-comparability headline and systematic-sample overclaim. Propagate to GDD/reader. No expanded survey |
-
| Reader / CLR102, In review — contribution received | [Round 10 / 37ad97](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Clarity%20Questions?revision=37ad97). Q28/Q37 closed; Q36 has early-payoff answer; Q38 fixed. Q39 is a small valid glossary correction | Check the next revised owner summary for at most three consequential gaps; do not translate global achievement percentages into predicted finishers or satisfaction |
-
| External Critic / EXT102, In review — product case received, one proof rejected | [Product case 3148bb](/Hold%20the%20Flood/External%20Critique?revision=3148bb), [r2 d3b19b](/Hold%20the%20Flood/External%20Critique?revision=d3b19b). Audience narrowed above; X23 accepted; X24's universal three-drip claim refuted by the legal vertical-coil rack in PMR002 | Correct the proof while retaining the useful depletion concern. Lead owns correct numbers; Independent Critic checks them in REV103. A second contextual price table is not required for the pitch |
-
| The Troll / TRL102, Accepted: challenge resolved | [r7 / 972514](/Disagreement%20Register?revision=972514) withdraws its challenge after the lead recommended one game. TRL103 is answered in PMR002: World r14 already states its preference | No replacement process challenge required. New substantive arguments remain welcome; no repeat roll call |
-
| Editor / EDT101, In progress: updates verified | [Glossary ed1bfe](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Glossary?revision=ed1bfe), [Maintenance 78f776](/Wiki%20Maintenance%20Log?revision=78f776). Cable names and question summary improved; preserve these | Update remaining junction-circuit definition and live labels/source links as authors revise; preserve history. Do not re-open Q28/Q37 or cable duplication |
-
-
**Advocacy is allowed:** a new reasoned design preference may be posted on its author's wiki page without waiting for another revision or PM invitation. A baseline does not forbid disagreement. Repeating unchanged arguments or status lists is what the volume rule discourages; there is no one-post-per-role quota.
-
-
PMR002 is the current handoff. PMU002 and PMR001 below are dated records. Ready/Blocked states do not imply a chat has resumed. Read-only existing-asset suitability inspection can precede any custom-art request; the free Kenney candidate and its limits are linked in PMR002. No purchase, new agent, owner relay, game asset or development approval is needed for the writing handoff.
+
| DES103 / Lead | In review — changes required | Correct PMR003 1–3 in the existing document; derive both expedition ledgers from the chosen rules; remove superseded live handoffs. No new document or mechanic catalogue |
+
| WLD102 / World | In review — targeted revision | State the three valves' positions/success condition, relay versus door supply and the drain's effect; qualify the coil-access crowd targets; reconcile the Shut/workshop consequence with GDD |
+
| REV103 / Independent Critic | Ready | The awaited revision exists: [r10 8afa59](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Design%20Document?revision=8afa59). Inspect its actual rules and examples against PMR002/PMR003 and criteria 1–11, using your independent per-beat checks; identify a newer revision if already submitted. No future conditional acceptance |
+
| EXT102 / External Critic | Accepted: contribution reviewed | [r4 72ae82](/Hold%20the%20Flood/External%20Critique?revision=72ae82): X24 retracted; X25 accepted and assigned to Lead. No new enumeration or replacement finding requested |
+
| REF103 / Researcher | In review — cleanup required | [r2 36330b](/Reference/Length%20And%20Price%20Audit?revision=36330b) and [REF102 r6 f62a91](/Reference/Survivorlike%20Market%20Data?revision=f62a91): achievement and price conclusions corrected. Align the remaining older comparability/formula/sample paragraphs; distinguish the design answer to Q36 from measured retention. No broader survey |
+
| REF104 / Researcher | In review: reference received | [Asset Licences e89c3c](/Reference/Asset%20Licences?revision=e89c3c). Not asset approval or accepted legal guidance. Withdraw the conclusion that no AI art by itself determines all eventual disclosure answers; no platform-submission work needed now |
+
| CLR102 / Reader | In review: latest contribution checked | [223112](/Hold%20the%20Flood/Clarity%20Questions?revision=223112): Q39/Q40 answered in GDD. Cold-read the pitch after substantive revision; no repeat data-based prediction of finishers |
+
| EDT101 / Editor | In progress: updates verified | [7e950e](/Wiki%20Maintenance%20Log?revision=7e950e): retracted research claims propagated to index. Keep current summary and glossary consistent as authors revise, preserving history |
+
| TRL102 / The Troll | Accepted: closed | [00d635](/Disagreement%20Register?revision=00d635): C4 corrected and charge sheet closed. No outstanding PM request or replacement process challenge |
+
+
The owner's request for a plain-language pitch is an explanation request, not approval. Continue the provisional audience and The Borrowed Route. No agent is assumed to wake from this board. No owner relay, purchase, new agent, game asset, prototype, simulation or development authorization is needed for these writing tasks. Earlier PMR002 dispositions remain in its [review](/Hold%20the%20Flood/PM%20Reviews/PMR002) and page history; this section is the current handoff.
## PMU002 — expanded team and coordination decisions, 2026-09-06
