2026-09-14 19:25:19
Anonymous:
Remove text slop: disclaimers, process metadata, restatements and hedge tags; no rule changes (owner readability review, 14 Sep)
hold the flood/story and ending map.md ..
@@ 1,36 1,36 @@
# Hold The Horde — Story And Ending Map
-
**Status.** First-pass SMALL-band proposal: one causal working spine, four mystery/personal chains and choices across apparent, deeper and optional-secret layers. It is not owner-selected canon, a count of endings, a final cast, complete room/scene placement, implementation or evidence of duration. The owner's ancient-experiment/human-hospital/captive-god premise is explicitly fully revisable. “Leading branch” below means the team's concrete version to inspect and revise, not approval.
+
This page proposes one causal spine, four mystery and personal chains, and player choices across apparent, deeper and optional-secret layers; the “leading branch” is the team's concrete version for the owner to inspect and revise. Owner decisions are recorded in the [Owner Brief](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Brief).
## Three levels of authority
| Authority | What currently belongs there | What it does not settle |
|---|---|---|
-
| **Selected gameplay facts** | Death returns the astronaut aboard, shifts the station, preserves selected completed work and returns every still-carried rig/cargo object once. The journal fully pauses. At least two alien languages exist. Survivors form an authored home. Some joins persist, and connecting every actual playable room is deepest/latest. | Why revival or shifts happen; survivor mortality; corruption; a final story; departure/credits; what full connection does to later shifts or endings. |
+
| **Selected gameplay facts** | Death returns the astronaut aboard, shifts the station, preserves selected completed work and returns every still-carried rig/cargo object once. The journal fully pauses. At least two alien languages exist. Survivors form a home. Some joins persist, and connecting every actual playable room is deepest/latest. | Why revival or shifts happen; survivor mortality; corruption; a final story; departure/credits; what full connection does to later shifts or endings. |
| **Owner's fully revisable leading premise** | An ancient alien godhood experiment was abandoned; humans made the station a hospital because healing and revival worked; researchers found a captive alien god; knowledge harmed them, healing machines became harmful, and repeated restoration may relate to creatures. | Every causal link, the being's nature, why the experiment ended, whether death changes the player, and every ending action. |
-
| **Team leading branch, proposed here** | An ancient restoration field repairs living tissue toward a form template. Its experiment produced or bound one ascendant organism in the core; its makers sealed the coupling and left. Humans later opened the containment and inserted hospital treatment profiles. That intervention mixed the core organism's changing morphology into some repair instructions. A docking-registration/intake process returns the astronaut and re-seats unbound architecture after death. | Literal godhood, mind/soul mechanics, alien intent, memory storage, registration details, whether the core process speaks, or any survivor's eligibility. These are working causal facts only if this branch is chosen. |
+
| **Team leading branch** | An ancient restoration field repairs living tissue toward a form template. Its experiment produced or bound one ascendant organism in the core; its makers sealed the coupling and left. Humans later opened the containment and inserted hospital treatment profiles. That intervention mixed the core organism's changing morphology into some repair instructions. A docking-registration/intake process returns the astronaut and re-seats unbound architecture after death. | Literal godhood, mind/soul mechanics, alien intent, memory storage, registration details, whether the core process speaks, or any survivor's eligibility. |
### The causal working spine
1. **Ancient intervention.** The builders create a field that can restore damaged living form. In the leading captive branch, the experiment leaves a living ascendant organism dependent on or confined by the field. Builders isolate the organism from the wider repair template and abandon the station for an unknown reason. Their ordered runs, access markings and containment machinery survive; none explains motive.
-
2. **Human hospital.** Humans encounter extraordinary healing and build ward machinery, records and transfer systems around it. Researchers open or bypass the old isolation to increase reach and edit treatment profiles. The proposed consequence is concrete rather than mystical shorthand: some active hospital machines begin repairing tissue toward a mixed, changing profile. Patients, staff decisions and hostile creatures are consequences of those particular interventions, not proof that every revival corrupts.
-
3. **Present return and shifting.** The astronaut's berth records one active return relationship. Under the proposed explanation, restoration returns the body and worn/carried property to that registered ship-side point; the same intake transaction causes unbound station fabric to re-seat while persistent joins/work remain. This supplies a candidate cause for selected gameplay rules without changing them. It does not establish that survivors are registered, safe, mortal, revivable or shift-causing.
+
2. **Human hospital.** Humans encounter extraordinary healing and build ward machinery, records and transfer systems around it. Researchers open or bypass the old isolation to increase reach and edit treatment profiles. Some active hospital machines begin repairing tissue toward a mixed, changing profile. Patients, staff decisions and hostile creatures are consequences of those particular interventions, not proof that every revival corrupts.
+
3. **Present return and shifting.** The astronaut's berth records one active return relationship. Restoration returns the body and worn/carried property to that registered ship-side point; the same intake transaction causes unbound station fabric to re-seat while persistent joins/work remain. This supplies a cause for the selected gameplay rules without changing them.
4. **Player intervention.** Regional evidence lets the astronaut separate ordinary restoration from harmful treatment profiles, trace one disputed human transfer and reach containment. The player may prepare to leave, isolate the mixed profile, leave it alone, accept/refuse a voluntary treatment, or keep investigating. No free-text interpretation or language completion secretly selects an outcome.
-
**Ordinary corruption rule recommended for this branch.** Use evidence-only ordinary revival plus the separately proposed voluntary treatment bargain. Death itself adds no mark, budget, forced transformation or ending state. A treatment can offer a visible ancient-interface benefit and a visible hospital-machine hazard before consent; refusal preserves every main path, and one known ship purge removes both benefit and hazard without upkeep. This remains a team proposal, not owner selection.
+
**Ordinary corruption rule recommended for this branch.** Use evidence-only ordinary revival plus the voluntary treatment bargain. Death itself adds no mark, budget, forced transformation or ending state. A treatment can offer a visible ancient-interface benefit and a visible hospital-machine hazard before consent; refusal preserves every main path, and one known ship purge removes both benefit and hazard without upkeep.
### Compact competing branch — the empty core/template engine
The strongest alternative keeps the ancient experiment and hospital intervention but removes the living captive: the ascendant left, while a machine retained its form template. Humans treated that template as a patient and altered it, producing the harmful mixed profile. The physical content changes: the deeper cell needs an inspectable template lattice and stored profile comparisons instead of living containment evidence, and responsive utterances become reproduced procedure rather than possible address to a prisoner. The creative cost is material: the strongest image—someone deliberately sealed inside—disappears, along with the possibility that one physical act also answers a confined party.
-
Its deeper choice also changes. Instead of **re-seat the isolation around a living source or leave it coupled**, the player chooses which already evidenced repair profile the engine should use—or leaves it untouched. A cleaned human baseline offers a colder engineering decision; an ancient template risks repeating an unknown experiment. No person, including the astronaut, is permanently bound or transformed by this first-pass alternative. Selecting a sacrificial personal template would be a different owner-level proposal and is excluded here.
+
Its deeper choice also changes. Instead of **re-seat the isolation around a living source or leave it coupled**, the player chooses which already evidenced repair profile the engine should use—or leaves it untouched. A cleaned human baseline offers a colder engineering decision; an ancient template risks repeating an unknown experiment. No person, including the astronaut, is permanently bound or transformed by this alternative. A sacrificial personal template would be a different proposal and is excluded here.
| **1. The berth that remembers** | Why does the astronaut return aboard while the station does not rewind? | Objective 1, death/manifest state, persistent fasteners/installed Fork, historical routes | Treat departure and installation as different commitments; investigate the berth record rather than assume time reset |
-
| **2. The harmful profile** | Did revival itself create the creatures, or did a human treatment intervention alter some repairs? | Ward logs, treatment machinery, objective 6 pressure work, objective 9 regulators, voluntary-treatment proposal | Bypass/isolate a harmful profile; knowingly accept or refuse treatment |
+
| **2. The harmful profile** | Did revival itself create the creatures, or did a human treatment intervention alter some repairs? | Ward logs, treatment machinery, objective 6 pressure work, objective 9 regulators, voluntary treatment | Bypass/isolate a harmful profile; knowingly accept or refuse treatment |
| **3. The last transfer** | Who moved a patient after transfers supposedly stopped, and what does that change between people? | Yeva's pressure history, Aster's ledger, Dorn's seal, objective 6 ledger, visitor transfer pairs, home comparison table/receiver | Inspect a destination and revise an accusation without turning testimony into truth |
| **4. What the core contains** | Is a responsive process a captive person, an automatic console or an empty template engine? | Objective 9 reply protocol, objective 11 iris/deeper cell, builders' seals, both languages, core containment | Inspect, re-seat isolation, leave coupled, or postpone with consequences visible on revisit |
@@ 44,7 44,7 @@
**Correction and limit.** Persistent world state rules out a whole-world rewind. Different restoration locations weaken “every repaired body goes to this ship.” They do not distinguish relocation from reconstruction, prove the field's range or establish a survivor rule. A route record from before death is historical even when its object/work facts persist.
-
**Later use, cost and human consequence.** The player can predict that reclaiming a station-installed part is a different commitment from dying with a carried one, and can evaluate a proposed irreversible departure honestly. Aster may ask to compare her arrival theory with the berth trace. Sharing it lets her retract “every crossing causes a shift” while retaining “this docking may”; refusing or postponing costs no relationship or help. The chain costs one optional diagnostic capture and a return comparison, not a death tax.
+
**Later use, cost and human consequence.** The player can predict that reclaiming a station-installed part is a different commitment from dying with a carried one, and can evaluate an irreversible departure honestly. Aster may ask to compare her arrival theory with the berth trace. Sharing it lets her retract “every crossing causes a shift” while retaining “this docking may”; refusing or postponing costs no relationship or help. The chain costs one optional diagnostic capture and a return comparison.
### Chain 2 — the harmful treatment profile
@@ 52,7 52,7 @@
**Rivals.** All resurrection eventually corrupts; the core field changed by itself; humans installed a harmful profile; the creature's pattern is unrelated disease; the record and creature merely share a ward label.
-
**Discriminating observation/action.** In an already-budgeted clinical treatment fixture, the player places two equivalent living culture patches from the same recorded source behind a transparent shield—one under the machine's active profile and one with the named profile physically bypassed. This is a voluntary world-time test on non-sentient tissue, not a survivor. The active side restores toward the visible anomalous pattern while the bypassed side closes without it. Removing power or interrupting before both committed observations yields an incomplete test; it does not prove safety. Objective 6's line trace and objective 9's regulator state can then identify which hospital branch carries that profile toward the core coupling.
+
**Discriminating observation/action.** In a clinical treatment fixture, the player places two equivalent living culture patches from the same recorded source behind a transparent shield—one under the machine's active profile and one with the named profile physically bypassed. This is a voluntary test on non-sentient tissue that runs while the game runs. The active side restores toward the visible anomalous pattern while the bypassed side closes without it. Removing power or interrupting before both committed observations yields an incomplete test; it does not prove safety. Objective 6's line trace and objective 9's regulator state can then identify which hospital branch carries that profile toward the core coupling.
**Correction and limit.** The comparison supports “this human-configured profile causes this observed pattern under these conditions” over “all revival necessarily does.” It does not prove the origin of every creature, that the core is innocent, that changed people are less themselves, or that field restoration is metaphysically safe.
@@ 64,11 64,11 @@
**Rivals.** One clock drifted; Aster recorded a planned rather than completed shipment; the line was redirected; another person used the same identifier; Dorn is hiding a transfer; shifting geography has been mistaken for chronology.
-
**Discriminating observation/action.** At objective 6 the player restores the sampled pressure line, follows physically visible source/destination evidence or the long route, and opens a **newly proposed record drawer placed at that existing destination fixture**. Its transfer card carries the completion impression from the same pressure-loop cycle counter whose earlier value is physically impressed on the R-3 wall record. The exposed ratchet advances when the line cycles and has no observed reverse control; the destination value is later in that mechanical sequence. Visitor-pair knowledge can predict the destination, but gauges and the long approach remain sufficient. A failed continuation, unpowered line or missing current access records an incomplete attempt, not a false witness.
+
**Discriminating observation/action.** At objective 6 the player restores the sampled pressure line, follows physically visible source/destination evidence or the long route, and opens a **record drawer at that destination fixture**. Its transfer card carries the completion impression from the same pressure-loop cycle counter whose earlier value is physically impressed on the R-3 wall record. The exposed ratchet advances when the line cycles and has no observed reverse control; the destination value is later in that mechanical sequence. Visitor-pair knowledge can predict the destination, but gauges and the long approach remain sufficient. A failed continuation, unpowered line or missing current access records an incomplete attempt, not a false witness.
**Correction and limit.** The shared counter supports one narrow order: this apparatus completed a transfer after the R-3 record's last stable pressure cycle. It does not reconcile Aster's and Yeva's calendar clocks; clock drift remains a rival for their dates. Counter replacement, reset or a copied false impression also remain possible until separately evidenced. The result establishes neither who travelled, why Dorn sealed the section, whether the patient survived nor which account is morally right. A shift changes current access, not the captured sequence values.
-
**Later use, cost and human consequence.** The physical chain needs only captures of the wall impression and destination card/counter; no survivor is required. The destination becomes one bounded investigation/rescue lead and its line state helps choose a pressure-control route. Back aboard, the player decides whom to show. Only a present, participating person speaks: Yeva may withdraw a specific accusation that Dorn falsified the shutdown without forgiving the seal; Aster may admit her ledger cannot identify a passenger; Dorn may reveal that he sealed the section after hearing its cycle, not seeing who crossed. An absent or unselected person contributes nothing. Postponement causes no unseen conversation or relationship penalty. The chain changes a relationship and next action without solving a culprit.
+
**Later use, cost and human consequence.** The physical chain needs only captures of the wall impression and destination card/counter; no survivor is required. The destination becomes one investigation/rescue lead and its line state helps choose a pressure-control route. Back aboard, the player decides whom to show. Only a present, participating person speaks: Yeva may withdraw a specific accusation that Dorn falsified the shutdown without forgiving the seal; Aster may admit her ledger cannot identify a passenger; Dorn may reveal that he sealed the section after hearing its cycle, not seeing who crossed. An absent or unselected person contributes nothing. Postponement causes no unseen conversation or relationship penalty. The chain changes a relationship and next action without solving a culprit.
### Chain 4 — what the core contains
@@ 76,34 76,34 @@
**Rivals.** A living captive sends or receives the lines; an automatic console performs addressed procedure; an empty engine reproduces a departed language; humans projected a person onto machinery. The utterance correlation never proves life.
-
**Discriminating observation/action.** Objective 11 opens one bounded passage to a deeper evidence cell. Common evidence before branch selection includes the physical seal coupling, a repair-profile feed and a sight baffle the player can open in world time. The owner-selected story branch would determine what direct observation exists behind it:
+
**Discriminating observation/action.** Objective 11 opens one passage to a deeper evidence cell. Common evidence before branch selection includes the physical seal coupling, a repair-profile feed and a sight baffle the player can open while the game runs. The story branch the owner chooses determines what direct observation exists behind it:
- **Leading captive package:** the baffle exposes living tissue continuously exchanging material with the containment line. Direct instruments show recurring biological activity independent of console text. This establishes a living organism, not divinity, sapience, consent, authorship or the meaning of an utterance.
- **Empty-template package:** the baffle exposes an inactive chamber and a lattice replaying stored anatomical patterns with no observed living tissue. This supports an engine/template reading but cannot prove nothing living exists elsewhere.
-
These are mutually exclusive authored packages, not two clues placed together.
+
These packages are mutually exclusive.
-
**Choice, revisit and limit.** In the leading package, the player may re-seat the old isolation, leave the coupling open or postpone after inspection. Re-seating is world-time mechanical work: the coupling tell goes dark and the harmful profile feed disconnects. The team proposal is that ordinary ship revival remains active; continued exploration does not become mortal. A later ward revisit is required to observe whether its treatment profile changed—no remote “safe” verdict appears. Leaving keeps current behavior and future choice available. Whether the prior line asked for isolation remains unresolved, and sealing a dangerous system may coincide with an inferred request without proving it.
+
**Choice, revisit and limit.** In the leading package, the player may re-seat the old isolation, leave the coupling open or postpone after inspection. Re-seating is mechanical work done while the game runs: the coupling tell goes dark and the harmful profile feed disconnects. Ordinary ship revival remains active; continued exploration does not become mortal. A later ward revisit is required to observe whether its treatment profile changed—no remote “safe” verdict appears. Leaving keeps current behavior and future choice available. Whether the prior line asked for isolation remains unresolved, and sealing a dangerous system may coincide with an inferred request without proving it.
**Human consequence.** Ivo frames voluntary treatment as body agency: accepting, refusing and purging are choices he respects, while he objects to hidden exposure. Mara wants one profile trace preserved before isolation because completed evidence, unlike a live feed, survives disconnection. Yeva sees a chance to stop the ward machinery; Dorn refuses the claim that restoring an older shape restores a prior person. Aster favors leaving the seal choice open until the berth/shift evidence is better. These positions change later conversations and what each person asks the player to examine; they do not gate operation, friendship, equipment, language or an ending.
## Beat, evidence and action layers
-
“Apparent,” “deeper” and “optional-secret” are discovery layers, not an adopted number or hierarchy of endings.
+
“Apparent,” “deeper” and “optional-secret” are discovery layers, not a number or hierarchy of endings.
| Layer | Concrete entry / dependency | Visible choice, including defer | Immediate result and revisit | What stays available |
|---|---|---|---|---|
-
| **Apparent departure preparation** | Objective 10's proposed bridge, coupler, regulator and exchanger are installed; no language, survivor or core answer is required. | Inspect readiness; if the owner adopts the departure package, **undock**, or postpone and keep exploring. Leave assemblies installed or reclaim one after resolving its loadout state. | Readiness lists only actual ship functions. Proposed undocking receives an explicit irreversible preview: leaving the field ends revival and closes this continuity's station exploration. Nothing silently makes continued station play mortal. | Postponing keeps all regions, mysteries, projects and deeper work available indefinitely; readiness itself is not credits or escape until selected. |
+
| **Apparent departure preparation** | Objective 10's bridge, coupler, regulator and exchanger are installed; no language, survivor or core answer is required. | Inspect readiness; if the owner adopts the departure package, **undock**, or postpone and keep exploring. Leave assemblies installed or reclaim one after resolving its loadout state. | Readiness lists only actual ship functions. Undocking receives an explicit irreversible preview: leaving the field ends revival and closes this continuity's station exploration. Nothing silently makes continued station play mortal. | Postponing keeps all regions, mysteries, projects and deeper work available indefinitely; readiness itself is not credits or escape until selected. |
| **Deeper containment intervention** | Reach objective 11 through its physical iris; languages can guide but the two-clamp route works. Complete enough of Chains 2/4 to understand likely stakes, or act from physical hazard alone. | Inspect; re-seat isolation; leave coupled; accept/refuse/purge voluntary treatment; or withdraw. | Seal/coupling and treatment states change visibly. Completed work persists. Ward consequences require direct revisit, and people respond only to shared evidence/actions. | Ordinary revival and exploration continue under the recommended branch. No core action forces departure, answers metaphysics or completes the station. |
-
| **Optional-secret station account** | Objective 12 physically joins every actual placed playable room/group under the eventual selected mechanism; no story choice or diagnostic pulse is required for physical completion. | Leave the joined network as built, or route an optional current diagnostic through already discovered seal/profile/berth sites and compare its results with named stored records. | Joins persist. The diagnostic reports only present reach, input/output transformations and whether the profile coupling currently passes a signal. Historical order remains the player's revisable comparison of records below. | This is not a mandatory true-ending gate, release action or proof of a captive. What the complete layout does after later deaths remains the owner's unanswered stabilisation question; this page adopts neither result. |
+
| **Optional-secret station account** | Objective 12 physically joins every actual placed playable room/group under the eventual selected mechanism; no story choice or diagnostic pulse is required for physical completion. | Leave the joined network as built, or route an optional current diagnostic through already discovered seal/profile/berth sites and compare its results with named stored records. | Joins persist. The diagnostic reports only present reach, input/output transformations and whether the profile coupling currently passes a signal. Historical order remains the player's revisable comparison of records below. | This is not a mandatory true-ending gate, release action or proof of a captive. |
### Historical evidence and intervention availability
-
The optional diagnostic is not a history reader. The limited chronology comes from three named records sharing explicit cross-references:
+
The optional diagnostic is not a history reader. The limited chronology comes from three records sharing explicit cross-references:
-
1. At objective 11, a **new trapped seal-service strip** sits physically beneath the later human adapter. Its builders' cut style and punched value are visible; the overlay supports “seal service before this adapter,” while ancient authorship remains an inference.
-
2. Chain 2's existing human profile-commissioning card gains one field transcribing that same punched value as **found**, then names the installed human profile revision. A mistaken transcription or replaced strip remains possible.
-
3. Objective 1's existing berth intake trace gains the active profile-revision field and the directly observed docking registration event. Matching the human revision supports “profile commissioning before this docking,” not a universal calendar conversion.
+
1. At objective 11, a **trapped seal-service strip** sits physically beneath the later human adapter. Its builders' cut style and punched value are visible; the overlay supports “seal service before this adapter,” while ancient authorship remains an inference.
+
2. Chain 2's human profile-commissioning card carries one field transcribing that same punched value as **found**, then names the installed human profile revision. A mistaken transcription or replaced strip remains possible.
+
3. Objective 1's berth intake trace carries the active profile-revision field and the directly observed docking registration event. Matching the human revision supports “profile commissioning before this docking,” not a universal calendar conversion.
Together, physical layering plus the two cross-references support **old seal state → human profile installation → current docking registration** for these records only. The player compares them in the paused journal; no interface declares the chronology true. A whole-station diagnostic later measures only the current pulse at those discovered endpoints and each present transformation. It can show a live coupling, a bypass or a break; it cannot recover the trapped strip, read an old event or infer intent.
@@ 111,7 111,7 @@
**Construction before intervention.** Visiting objective 11 and completing objective 12 does not operate isolation. With the coupling still open, the completed physical network and optional diagnostic may expose and record the current mixed-profile path. Re-seating isolation afterward leaves every mechanical join and physical-completion count intact but breaks that diagnostic branch at the visible seal boundary. Historical records and prior captures remain.
-
**Reopening boundary.** First-pass isolation is deliberately reversible from the same reachable approach-side release. Before re-seat, the control previews **disconnect mixed profile; ordinary revival unchanged; reversible here**. Reopening is a world-time act with a visible warning that it reconnects the mixed profile; the coupling tell and live signal return only if their source is currently active. It does not erase completed evidence or automatically harm anyone, and it may allow a missed current test on a later reachable visit. Continued access after a shift is not guaranteed. Leaving isolation closed can therefore preserve a clear evidence gap without a hidden ending lock, mortality change or regenerated clue.
+
**Reopening boundary.** Isolation is deliberately reversible from the same reachable approach-side release. Before re-seat, the control previews **disconnect mixed profile; ordinary revival unchanged; reversible here**. Reopening happens while the game runs, with a visible warning that it reconnects the mixed profile; the coupling tell and live signal return only if their source is currently active. It does not erase completed evidence or automatically harm anyone, and it may allow a missed current test on a later reachable visit. Continued access after a shift is not guaranteed. Leaving isolation closed can therefore preserve a clear evidence gap without a hidden ending lock, mortality change or regenerated clue.
### Compatibility with both regional orders
@@ 122,30 122,21 @@
## Human scene obligations within five people / fifteen scenes
-
The chains imply **five short proposed scene variants**, intended to overlap home follow-through rather than silently exceed the SMALL cast ledger:
+
The chains imply **five short scene variants**, intended to overlap home follow-through rather than exceed five people and fifteen scenes:
1. Aster compares one berth trace and narrows—not abandons—her arrival theory.
-
2. Yeva and Dorn see the completed profile comparison and disagree over whether changed form equals harm; one shared scene must still be assigned to both arcs explicitly.
+
2. Yeva and Dorn see the completed profile comparison and disagree over whether changed form equals harm.
3. Mara asks whether to preserve a completed culture/profile trace before a live feed is disconnected; this is evidence stewardship, not her salvage-project consumption.
-
4. Yeva, Aster and Dorn confront the late-transfer record; each revises one bounded claim, and no damaged recipient field becomes a solved identity.
+
4. Yeva, Aster and Dorn confront the late-transfer record; each revises one claim, and no damaged recipient field becomes a solved identity.
5. Ivo states the voluntary-treatment consent boundary before the player accepts/refuses/purges; later response reflects the chosen act without friendship being a reward.
-
[Cast And Short Rescue Map](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Cast%20And%20Short%20Rescue%20Map) now allocates these variants within its fifteen primary scene briefs, and [Campaign Evidence And State Crosswalk](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Campaign%20Evidence%20And%20State%20Crosswalk) maps their participant and evidence conditions. Exact branch scripts and full state variants remain later work. These variants do not select Yeva or Aster as first survivor, define survivor delivery/loss/safety, or write final dialogue. If a named person is not selected, the evidence function can move to the stated pressure-tech, supply-clerk, maintenance, reclamation or rehabilitation role without making that role mandatory.
+
[Cast And Short Rescue Map](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Cast%20And%20Short%20Rescue%20Map) allocates these variants within its fifteen primary scene briefs, and [Campaign Evidence And State Crosswalk](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Campaign%20Evidence%20And%20State%20Crosswalk) maps their participant and evidence conditions. If a named person is not selected, the evidence function can move to the stated pressure-tech, supply-clerk, maintenance, reclamation or rehabilitation role without making that role mandatory.
-
## Finite reuse and new-obligation ledger
+
## Reuse and a smaller cut
-
| SMALL inventory | Reused here | New obligation exposed here | Count effect |
-
|---|---|---|---|
-
| **4 regions / 12 objectives** | Objectives 1, 6, 9, 10, 11 and 12 host the four chains/layers; all twelve remain in both orders. | Bind story evidence/results to those existing objectives. | **+0 regions, +0 objectives.** |
-
| **24 modules / 40 placed rooms** | Collar/service intake, clinical ward/pressure destination, regulator gallery, iris/deeper cell and core area have first-pass hosts in [Station Room And Module Inventory](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Station%20Room%20And%20Module%20Inventory). | The berth trace, controlled culture/profile station, destination record drawer, mutually exclusive core observation package and trapped seal strip are assigned to existing instances by that inventory and [Campaign Evidence And State Crosswalk](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Campaign%20Evidence%20And%20State%20Crosswalk); exact occurrence and state variants remain later work. | **+0 modules/rooms.** The four placement obligations and one cross-listed archive input have first-pass placements; detailed authoring must preserve those identities and record any genuinely necessary future increment. |
-
| **4 language chains** | Builder purpose, visitor transfer and reply protocol provide evidence/actions. | No translation or new chain; story consequences reference captured results. | **+0 language chains.** |
-
| **4 mystery/personal chains** | This article owns exactly the four briefs above. | Full occurrence, branch and failure variants remain later work. | **4 / 4 first-pass briefs.** |
-
| **5 people / 15 scenes** | Home interests and bounded knowledge for Yeva, Dorn, Aster, Mara and Ivo. | The five personal variants listed above are allocated within [Cast And Short Rescue Map](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Cast%20And%20Short%20Rescue%20Map)’s fifteen primary scenes and mapped to chain/evidence/participant states by [Campaign Evidence And State Crosswalk](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Campaign%20Evidence%20And%20State%20Crosswalk); full dialogue and materially different state variants remain later work. | **+0 people or primary scenes.** Five cast arcs/fifteen primary briefs are prepared; these five variants do not create five additional scenes or complete their detailed scripts. |
-
| **13 major placed mechanisms** | Objective-9 regulators/reply, objective-11 iris and existing hospital treatment/containment machinery. | Active/bypassed/after-isolation culture results, branch-specific baffle results and present-only diagnostic reach/break states retain their existing owners; the profile card and berth trace retain their cross-reference fields. Detailed variants remain authored work. | [Encounter And Mechanism Placement Inventory](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Encounter%20And%20Mechanism%20Placement%20Inventory) already cross-lists reversible core isolation/coupling as **P13** within the thirteen-major-instance first pass. Add its detailed state/record variants to that existing instance, not a new slot or invisible free mechanic. The final game band remains unselected. |
-
-
The captive and empty-template core packages are alternatives, not additive production. Neither this map nor shared evidence completes actual room placement, exact clue text, full dialogue, every visit/death order, save compatibility, accessibility presentation or ending sequence.
+
The chains and layers reuse objectives 1, 6, 9, 10, 11 and 12 and add no regions, objectives, modules, rooms, language chains, people, primary scenes or major placed mechanisms. Room hosts for the collar/service intake, clinical ward/pressure destination, regulator gallery, iris/deeper cell and core area are listed in [Station Room And Module Inventory](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Station%20Room%20And%20Module%20Inventory), and the reversible core isolation/coupling is listed in [Encounter And Mechanism Placement Inventory](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Encounter%20And%20Mechanism%20Placement%20Inventory).
-
**Smaller concrete cut.** Remove Chain 3 as a multi-step personal investigation. Keep the late-transfer card as one unresolved objective-6 clue, with no destination drawer and no three-person confrontation. The causal spine, both languages, departure, harmful-profile and core choices survive. What is lost is the main case where evidence changes relationships without solving the central mystery: Yeva cannot retract a specific accusation, Aster's ledger never meets a physical result, Dorn's seal remains generic suspicion, and home becomes more about explaining machinery than living with incomplete human consequences. No hours or playtime saving is claimed.
+
**Smaller concrete cut.** Remove Chain 3 as a multi-step personal investigation. Keep the late-transfer card as one unresolved objective-6 clue, with no destination drawer and no three-person confrontation. The causal spine, both languages, departure, harmful-profile and core choices survive. What is lost is the main case where evidence changes relationships without solving the central mystery: Yeva cannot retract a specific accusation, Aster's ledger never meets a physical result, Dorn's seal remains generic suspicion, and home becomes more about explaining machinery than living with incomplete human consequences.
## Recommendation, costs and owner choices
@@ 158,4 149,16 @@
1. **Core image:** choose the leading **living captive behind isolation** (recommended), or the **empty template engine**. The first preserves a party the player may answer but risks anthropomorphising an unknown organism; the second makes the intervention a profile-selection problem but loses the prisoner image.
2. **Apparent departure:** choose **voluntary undocking as an explicitly irreversible apparent-credit action that ends field revival and station exploration** (recommended), or keep readiness as a repair milestone with no departure/credits yet. In the recommended version, postponement remains indefinite and no player becomes mortal while continuing to explore.
-
No answer is inferred for full-layout stabilisation, first survivor, acquisition, survivor mortality, corruption, literal metaphysics or a “true ending.” No written map proves emotional impact, clarity, feasibility, content duration or fun; those require completed authoring and later owner-authorised implementation and observation.
+
## Open questions
+
+
- Core image: the living captive behind isolation or the empty template engine (owner choice 1 above).
+
- Apparent departure: voluntary irreversible undocking, or readiness as a repair milestone with no departure/credits yet (owner choice 2 above).
+
- Full-layout stabilisation: what the complete layout does after later deaths.
+
- The mechanism objective 12 uses to join every room is not yet selected.
+
- First survivor (Yeva or Aster), acquisition, and which named people are selected; survivor delivery, loss and safety, and whether survivors are registered, mortal, revivable or shift-causing.
+
- Corruption, literal metaphysics, and whether there is a “true ending.”
+
- The final game band.
+
- The shared Yeva/Dorn profile-comparison scene has not yet been assigned to both arcs.
+
- Exact branch scripts and full state variants for the five scene variants, and full occurrence, branch and failure variants for the four chains.
+
- Exact room placement, clue text, full dialogue, every visit/death order, save compatibility, accessibility presentation and the ending sequence.
+
- These rules are untested; numbers are proposals.
