2026-09-08 18:22:41
Anonymous:
Record State and Production closeouts, regional review, and aligned v1 scope forecast
hold the flood/progress.md ..
@@ 1,12 1,12 @@
# Hold The Horde — Progress
-
**Updated 2026-09-08 17:54 Jerusalem (UTC+3).** PM and GPT work continues; only the two Claude roles are paused. All work remains **design only**.
+
**Updated 2026-09-08 18:22 Jerusalem (UTC+3).** PM and GPT work continues; only the two Claude roles are paused. All work remains **design only**.
-
**23 tracked design packages: 21 preparation-closed, 2 open.** Traps21 and Development Handoff22 closed410 at17:48. New outcome23 Save And Content State was explicitly assigned411 at17:49; shared integration04 remains dependent. The separate management coverage map and two unadopted intake contributions are not extra completed packages. These are bounded written outcomes, not overall game completion.
+
**25 tracked design packages: 23 preparation-closed, 2 open.** Save And Content State23 closed417 at18:09:56 Jerusalem. Production Scope24 then closed423 at18:21. Regional Discovery Map25, assigned418, is reviewing draft420; shared integration04 remains dependent. The separate management coverage map and two unadopted intake contributions are not extra completed packages. These are bounded written outcomes, not overall game completion.
“Closed” means the bounded written design/review outcome is complete. It does not mean a feature is implemented, every detail approved or fun validated. This board covers the current design batch; it is not a complete campaign or production backlog, and the closed/total ratio is not an overall game-completion percentage. Stable IDs stay fixed; added/reopened work must be recorded explicitly.
-
**Availability correction —8 Sep:** only Claude is paused. PM and the existing GPT Systems designer continue useful work with bounded independent GPT reviews. Systems is assigned the save/content-state contract; PM handles integration, new proposal intake and forecasts. Neither permanent Claude role will be woken or replaced before owner confirmation. Active one-minute fallback monitoring and15-minute progress/forecast reports continue.
+
**Availability correction —8 Sep:** only Claude is paused. PM and the existing GPT Systems designer continue useful work with bounded independent GPT reviews. Production24 is preparation-closed423; Regional25 draft420 is in focused independent review. Systems retains stopped ownership while PM handles the review, intake and forecasts. Neither permanent Claude role will be woken or replaced before owner confirmation. Active one-minute fallback monitoring and15-minute progress/forecast reports continue.
## Forward forecast — baseline F1
@@ 43,7 43,7 @@
The critical sequence is core decisions and interfaces → whole-game architecture/content budget → domain designs → cross-domain integration → v1. Content detail proceeds in parallel only where interfaces are stable. Extra writers do not eliminate the PM/review bottleneck.
-
**Next deliveries:** Save And Content State draft target18:20 today(range18:05–18:45), reviewed outcome19:00(range18:30–19:30). Traps21 and Development Handoff22 both closed17:48, ahead of their18:45/18:15 targets. Core11 Sep(10–14), complete first-pass wiki22 Sep(18–29), and specialist setup9–10 Sep remain unchanged.
+
**Next delivery, today Jerusalem:** [Regional Discovery Map25](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Regional%20Discovery%20Map) draft arrived18:16 (target18:45); reviewed target19:30(range19:00–20:00). [Production Scope24](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Production%20Scope) closed18:21 (target19:40), and Save And Content State23 closed18:09:56 (target19:00). Core11 Sep(10–14), complete first-pass wiki22 Sep(18–29), and specialist setup9–10 Sep remain unchanged. The revised144–247role-hourv1 allowance needs the9Sep capacity check; if both additional streams are absent10Sep, the provisional current-team scenario is25Sep(22Sep–2Oct).
## Extra agents — when and why
@@ 76,14 76,16 @@
|Availability correction|8 Sep17:10|Only Claude paused; PM/GPT work resumed after PM incorrectly stopped broader intake. Equipment Catalogue20 now targets reviewed18:30 today. M2–M4 dates unchanged pending coverage reassessment.|
|F1.3|8 Sep17:32|Catalogue actual17:29 and coverage actual17:27 recorded ahead of their18:30/17:45 targets. Next reviewed trap/encounter outcome targets18:45(18:15–19:15). M2–M4 unchanged: the coverage audit still identifies eight partial domains and three missing contracts; remaining-work estimates need deduplication.|
|F1.4|8 Sep17:54|Traps21 and Handoff22 actual17:48 recorded against18:45/18:15 targets. Next Save And Content State23 reviewed target19:00(18:30–19:30). M2–M4 unchanged: full campaign, content inventory and integration still require work.|
+
|F1.5|8 Sep18:09:56|State23 actual closeout417 recorded against its19:00 reviewed target. New418 outcomes: Regional Map25 reviewed19:30(19:00–20:00), Production Scope24 reviewed19:40(19:05–20:10). M2–M4 unchanged pending reviewed remaining-scope accounting; a Production draft is not a reviewed forecast.|
+
|F1.6|8 Sep18:21|Production24 closed423. Its reviewed response exposes previously unallocated v1 room/mechanism briefs:144–247role-hours replaces draft116–201. M2–M4 dates retained provisionally;9Sep re-estimate must check capacity. If extra streams are unavailable10Sep, current-teamv1 scenario25Sep(22Sep–2Oct). Regional25 reviewing420, target19:30.|
## What changed in this report
-
- Traps21 is preparation-closed410: five families, a four-region pressure map and two legal encounter traces. One review/response corrected Triage's trigger/override and the cap-work opportunity after crowd clearance; actual placements and balance remain later.
-
- Development Handoff22 is preparation-closed410. It now includes a distinct later evidence path for sustained discovery/build changes across successive expeditions, following independent review. No development or test phase is authorized.
-
- Systems411 continues with the save/content-state contract. The [coverage map](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Design%20Coverage) now distinguishes five first-pass contracts, eight partial areas and two missing dedicated contracts; no overall percentage is implied.
-
- Two previously untracked contributions—[Rescue Shift Proposal](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Rescue%20Shift%20Proposal) and [Station Assembly Example](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Station%20Assembly%20Example)—remain unadopted intake. PM has read them; contributor/ownership context and consequential choices remain to be dispositioned. A tracking gap is not proof of unauthorized work.
-
- The collector's13changed snapshots,6available before-diffs and30messages were reviewed and acknowledged with follow-ups. Known closures show no rollback. Full-wiki forecast remains22 Sep(18–29).
+
- [Save And Content State23](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Save%20And%20Content%20State) preparation-closed417 at18:09:56, final438cdf35. The returning manifest includes active rig and inactive cargo once; delivery requires the same person aboard and the closed airlock; saved evidence retains provenance without refreshed truth. Save policy and unresolved rescue/shift behavior remain proposals.
+
- New [Production Scope24](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Production%20Scope) gives PM the finite scope/reuse/cost comparison. New [Regional Discovery Map25](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Regional%20Discovery%20Map) gives Systems four proposed regions and twelve linked objectives. Production24 closed423 at18:21 after its one review/response; Regional25 draft420 at18:16 is under independent review, then one response and PM disposition.
+
- The [coverage map](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Design%20Coverage) now distinguishes seven first-pass contracts and eight partial areas. The regional map remains partial; no overall percentage is implied.
+
- Intake407 remains open: Rescue Shift Proposal and Station Assembly Example are unadopted, with contributor/ownership context and consequential choices pending. Neither answers the existing owner questions or closes04.
+
- Production review exposed missing explicit room/mechanism authoring. The revised144–247role-hourv1 allowance includes24module/40room/12mechanism brief minimums and unique review/response/integration. It is a planning estimate, not recorded effort. Both Claude roles remain paused; dates stay provisional pending9Sep capacity review.
## Open and closed outcomes
@@ 113,7 115,9 @@
|20|[Equipment catalogue](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Equipment%20Catalogue)|Closed|Reviewed12-part planning sample; acquisition unchosen|Sep8 17:29 disposition400|Exact thresholds, multi-actuator controller rules, acquisition and later finite catalogue remain open|
|21|[Traps and encounter progression](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Traps%20And%20Encounter%20Progression)|Closed|Reviewed five-family/four-region SMALL proposal|Sep8 17:48 disposition410|Twelve actual instances, full roster/placement, reset boundaries and balance remain later|
|22|[Development and validation handoff](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Development%20And%20Validation%20Handoff)|Closed|Reviewed first-pass risk/evidence plan|Sep8 17:48 disposition410|Final v1-specific scope, staffing and estimates precede any owner phase decision; no development authorized|
-
|23|[Save and content state](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Save%20And%20Content%20State)|Open — reviewing|Proposed save policy and continuity contract|Sep8 17:49 assignment411|Draft18:20(18:05–18:45); reviewed19:00(18:30–19:30); unresolved rescue/shift choices stay visible|
+
|23|[Save and content state](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Save%20And%20Content%20State)|Closed|Reviewed first-pass continuity contract; save policy unselected|Sep8 18:09:56 disposition417|Final438cdf35; detailed transitions, rescue/shift ordering, save-policy and recovery choices remain open|
+
|24|[Production scope](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Production%20Scope)|Closed|Reviewed provisional finite scope and work accounting|Sep8 18:21 disposition423|Finalc1a60388;144–247role-hourv1 planning allowance, not measured labor; band/cuts unselected|
|Equipment catalogue|Preparation closed400; final737b3cfd|Use in trap/encounter examples; detailed controller and acquisition integration later|
-
|Whole-v1 coverage|Fifteen-domain map updated after410|Reconcile unique remaining work; save and production contracts still need preparation|
+
|Whole-v1 coverage|Fifteen-domain map updated after423: seven first-pass contracts and eight partial areas|Production24 establishes the costing/depth baseline; Regional Map25 advances a partial domain, while finite inventories still need authoring|
|Trap/encounter progression|Preparation closed410; finala280131b|Use concrete family rules; detailed instances/roster later|
|Development handoff|Preparation closed410; finalc0c38e8b|Keep gates explicit; final handoff packet depends on concrete v1/development scope|
-
|Save/content state|Draft413 received17:54; Systems stopped, temporary GPT review active|Actual submission, one focused review/response, PM disposition|
+
|Save/content state|Preparation closed417 at18:09:56; final438cdf35|Use explicit continuity interfaces; detailed state work and owner selections remain later|
+
|[Production Scope24](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Production%20Scope)|Preparation closed423 at18:21; finalc1a60388|Use144–247role-hour planning allowance with explicit v1/M4 depth and capacity limits|
+
|[Regional Discovery Map25](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Regional%20Discovery%20Map)|Systems draft420 under focused review|One independent critique/response; reviewed19:30(19:00–20:00)|
|Additional proposal intake|Both full pages read; explicitly unadopted|Track authorship and assess protected retreat/next-shift meeting before integrating|
|Shared integration04|Current owner rules known; some mechanisms/choices pending|Integrate confirmed rules and explicitly isolate unresolved decisions|
|Claude Lead/Reviewer|Paused by owner for token limits|Resume only when owner confirms; GPT work continues meanwhile|
