2026-09-09 12:42:41
Anonymous:
Record completed readiness critique559 and verified ONE response560
hold the flood/progress.md ..
@@ 1,14 1,14 @@
# Hold The Horde — Progress
-
**Updated 2026-09-09 12:16 Jerusalem (UTC+3); current status through558.** The owner resumed all project work and original Claude roles in490. All work remains **design only**.
+
**Updated 2026-09-09 12:40 Jerusalem (UTC+3); current status through560.** The owner resumed all project work and original Claude roles in490. All work remains **design only**.
**38 tracked design packages:37 preparation-closed,1 open (38).** Scope and development handoff refresh37 ([Production Scope](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Production%20Scope); [Development And Validation Handoff](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Development%20And%20Validation%20Handoff)) closed550 at12:05:47. [V1 Readiness38](/Hold%20The%20Flood/V1%20Readiness), assigned551–553, gives a stable ID to the already-planned final coherence/readiness work; it adds no game scope. All15 domains have usable first-pass contracts/0 partial; M2/M3 are not yet declared complete and this is not a game-completion percentage. Existing24 modules/40 rooms,12 equipment definitions,10 encounters INCLUDING2 setpieces and13 major mechanisms remain proposed content;13 is not every interactive object. Intake407 and administration add no further packages.
“Closed” means the bounded written design/review outcome is complete. It does not mean a feature is implemented, every detail approved or fun validated. This board covers the current design batch; it is not a complete campaign or production backlog, and the closed/total ratio is not an overall game-completion percentage. Stable IDs stay fixed; added/reopened work must be recorded explicitly.
-
**Readiness inputs delivered:** Lead557 at12:12:42 and Systems555 at12:12:20; both STOPPED. Reviewer554 criteria are complete, and its ONE critique558 is now WORKING. Critique target13:15 (12:45–14:00); reviewed38 remains16:00 (14:30–18:00), Jerusalem today. The four-defect Lead claim and13-record audit require reconciliation; neither closes M2/M3.
+
**Readiness response underway:** Lead557 at12:12:42 and Systems555 at12:12:20 supplied the assessment and factual audit. The ONE critique559 is complete; Reviewer is STOPPED. Lead560 is WORKING on the ONE consolidated response, targeting **13:15 (12:50–14:00)**; reviewed38 remains **16:00 (14:30–18:00)**, Jerusalem today. PM prepares bounded local parent repairs. M2/M3 remain open.
-
**Actual availability and handoffs:** original identities/models/efforts remain unchanged. Lead557 and Systems555 are STOPPED after their38 submissions; Reviewer558 is WORKING on the ONE combined critique after criteria554. Receiving558 and the full contract were verified at12:14:39/44. Receiving/full contracts were verified at12:06:22/27 for Lead,12:06:18/22 for Systems and12:07:16/21 for Reviewer. Lead owns only the new administrative V1 Readiness article; Systems supplies a local factual audit for the same38 outcome; Reviewer saved independent criteria554 and is conducting ONE critique of the stopped submission and audit. All existing game articles and prior parent ownership are STOPPED; no37 follow-up is authorized. PM owns36/Home/Information STOPPED. No additional permanent agent or owner forwarding is needed.
+
**Actual availability and handoffs:** original identities/models/efforts remain unchanged. Lead560 is WORKING on the ONE response to critique559, incorporating the submitted557 assessment and555 factual audit. Receiving was verified at12:35:14.291 Jerusalem and the full559/560 reading at12:35:31.379; one courier was delivered. Reviewer is STOPPED after559; Systems remains STOPPED after555. Lead owns only the administrative V1 Readiness article. PM is preparing bounded local parent repairs; game sources remain unchanged and no parent ownership transfer is implied. All existing game articles and prior parent ownership are STOPPED; no37 follow-up is authorized. PM owns36/Home/Information STOPPED. No additional permanent agent or owner forwarding is needed.
## Forward forecast — baseline F1
@@ 43,7 43,7 @@
The remaining critical sequence is38 readiness assessment + supporting factual audit → ONE critique and at most ONE consolidated response → bounded repairs and separate PM M2/M3 disposition.35,36 and37 are preparation-closed inputs. The14–26 role-hour allowance at response549 included37 response/disposition4–8 plus coherence10–18. With37 closed, only **10–18 role-hours for coherence/repair disposition** remains forward work. M4 **350–590 role-hours** and the future packet **289–490 role-hours /5–8 working weeks** are low-confidence conditional estimating proposals, not logged labor or development authority. No additional agent or development phase is assumed.
-
**Next delivery, Jerusalem:** [V1 Readiness38](/Hold%20The%20Flood/V1%20Readiness) numbers the previously planned whole-v1 coherence work. Draft target **13:30 (12:45–14:30)** and reviewed disposition **16:00 (14:30–18:00)** today9 September, low confidence; earlier completion can support an earlier M2/M3 delivery decision. Systems552 factual support targets **13:00 (12:30–14:00)**; Reviewer553 criteria **12:45 (12:30–13:15)**, then ONE critique roughly30–60 minutes after the stopped full submission. Lead557 and Systems555 are STOPPED after their38 submissions; Reviewer558 is WORKING on the ONE combined critique after criteria554. Receiving558 and the full contract were verified at12:14:39/44. Receiving/full contracts were verified at12:06:22/27 for Lead,12:06:18/22 for Systems and12:07:16/21 for Reviewer. Lead owns only the new administrative V1 Readiness article; Systems supplies a local factual audit for the same38 outcome; Reviewer saved independent criteria554 and is conducting ONE critique of the stopped submission and audit. Scope and development handoff refresh37 ([Production Scope](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Production%20Scope); [Development And Validation Handoff](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Development%20And%20Validation%20Handoff)) closed550 at **12:05:47**, after response549 at11:58:19 and one critique/response: Production68db46ea (21,243 bytes), Handoff59945901 (27,529 bytes), before its15:00 reviewed target. Both parents are Systems STOPPED.35 closed11:35:17 and36 closed11:49:32. The14–26 role-hour allowance at response549 included37 response/disposition4–8 plus coherence10–18. With37 closed, only **10–18 role-hours for coherence/repair disposition** remains forward work. M4 **350–590 role-hours** and the future packet **289–490 role-hours /5–8 working weeks** are low-confidence conditional estimating proposals, not logged labor or development authority. F1.14 milestone dates remain unchanged pending38; five owner choices remain unanswered. The overnight owner pause was authorized downtime;144–247 remains dated8September planning history.
+
**Next delivery, Jerusalem:** [V1 Readiness38](/Hold%20The%20Flood/V1%20Readiness) numbers the previously planned whole-v1 coherence work. Lead560’s ONE response to critique559 targets **13:15 (12:50–14:00)**; reviewed disposition remains **16:00 (14:30–18:00)** today9 September, low confidence. Earlier completion can support an earlier M2/M3 delivery decision; neither milestone is closed. Initial Lead557 assessment and Systems555 audit arrived at12:12:42/12:12:20, and independent criteria554 and ONE critique559 are complete. Lead560 is WORKING on the ONE response to critique559, incorporating the submitted557 assessment and555 factual audit. Receiving was verified at12:35:14.291 Jerusalem and the full559/560 reading at12:35:31.379; one courier was delivered. Reviewer is STOPPED after559; Systems remains STOPPED after555. Lead owns only the administrative V1 Readiness article. PM is preparing bounded local parent repairs; game sources remain unchanged and no parent ownership transfer is implied. Scope and development handoff refresh37 ([Production Scope](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Production%20Scope); [Development And Validation Handoff](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Development%20And%20Validation%20Handoff)) closed550 at **12:05:47**, after response549 at11:58:19 and one critique/response: Production68db46ea (21,243 bytes), Handoff59945901 (27,529 bytes), before its15:00 reviewed target. Both parents are Systems STOPPED.35 closed11:35:17 and36 closed11:49:32. The14–26 role-hour allowance at response549 included37 response/disposition4–8 plus coherence10–18. With37 closed, only **10–18 role-hours for coherence/repair disposition** remains forward work. M4 **350–590 role-hours** and the future packet **289–490 role-hours /5–8 working weeks** are low-confidence conditional estimating proposals, not logged labor or development authority. F1.14 milestone dates remain unchanged pending38; five owner choices remain unanswered. The overnight owner pause was authorized downtime;144–247 remains dated8September planning history.
**Adopted F1.14 forecast — 9 September:** M3 first-pass wiki now targets **14 September (11–18 September), low confidence**. M2 coherent core remains11 September (10–14); M4 detailed campaign remains10 November (20 October–1 December). The revision follows the remaining-deliverables audit and preparation closeouts25–33, including the actual24-module/40-room and ten-encounter/thirteen-mechanism first passes. It uses current PM, Systems and restored original Lead/Reviewer capacity; additional agents are not prerequisites. It is a scope-based calendar judgment, not a conversion of word counts or elapsed chat minutes into role-hours. A changed joining architecture, expanded first-pass scope, unresolved integration or unavailable capacity can move the estimate. Next scheduled re-estimate:9 September18:00 Jerusalem, or sooner after consequential acceptance, scope or capacity changes. The earlier absent-two-specialists→25Sep scenario is historical and no longer the current schedule. The earlier14Sep conditional calculation in yesterday’s unpublished draft is now explicitly adopted by PM.
@@ 106,7 106,7 @@
- [Mechanical Interfaces And Opening Quantities35](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Mechanical%20Interfaces%20And%20Opening%20Quantities) preparation closed533 at11:35:17, final2e604fc2 (44,079 bytes), after one critique/response, twelve independently verified parent revisions and two narrow PM532 collar fixes. Home is now08f8dde6 and Information9ca194c2; the other ten retain530 revisions. Counts/owner branches are unchanged.
- [Campaign Evidence And State Crosswalk36](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Campaign%20Evidence%20And%20State%20Crosswalk) closed545 at11:49:32, final70e004e9 (28,144 bytes), after one critique/response and PM integration. It maps 8 existing chains,15 scenes and26 evidence INDEX entries—not26 new objects or single captures—with7 host variants,5 personal variants and2 Regional25 orders. Optional parent tags were declined; no handoff remains. Lead stopped36 at closeout; PM36 remains STOPPED. Lead’s current38 administrative assignment is separate.
- Scope and development handoff refresh37 ([Production Scope](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Production%20Scope); [Development And Validation Handoff](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Development%20And%20Validation%20Handoff)) closed550 at12:05:47 after response549 at11:58:19, ONE critique547 and independent factual verification. Final Production68db46ea/Handoff59945901,21,243/27,529 bytes; both Systems STOPPED. The14–26 role-hour allowance at response549 included37 response/disposition4–8 plus coherence10–18. With37 closed, only **10–18 role-hours for coherence/repair disposition** remains forward work. M4 **350–590 role-hours** and the future packet **289–490 role-hours /5–8 working weeks** are low-confidence conditional estimating proposals, not logged labor or development authority.
-
- [V1 Readiness38](/Hold%20The%20Flood/V1%20Readiness) assigned551–553 for the existing final coherence/readiness obligation. Lead557 and Systems555 are STOPPED after their38 submissions; Reviewer558 is WORKING on the ONE combined critique after criteria554. Receiving558 and the full contract were verified at12:14:39/44. Receiving/full contracts were verified at12:06:22/27 for Lead,12:06:18/22 for Systems and12:07:16/21 for Reviewer. Lead owns only the new administrative V1 Readiness article; Systems supplies a local factual audit for the same38 outcome; Reviewer saved independent criteria554 and is conducting ONE critique of the stopped submission and audit. Draft13:30 (12:45–14:30), reviewed16:00 (14:30–18:00); no new game content or scope.
+
- [V1 Readiness38](/Hold%20The%20Flood/V1%20Readiness) assigned551–553 for the existing final coherence/readiness obligation. Lead560 is WORKING on the ONE response to critique559, incorporating the submitted557 assessment and555 factual audit. Receiving was verified at12:35:14.291 Jerusalem and the full559/560 reading at12:35:31.379; one courier was delivered. Reviewer is STOPPED after559; Systems remains STOPPED after555. Lead owns only the administrative V1 Readiness article. PM is preparing bounded local parent repairs; game sources remain unchanged and no parent ownership transfer is implied. Response13:15 (12:50–14:00), reviewed16:00 (14:30–18:00); no new game content or scope.
- Five unanswered owner questions and unadopted intake407 remain. All original roles resumed490. M3 now targets14 September (11–18), low confidence; M2/M4 remain unchanged. The144–247 allowance remains dated. Yesterday’s F1.14 drafts were not published.
## Open and closed outcomes
@@ 152,7 152,7 @@
|35|[Mechanical Interfaces And Opening Quantities35](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Mechanical%20Interfaces%20And%20Opening%20Quantities)|Closed|Reviewed conditional interfaces/quantities; no gameplay validation|9Sep11:35:17 closeout533, final2e604fc2|One critique/response, twelve-parent alignment and two532 fixes verified. Mechanical35/ten parents Systems STOPPED; Home/Information PM STOPPED. Owner choices and M4 variants remain|
|36|[Campaign Evidence And State Crosswalk36](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Campaign%20Evidence%20And%20State%20Crosswalk)|Closed|Finite8-chain/15-scene crosswalk;26 evidence INDEX entries, not26 new objects|9Sep11:49:32 closeout545, final70e004e9 (28,144 bytes)|One critique/response and PM integration verified;7 host variants/5 personal variants/2 Regional25 orders. PM owns36 STOPPED; Lead STOPPED. Optional parent tags declined; no transfer needed. Prior reviewed14:00 target achieved|
|37|Scope and development handoff refresh37 ([Production Scope](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Production%20Scope); [Development And Validation Handoff](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Development%20And%20Validation%20Handoff))|Closed|Reviewed scope/packet planning proposal; no development authority|9Sep12:05:47 closeout550; response54911:58:19; final68db46ea/59945901|ONE critique/response and exact factual verification.21,243/27,529 bytes; both Systems STOPPED. Prior15:00 reviewed target achieved; only10–18 coherence role-hours remains forward|
-
|38|[V1 Readiness38](/Hold%20The%20Flood/V1%20Readiness)|Open — ONE critique558 underway|Previously planned final coherence/readiness assessment and supporting audit; no new game scope|Lead557/Systems555 STOPPED after submissions; Reviewer558 WORKING, receiving/full contract verified|Lead administrative draft13:30 (12:45–14:30); Systems support13:00 (12:30–14); Reviewer criteria12:45; ONE critique, at most ONE response, reviewed16:00 (14:30–18). PM decides M2/M3|
+
|38|[V1 Readiness38](/Hold%20The%20Flood/V1%20Readiness)|Open — ONE response560 underway|Previously planned final coherence/readiness assessment and supporting audit; no new game scope|Lead560 WORKING on ONE response; Reviewer STOPPED559; Systems STOPPED555; receiving/full reading verified|Response13:15 (12:50–14:00), reviewed16:00 (14:30–18). PM prepares bounded local parent repairs and decides M2/M3; sources remain unchanged|
## Recent delivery timeline
@@ 190,13 190,13 @@
|[Mechanical Interfaces And Opening Quantities35](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Mechanical%20Interfaces%20And%20Opening%20Quantities)|Preparation closed533 at11:35:17; final2e604fc2; prior13:00 target achieved|Use reviewed interfaces/quantities and exact aligned parents; no second review or phase authorization|
|[Campaign Evidence And State Crosswalk36](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Campaign%20Evidence%20And%20State%20Crosswalk)|Preparation closed545 at11:49:32, final70e004e9; prior14:00 target achieved|Use accepted8-chain/15-scene/26-index crosswalk in whole-v1 coherence. PM owns36 STOPPED; no parent transfer needed|
|Scope and development handoff refresh37 ([Production Scope](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Production%20Scope); [Development And Validation Handoff](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Development%20And%20Validation%20Handoff))|Closed550 at12:05:47, final68db46ea/59945901; Systems STOPPED|Use accepted scope/packet in38; no second37 review|
-
|[V1 Readiness38](/Hold%20The%20Flood/V1%20Readiness)|Lead557/Systems555 STOPPED after submissions; Reviewer558 WORKING, receiving/full contract verified. One administrative result with local factual support|Draft13:30 (12:45–14:30), support13:00 (12:30–14), criteria12:45, reviewed16:00 (14:30–18)|
+
|[V1 Readiness38](/Hold%20The%20Flood/V1%20Readiness)|Lead560 WORKING on ONE response; Reviewer STOPPED559; Systems STOPPED555; receiving/full reading verified. One administrative result with local factual support|Response13:15 (12:50–14:00), reviewed16:00 (14:30–18); PM prepares bounded local parent repairs|
|Additional proposal intake|Both full pages read; explicitly unadopted|Track authorship and assess protected retreat/next-shift meeting before integrating|
|Shared integration04|Preparation closed518 at11:07:24 after accepted [Death Shift And Rescue Continuity](/Hold%20The%20Flood/Death%20Shift%20And%20Rescue%20Continuity) candidate577236e7 and eleven verified parent alignments|All affected parents and Continuity STOPPED under current533 ownership. No further04 review; owner-dependent branches and remaining whole-v1 interfaces stay explicit|
-
|Original Claude Lead/Reviewer|Original roles resumed490; identities unchanged|Lead557 and Systems555 submitted/STOPPED. Reviewer558 WORKING after verified receiving/full contract; criteria554 complete; earlier35/36/37 reviews complete|
+
|Original Claude Lead/Reviewer|Original roles resumed490; identities unchanged|Lead560 WORKING on ONE response after verified receiving/full reading. Reviewer STOPPED559; criteria554 and ONE critique complete. Earlier35/36/37 reviews remain complete|
|Additional specialist setup|No extra agent required today; no new sessions created|Technical/production candidate10Sep only for concrete independent handoff scope; optional campaign integration only for an actual gap|
-
Current ownership through558: Lead owns only the new administrative V1 Readiness article for38. Systems552 has local factual-support work and no new article ownership. Reviewer553 criteria554 are complete; ONE critique558 is underway; Lead557 and Systems555 are STOPPED after their38 submissions; Reviewer558 is WORKING on the ONE combined critique after criteria554. Receiving558 and the full contract were verified at12:14:39/44. All existing game articles retain their STOPPED owners, including Systems’ two37 parents, Mechanical35 and ten mechanical parents; PM36/Home/Information remain STOPPED. Any actual parent repair requires a later explicit transfer; none is assumed here.
+
Current ownership through560: Lead owns only the administrative V1 Readiness article and is WORKING on the ONE response560. Systems552 local factual support was submitted555; Systems is STOPPED and holds no new article ownership. Reviewer553 criteria554 and ONE critique559 are complete; Reviewer is STOPPED. PM prepares bounded local parent repairs, with no shared source change or ownership transfer from draft work. Existing game articles retain their STOPPED owners, including Systems’ two37 parents, Mechanical35 and ten mechanical parents; PM36/Home/Information remain STOPPED. Any actual parent repair requires explicit transfer.
